Words that make love come unDonne

by Catherine Malpass

John Donne – lawyer, priest, poet – essentially an incredibly clever man. This sharp intelligence shines through in his poetry, characterised by its lofty eloquence and unexpected yet somehow perfectly chosen conceits. But beneath this immaculately polished exterior lie raw and often volatile emotions. In reading Donne’s poetry, we are treated to an insight into the musings of the man himself, not merely the persona of Donne as a poet.

Donne’s collection of Songs and Sonnets reveal his all-too-human tendency to over-think. His musings on love in particular have remained continuously fascinating, not least because many of his private meditations reflect thoughts we still have today. Donne famously stated that, “I will have no such readers as I can teach”. Whilst Donne’s poetic prowess is amazing on an intellectual level, it is his emotional subject matter that readers most easily engage and empathise with.

Donne’s own love story is one of many complications. Some of his richest poetry concerns Anne More, a woman that inspired in Donne a combination of both spiritual and earthly love. However, the poet married Anne against the wishes of her family, an action that effectively was career suicide for him. Donne’s relationship was eventually accepted, yet he was forced to lived a life of poor economic existence as a consequence of his forbidden feelings. Possibly Donne’s most apt comment on the affair was simply: “John Donne, Anne Donne, Undone.”

The stages of this love story can be traced through Donne’s poetry. The relationship’s origins can easily be imagined in the famous opening lines of “The Good-Morrow”: “I wonder, by my troth, what thou and I did, till we loved?”An existence without love cannot be imagined, as the strength of the poet’s feeling now defines him. The emotions are all-encompassing, powerful enough to “[make] one little room an everywhere”.

In “The Undertaking”, Donne discusses his forbidden love. For the poet, marrying Anne is, a “braver thing than all the Worthies did” – the Worthies being the nine supreme heroes of history. Donne encourages his readers to understand the paradoxical nature of his relationship: the elation and compulsion of love alongside the shame and frustration of its illicit nature. Whilst Donne boasts of his self-control and prowess, he is simultaneously aware of his limitations as a human being. The clandestine nature of the love affair may make Donne appear a more courageous man, yet it undoubtedly drains him.

One of Donne’s most didactic poems is “A Lecture upon the Shadow”, forming the last leg in the journey that is his relationship. Here, Donne becomes love’s veteran, displaying a more detached view on the feeling of love. The poem lacks the immediacy of “The Good Morrow” or the defiant nature of “The Undertaking”, as its tone seems to be predominantly one of resignation. For the poet, “love is a growing or full constant light, and his first minute after noon is night.” The seasoned speaker, through the symbolism of shadows, appreciates the disguises that lovers will put on in the first hours of their relationship to impress one another. At midday, the shadows fade as pure love is reached, only for these shades to lengthen again as night beckons. Donne, writing later on in his career, seems to have learnt love’s lessons. This more cynical outlook implies a broad range of perspectives on love – Donne’s writing covers its joys and pains, illusions and realities.

This journey through one man’s intense self-analysis leads to an understanding of the paradoxical nature of romantic relationships. Each love story follows a similar prototype, yet has its own unique imprint – and both of these viewpoints are explored in Songs and Sonnets. As Shakespeare, one of Donne’s contemporaries, once stated in A Midsummer Night’s Dream: “The course of true love never did run smooth”. This aphorism well describes Donne’s tragic love affair, which, being immortalised in his poetry remains accessible to readers today.

Photograph: Anni Pekie