The Week Force: Should scientists be responsible for getting it wrong?

by Jonny Bowers

Firstly I would like to apologise for not getting one of these up for the last two weeks; I came down with a particularly nasty bout of Freshers Flu but thankfully am all better now.

Many of you will remember the news that broke on the morning of the 6th April 2009. The historic town of L’Aquila in central Italy was flattened by an earthquake measuring 6.3 on the Richter scale.

Just six days before this, on 31st March, a meeting of six of Italy’s top earthquake specialists had been convened to reassure the population of L’Aquila about the increasing number of small tremors that they had been experiencing.

The scientists claimed that at the meeting they erred on the side of caution greatly, one saying “I attended the press conference after the meeting on 31st March and said earthquakes were not predictable and nothing could be excluded”.

The citizens of L’Aquila heeded the advice of the authorities and as a result when the earthquake hit, many were unprepared.

Just before the meeting however, Bernardo De Bernardinis, the deputy head of Italy’s civil protection agency, and one of the politicians behind the meet, gave an interview to the press stating that the tremors were helping the earth release pent-up energy and called the situation ‘favourable’. The citizens of L’Aquila heeded the advice of the authorities and as a result when the earthquake hit, many were unprepared.

Last week the six scientists, along with Bernardinis, were sentenced to 6 years imprisonment for the manslaughter of the 308 people who died in the tragedy. The general reaction of the scientific community has been one of horror, whilst the residents of the destroyed city feel that justice has been done.

The scientists were convicted, say the residents, not for getting the science wrong, but for providing unreasonable assurances that no earthquake would come. Even if the main assurances came from the politician, one resident said, “no one denied what he said”. The scientists are guilty of manslaughter by failing to act, and providing “incomplete, imprecise, and contradictory information”.

This is just the latest, and possibly the most serious, incident of scientists being used as tools in politics and then taking the flak if things go wrong. Reportedly the scientists in L’Aquila were under pressure from the government to ‘calm things down’, so they did. By interfering with the science, the wrong verdict was reported and now the scientists are being held responsible.

But in addition to the question of politics and blame, a simpler question is here; should scientists be held responsible for wrong predictions? In a field like earthquake prediction, the science is incomplete and in the majority of cases the only true answer is, “We are unsure”; yet, experts are put under pressure to provide practical advice and it is only natural that they will occasionally be wrong.

This can have catastrophic effects and it’s only natural that people involved will be angry, but should the scientists really be liable? Surely it is better to allow them to continue to work, learn from their mistakes and make steps forward, after all, is that not how science is meant to work?

The Italian scientists reportedly plan to appeal against the conviction, whilst the large scale reconstruction of L’Aquila is set to begin in early 2013.

Photograph: RaBoe/Wikipedia