Woolwich: how we respond will define our society
The chilling footage of a man, his hands covered in blood as he argues with a Scout Club leader, exemplifies the brutality of modern terrorism. The tragic murder of Drummer Lee Rigby was intended to bring the battlefields of Afghanistan to the peaceful suburban streets of London: the killers wanted to divide us.
“We are going to start a war in London tonight”, one of the men holding a meat cleaver was reported to have told a passer-by.
At first it seemed like they might have done just that: Faith Matters, which runs a helpline, reported a large increase in anti-Muslim incidents after the murder. This was not characterised by widespread violence – an investigation by The Telegraph failed to find a single case where any individual Muslim was hospitalised by a racially-aggravated assault – but the rise in incidents of aggression towards Muslims is undeniable.
This is a moment to condemn the attackers and all they stand for, but also a time for reflection, as our response to Woolwich will reflect the society that we wish to live in.
The EDL took to the streets under the guise of patriots, claiming to be the opponents of a religion that “runs counter to all we hold dear in our British liberal democracy”. Yet these vile extremists have done more than anyone to taint the image of the St George’s Cross, which has now replaced the Union Flag as the symbol of intolerance and bigotry in Britain.
What this attack has revealed is not a war between religions or groups in society, but between two competing interpretations of national identity – two different visions of Britain. Those on the Far Right appropriate our national symbols in an attempt to achieve a society based on xenophobia and hatred; it is our responsibility to wrest this power from their hands.
Meanwhile intolerant forces are taking control of the identity debate in mainstream politics: “The Muslims are breeding ten times faster than us… I don’t know at what point they reach such a number that we are no longer able to resist their demands”.
Yet another ignorant EDL member surely? No, this statement came from a UKIP peer – Lord Pearson of Rannoch – who currently sits in the House of Lords.
Indeed, surveys have consistently shown that Muslims claim to feel more British than most other ethnic groups – including white Britons themselves. This makes the idea that Muslims represent a subversive threat to society all the more ridiculous.
Yet this particular intolerant view of British identity is at the heart of UKIP policy: the “Pocket Guide to Immigration” – which has since been withdrawn due to the controversy it generated – spoke of the need to “end support for multiculturalism and promote one, common British culture”.
UKIP is not an extremist party, yet many of its supporters appear to support a similar message espoused by the Far Right. A YouGov survey of UKIP and BNP members found that both groups tended to have similar attitudes to Muslims.
85% of UKIP supporters surveyed agreed that Islam posed a “serious danger to western civilisation”, while the BNP score was only three points higher. Over three-fifths (64%) would be “bothered a lot” by the presence of an Islamic institution in their community, compared to a national average of 31%.
When you consider that these statistics represent the supporters of a party that could enter government in a coalition with the Conservatives in 2015 it is hard not to be concerned.
There is a wider issue here though: in Britain, and especially England, strong assertions of patriotism are often considered unfashionable, as they are seen to contradict the idea of a multicultural society.
People are frustrated by this, as indicated in the UKIP 2013 local manifesto:
“Children are taught to be ashamed of our past, multiculturalism has split our society, political correctness is stifling free speech”.
This lack of debate has created a vacuum into which have stepped groups such as the BNP and EDL, who currently dominate the identity debate and contribute to the idea that patriotism is a negative phenomenon.
The Woolwich attack has not – at least in the short term – dramatically increased support for these organisations. A recent Survation poll showed that support for the EDL has actually dropped after the attack, with 6% saying they would consider joining the group after the murder compared to 9% the previous year.
Yet this does not mask the need for us as a nation to formulate a positive conception of national identity that does away with the intolerant ideas espoused by the Far Right.
Take the example of the members of the York Mosque who responded to the arrival of the EDL by making cups of tea for the protesters – a characteristically British way of resolving conflict that undermines any idea of non-integration.
So as we think of the family of Lee Rigby, led us also consider what kind of a country we want to live in. It is time to wrest the identity debate out of the hands of extremists and promote our own positive idea of who we are as a nation.
Photograph: Gavin Lynn

