A well-deserved 4-star rating for ‘The History Boys’

TheHistoryBoys3

By Niall Oddy

One of the many curious aspects of doing a first degree at Durham and then staying for postgraduate work is discovering plays you saw, say, four years ago, return to the stage. Such was the case with the recent production of The History Boys, which I attended with the memory of a superb performance in 2009 still relatively vivid in my mind.

That version was, in my opinion, distinguished for two chief reasons: the novel use of local adult actors to play the roles of the elder teachers and an amazing soundtrack of 80s tunes to titillate the audience during scene changes (surely nothing exists that cannot be improved by the addition of Depeche Mode’s Enjoy the Silence). I presumed that Bad Seed Productions’ offering would not repeat these triumphs and I assumed that it would be poorer for it.

TheHistoryBoys4On the second, crucial point, I was wrong. The lethargy of a laborious scene change was avoided by retaining throughout the same set, a classroom.  Not only did this preserve the energy of the piece, but it was entirely appropriate and meaningful in a play that is framed as flashback, in which the schoolroom is a remembered, imagined space; a site of memory.

And the youth of the performers did not detract from the quality of the production. Sophia Harrop’s comportment and costume combined to create the illusion of a much older woman.  The same applied to Will Hannam in the central role of Hector. After a nervy start, with a few issues of diction, he settled gloriously into his character and was thoroughly convincing as the sixty-year-old eccentric.

When it comes, the climax is a veritable punch in the guts. I was not expecting to be moved.

He had to be, for The History Boys is Hector’s tragedy. It is a funny play, but wrapped up inside all of the comedy is catastrophe.  After Hector’s indiscretions with his pupils are revealed, the doom weighs heavily, visibly, on Hannam. He is notably, poignantly, absent on the day the boys receive their Oxbridge examination results.  And when it comes, the climax is a veritable punch in the guts. All because Hannam made us care. Having seen a production before, as well as the successful film adaptation, I was not expecting to be moved. Yet I was.

TheHistoryBoys5The Headmaster (Freddie Herman) was the one aged member of staff who did not look much older than the boys, unfortunately. But did it matter? Not one bit. He was a real hoot, a big hit with the audience, a dab hand at comic delivery.

The rather trite adage ‘the key to acting is reacting’ is appropriate for The History Boys as it is a play that has the potential to founder should the boys lack chemistry. In this production, they functioned as a slick team, feeding off one another and reacting accordingly to create a lively, jesting atmosphere.  Xander Drury stood out, despite his limited role, but the greatest acclaim must go to the charming Callum Kenny whose abilities and self-assurance allowed him to master the character of the gay, Jewish Posner. His rendition of a scene from Brief Encounter was especially exquisite; had I closed my eyes I would have thought that I was in the presence of Celia Johnson herself.

TheHistoryBoys2A tale of a group of youngsters trying to get into Oxbridge, The History Boys was always going to be apt for a Durham audience. This production was done tremendously well, with a cast that effectively executed Alan Bennett’s glorious script. It was deserving of the full house that came out to see it.

Photographs: Rose Innes