Women in the Church: a blind spot in Christianity
By Edward Stroud
A woman’s place in the Church is not merely a woman’s issue. It is a human issue, and a Christian issue. I write this as someone who is committed to the Church. It is my view that this is meaningful critique, because it is the Church on a ground which it can engage with.
During Durham Inter-Collegiate Christian Union (DICCU)’s forum a little while ago on whether to make structural changes to their leadership and introduce co-presidency rather than having a vice president and president, a number of the participants in the forum were alarmed at the possibility of a woman and a man leading on the same level. While it is important to make clear that DICCU in no way disallows women from positions of leadership, these opinions raise important, wider issues about attitudes in the Church towards women.
Women must be given a place of respect in the Church and that this place of respect should entail the same ability to lead and represent communities and churches as any male might. I apologise that the previous sentence might sound so patronising. Indeed to my mind this is obvious. However, the debate is such that my position needs to be made explicit.
As I mentioned above this is not just an issue which should only concern women, it is a human issue. It speaks of half the population who have been muted. Fighting this kind of oppression and repression is part of what it is to be human, not solely the domain of the downtrodden.
The harsh truth is for all the beauty of the Church, and the incredible things that it has written and produced in the past two millennia, it has failed to give a voice to women in the way in which it has started to do in the past century, with the ordination of women.
This is not just an issue which should only concern women, it is a human issue
Yet women are still excluded. For instance women are still refused ordination in the Catholic Church and a recent vote for women to be allowed to become Bishops in the Anglican Church failed. Having said this, it should be noted that Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby fully supports women bishops, and there is a sense that this will become a reality soon.
In the discussion we need to be careful not to demonise those who are opposed to the ordination of women. Such action prevents meaningful conversation, rather than resolving an issue crying out for resolution.
This is a blind spot in the Church, those who opposed it are merely blind to this injustice.
Indeed there are often sophisticated metaphysical, ontological or exegetical reasons why the ordination of women is opposed. It is not my plan to confront these here; rather I will simply look at the results of excluding women in this way. From this I will look at what it means to lay claim to the name of Christ.
This is a blind spot in the Church, those who opposed it are merely blind to this injustice
I proceed by looking at the testimony of two members of the Church, hoping that concrete examples give more traction to my argument than vague polemics.
The first testimony is that of Daphne Hampson, a post-Christian theologian currently a Professor at Oxford. She writes of a time when she was part of the Church and working towards women’s ordination in the 1970s. During this time she felt that the Church placed her identity in powerlessness. For her, a priest telling her to look to Christ’s sufferings suggested no more than that she should put up with “a basic denial of justice”.
Regardless of your theological, philosophical or sociological position the undeniable fact is that the workings of the Church have made women like Daphne Hampson feel marginalised, and uncared for. Indeed Daphne Hampson has left the Christian Church because of this experience.
This is not because the Church is evil. Indeed when instances of this happen it is because the Church is not present. Nor is it because the Christian God is ambivalent about women, this blindspot is human not divine.
To add to this, the other testimony I will look at is a short passage written by Elisabeth Johnson, a Christian Theologian. She writes that: “the glory of God is woman, all women, every woman everywhere, fully alive. Wherever women are violated, diminished, have their life drained away, God’s glory is dimmed and put at historical risk: hence sexism is religiously unconsciousable”.
This is not because the Church is evil. Indeed when instances of this happen it is because the Church is not present
The place of women in the Church is a human issue and a Christian issue because in proposing that a woman or anyone should put up with ‘a basic denial of justice’ one is arguing something against both what it is to be human and what it is to be a Christian. The Church cannot fulfill its role as bringing all human beings into a community of love while, half of that community is told that it is inadequate. This point deserves to be laboured: the teachings and practice of the Church, an organisation committed to justice and the flourishing of human beings are contributing to a denial of justice. Put more humanly, this suffocates the very being of women as a limit is set on their potential.
In laying claim to Jesus Christ, the Church lays claim to equality between men and women, an equality which does not abolish sexual difference, but recognises that “women are equally created in the image and likeness of God, equally redeemed by Christ, equally sanctified by the Holy Spirit; women are equally involved in the ongoing tragedy of sin and the mystery of grace, equally called to mission in this world, equally destined for life with God in glory” (Johnson, She who is). Indeed one might add equal in leading God’s Church, for it is God’s not man’s.
Photograph: Teach46

