Why Rooney is not captaincy material

Catatan Bola

By Will Freemont-Barnes

The search for Manchester United’s next captain begins. Nemanja Vidic’s impending departure from Old Trafford not only leaves the club with a gaping hole in the centre of defence, but facing a crisis of leadership on the field.

Assuming that fellow ageing defenders Rio Ferdinand and Patrice Evra follow close behind out of the exit door, options for the captaincy are limited.

Robin van Persie, while eminently qualified, is the wrong side thirty, Darren Fletcher is not an automatic starter, and Phil Jones lacks the experience to lead one of the biggest clubs in the world.

And then there is Wayne Rooney. All the speculation over the past week is that he is in pole position to receive the armband on a permanent basis, having been overlooked previously when the role was available.

That was when Alex Ferguson was in charge; this is a different regime, overseen by a manager with whom Rooney enjoys a much healthier working relationship.

Rooney has already taken on a greater role since David Moyes took over last summer, apparently now kept informed of United’s transfer policy and being asked for his own opinion.

It is a far cry from his situation a year ago, when he was omitted from the starting eleven for a crucial Champions League knockout match against Real Madrid.

Such was Rooney’s frustration at being played out of position, or left on the bench, to accommodate van Persie, that he agitated for a transfer to Chelsea.

The manager may have changed, but United’s star player remains as problematic as ever.

The manager may have changed, but United’s star player remains as problematic as ever

At the age of 28, this is the stage of his career that he should be assuming greater responsibilities, but there is no evidence that Rooney is capable of captaining the club as it goes through this transitional period.

Even after a decade at United, his attitude still leaves a lot to be desired. This is a player who has twice sought a move away from Old Trafford, only to commit his future after receiving assurances about United’s ambitions, not to mention a substantial pay increase.

We should not exactly be surprised by Rooney’s avaricious behaviour. After all, this is someone who wore a t-shirt bearing the words “once a blue, always a blue”, right before jumping at the first opportunity to leave Everton in 2004.

Although he is by no means alone in chasing and getting the most lucrative deal possible, it seems unreasonable that Rooney’s lack of loyalty should be rewarded with the captaincy.

Furthermore, with United currently cut adrift of the Champions League qualification spots, there is no guarantee that he will remain at a club heading in the wrong direction.

It is not just Rooney’s ill treatment of United which makes him an unsuitable choice as club captain. For all his technical gifts as a player, there are still significant doubts about his temperament and leadership skills.

His indiscipline has become a defining characteristic of his personality, from the dangerous stamp on Ricardo Carvalho at the 2006 World Cup in Gelsenkirchen, to the impetuous kick of a Montenegro defender which excluded him from the first two games of Euro 2012.

Anyone who thinks these isolated incidents of mindlessness are behind him should consider the eight yellow cards he has picked up already this season, including an altercation with Jordan Mutch from which he somehow escaped without a red card despite clattering into the Cardiff midfielder.

An essential aspect of the captaincy role is managing to lead your team-mates, yet Rooney is barely to control himself.

Giving him an official leadership role would presumably act as an added pressure, which seems unwise for a player who struggles to cope on big occasions at the best of times.

Particularly on international duty, Rooney has been unable to cope under the burden of expectation, failing to perform at his best in any major tournament since Euro 2004.

Alex Ferguson and Roy Hodgson are both fairly good judges of a player, and neither thought it appropriate to make Rooney captain for club or country.

Rooney is unquestionably the finest English player of his generation, as well as the most talented player at Manchester United, but it does not necessarily follow that he would be the ideal captain.

David Moyes has a big decision to make; making Rooney the senior player in the dressing room might seem the perfect way of reinvigorating him as he approaches the peak of his powers, yet it would be a risk move because of his attitude and divisive personality.

Leaving Rooney to concentrate on his own game would be a far more sensible approach.

Photograph: Catatan Bola