Winding Words: The Cathedral Part 16

by Katie Lumsden

On my last night in this beautiful ruin, my last night in all this wonder, my last night in Hugh’s cathedral, we sit by the fire and I feel strange. He doesn’t speak. He’s barely said a word all day, barely even cast his eyes in my direction. I wonder if he’s gone back to disliking me, if he’ll be glad when I leave. The thought doesn’t even make me angry. I almost think you couldn’t get angry much, not really, in a place like this.

“Tomorrow,” I say, “I’ll leave you in peace.”

He turns from the fire, and he looks afraid, pale and scared like the first time I ever saw him. He frowns, and repeats, vaguely, the word “Peace…”

Silence again. I don’t like this silence, because beside me sits a ghostly bizarre amazing man who I’ll never see again.

“I’ve been trying to work it out,” I say. “I’ve been trying to work out which option would make me a happy coward and which would make me brave and miserable.”

He gives me no reply.

“You never did tell me, Hugh, how you got to be both.”

Nothing happens for a few moments, for a few minutes even, and then he turns to me, frowning, and nods with a slow thoughtful movement. “I do not mind telling you,” he says. “I would mind telling anyone else, but not you… besides, if you really wanted to know you could find out when you leave. Everything was recorded, and with titled families it is not easy to prevent scandals spreading.” He hesitates, and I almost think he’ll never go on. Then he sits up straighter. “I suppose it was fourteen years ago, though to me it is another life time away. I was twenty-three when my parents died. They were murdered – shot.”

“My God,” I mutter.

“I told you before that I loved my parents, and it is true. They had always been kind to me, and they had always cared, and I was not… I was not comfortable with anyone outside of our family. You see, this… this fear, this dislike of people, was something I have always had. They sent me to counsellors and tried to help me in every way they could, and though it did nothing, they were kind to me and they loved me. When they were killed, I… I had a breakdown, I suppose. I had a fit and ended up in… in a mental home.” He breathes in deeply. I stare at him as he speaks. “When I got out,” he says, “it was six months later, and the trial had just ended. They convicted a man who worked for my father and he had just begun his twenty-five years in prison… The problem was then that… that I knew that man had not done it, and I knew who had.” He shifts, uneasily, on the stones. “I chose not be a coward. I chose to be brave instead, and I gave up the murderer to the authorities.”

He’s silent for so long that I feel I should speak. I say, in as soft a voice as I can, “that was the right thing to do.”

“Yes… But it made me miserable anyway. Because, you see, Isabelle, the man who did it, the murderer – it was my brother.”

I stare at him, wide-eyed, and I think, I’d run, too, and I’d hide, if I was him. I’d take refuge in a ruined cathedral if my world was shattered like that.

“I used to love my brother,” says Hugh. “When we were growing up, he and I were best friends. He was six years older than me and I thought he was the most amazing person in all the world. I loved him a great deal better than I loved my parents. When people at school thought I was strange, my brother took me out with his older friends and stuck up for me when they picked on me. When my parents took me to psychiatrists, he told me I was fine without them. He had thousands of friends and everybody loved him, and I worshipped him.

“My brother, he loved money, a lot. Flash cars, flash clothes, flash parties, houses in other countries, and he never worked a day in his life. The only thing he loved more than money was women. He had various… girlfriends, I suppose – or mistresses, maybe, I should say – and he was always furnishing them with gifts and incomes. He was rich, and people were drawn to him, and he thought from a young age that if he was not rich or did not show it, people would not be drawn to him, and they would not love him either. So he kept on spending fortunes over and over again.

“He was badly in debt, and my parents refused to give him any more money, so he… he shot them both through the head so he could inherit their title and their wealth.” Hugh winces when he stops speaking, and despite the growing dark I can see tears on his cheeks. “The irony is that my parents and everyone I ever knew always thought I was the unstable one… in the end it was my brother who turned out to be half mad.” He sighs. “The second trial after I gave evidence was the worst thing I have ever been through. My brother, he… he claimed that I had done it, that I was mad and had done it, and threw back all my life at me, all the psychiatrists, everything like that, to try and put me in prison instead of him, or in an asylum. But I had evidence, and when they convicted my brother, he swore at me and told me to go to hell, and told me that I had betrayed him… But you see, Isabelle, he betrayed me first.”

“What you did was right,” I repeat. I don’t know what else to say.

“After that they stripped my brother of his title and I became Lord Blackmore. I sold everything, and I bought my cathedral, so that I could hide from the world, and hide the world from my sight.  I had never liked people, and after that I lost what little faith in humanity that I ever had.”

“I don’t blame you.” I remember that when I was crying he put his arms around me, so now I move closer to him and put my arm around his shoulder. He looks at me for a moment, and gives a weary smile.

“Now I am coward I am happier,” he says.

“But you’re wrong. Hugh, you’re not a coward at all. To live like you do, to ignore the world, to live for yourself, by yourself, to cope as you do without relying on anyone – that’s brave, Hugh; it’s incredibly brave.”

He stares at me, and he shakes his head. “You think too well of me.”

“I think that’s because I’m actually starting to understand you.”

Hugh’s eyes seem to darken, and he draws away from me, saying, in a murmur, “And tomorrow you are leaving. Who will understand me then?”

 

I can’t sleep. When I open my eyes and look down, Hugh lies on the floor, and I can hear his breathing. He’s asleep. I’m not calm enough for that. Tomorrow I’ll leave, just like he said, and I’ll go back to the village, back to the station, back to London, back to Jack. I can’t decide. I can’t decide what to do, what to be.

New chapter every Monday and Thursday!