Proportion of academics with doctorates is low
The proportion of academic staff with PhDs at UK universities is surprisingly low, according to recent findings published by a professor from Lancaster University.
The report, entitled Academic Staff in UK Higher Education Institutions: Are they fit for purpose? , has revealed that the figure could be as low as 45.7%.
In fact, there are five universities where less than a fifth of academics possess doctorates.
In the most extreme example, only 12.7% of full-time academic staff at Cumbria University have PhDs.
There is, however, a sharp distinction between the data collected from different universities. At the top end of the scale, information compiled by the Higher Education Statistics Authority has shown that 86.31% of full-time staff at Lancaster University have successfully achieved top-level academic qualifications. The figure is almost as high at a number of other British universities.
The University of Durham appears to buck this trend, as data collected by HESA shows that 73.94% of full-time academic staff have doctorates. While this figure drops below 50% when applied to part-time staff, this remains more than twice that of the national average.
Lower levels at some institutions may be explained by the fact that they have only recently acquired university status. At 86% of universities which were established before 1992, over half of the full-time academic staff have doctorate-level qualifications. Only ten universities founded since that date can claim to meet the same standards.
Malcolm Tight, the Lancaster academic who wrote the report, also points out that the data may have been affected by the nature of courses taught at some universities. The focus on vocational subjects at many newer establishments may lead to a different staff profile. Lecturers are more likely to be recruited from those working in the career in question, rather than from a purely academic background.
Tight does add, however, that the level of postdoctoral qualification is “rather low”, even at some of the older, more established universities. Worryingly, he even suggests that the nation’s academics may be “little or no better qualified than those they are teaching.” Indeed, his report emphasises that 11.8% of “academic professionals” have no higher qualification than an undergraduate degree.
Although this figure is not as high at Durham University, some 100 of its 1,190 full-time academic staff hold an undergraduate degree as their highest qualification.
Stephanie Marshall, a Chief Executive for the Higher Education Academy, has commented that, while a PhD is required for attaining an academic position at many universities, it is not necessarily essential. Nor does the lack of one mean that an individual’s teaching approach will be sub-standard.
Marine, an Erasmus student currently living in Durham, is inclined to agree. Having been taught by highly qualified lecturers with little teaching experience in the past, she believes that other aspects also have a role to play.
In her opinion, “the motivation that some teachers have to teach students and to help them in their work is sometimes more important than their qualifications.”

