Will Australia’s referendum finally give indigenous people a voice?

By Alex Thurston

On Saturday, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and his Labor government will be encouraging all Australians to vote yes to altering the constitution to recognise the First Peoples of Australia by establishing an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice. The First Peoples of Australia, also known as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, were the original settlers of Australia before European colonisation. Since then, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders have faced many hardships and injustices such as the loss of traditional culture and homelands, forced removal of children and denial of citizenship rights. They have also been denied access to basic human rights such as health, housing, employment, and education, leading the average Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander to have an average life expectancy 10-17 years less than other Australians.

The average Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander [has] an average life expectancy 10-17 years less than other Australians

The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice body will aim to be an independent, non-binding body that advises to Parliament and government, accountable and transparent, and work alongside previously existing organisations and traditional structures. The members of the Voice will be chosen by the wishes of the aboriginal community. The proposed body will make representations to Parliament and government on relevant matters, and they will be given the powers to make proactive representations in Parliament. Some Australians have voiced confusion over how this might impact the legislative process, as this is a first for indigenous representation; if the referendum is successful, it will be the first advisory body of its kind. But is such apprehension justified?

In an interview, Anthony Dillion, a researcher at Australian Catholic University in Sydney and an indigenous academic and commentator, expressed speculation over how the Voice body will help aboriginal people. Dillon argues that while there are residual negative effects from the colonisation, the immediate cause of current aboriginal disadvantage is that children of aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders are being brought up in disadvantage. Anthony sees this referendum as an instance of self-determination and identity politics which will not help the hundreds of existing indigenous representative bodies at all levels of government.

Some fear that a centralised voice will overlook the needs of regional and remote communities that are already crying out for help tackling devastating social problems. The rhetoric is that action is what is needed rather than more bureaucracy.
Other aboriginal community members are very supportive of the proposed Voice body and see it as a vessel to have their faces, identities, homes, and hardships remembered and not overlooked. They argue that this referendum and an aboriginal body could be the foot in the door for indigenous justice globally, it has the potential to allow for better, greater change to take the stage.
A hinderance in the uptake and attractiveness of the proposed Voice body is that there has been little clarity on what the body will look like and how it will function. Uncertainty understandably makes public and politicians anxious; changing a constitution is a huge affair, and once it is changed it cannot be undone easily. The Voice is not a trial or a pilot, and it is not legislation that can be reversed without a significant shift in public opinion.

This referendum is likely to be a once-in-a-generation opportunity

This referendum is likely to be a once-in-a-generation opportunity for the underrepresented and ill-treated Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders. It is an opportunity that cannot be passed over lightly. The proposed Voice body is very fragile and needs to be nurtured and watered by the aboriginal community and their leaders. If successful, the integrity of the body must be maintained with the vigour and determination that later aboriginal generations would hope. The Voice itself isn’t enough: Parliament and government must not think that their reconciliation for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders is ‘done’ through this body alone. It is the job of the Australian people not to let them forget this.

Image credit: Bidgee via Wikimedia Commons