India’s same-sex ruling: time for Britain to face its colonial past?

By Alex Thurston

India’s Supreme Court recently ruled that it would not recognise same-sex married couples existing under the current laws, but rather that this was a job of Parliament. While this has dashed the hopes of many LGBTQIA+ activists and couples, other community members are recognising that this ruling, while not successful, has given India an opportunity for educating citizens and legislators about homosexuality, as activist Suvir Saran, a celebrity chef, reflects. Following his approach and taking it a step further, a thorough and accurate education of homosexuality and gender fluidity in India needs to start with Britain’s imported and proliferated colonial homophobia.

The Supreme Court’s ruling bars same-sex couples from accessing the same legal benefits attached to matrimony that opposite-sex couples enjoy; these benefits cover adoption applications, insurance, inheritance, and joint bank accounts. Many have argued that the legal barring denotes same-sex couples as second-class citizens in their own community and country, with the legal – and socially implied – prejudice often being a source of harassment and discrimination for LGBTQIA+ persons and couples.

The five-judge constitution bench delivered the verdict on 31 October, with Chief Justice D. Y. Chandrachud speaking and emphasising that queerness as a “natural phenomenon” and expressed concern and warning to the government to ensure that the “queer community is not discriminated against because of their gender identity or sexual orientation.” Justice S. Ravindra Bhat added that LGBTQIA+ couples were not barred for choosing who their life partners are and they able and entitled to celebrate their love and commitment in any way they wish “within the social realm.” However, notwithstanding the positive impact of these speeches, it is yet to be seen just how far government will go in legislating to actually ensure this.

While this court ruling is a halt to the hopeful proliferation of LGBTQIA+ rights in India, it is important to situate this progression within the context of India’s ‘forgotten’ historically accepting and welcoming attitude to homosexuality and gender fluidity.

Many ancient temples… display erotic artwork depicting homosexuality

In India and Ancient India, Hinduism has been the largest religion for more than 4000 years. Hinduism is a vastly intricate religion with a rich genealogy and has been integral in modern India’s formation. Hinduism predates Christianity by over 600 years, but unlike Christianity, Hinduism doesn’t contain any explicit moral condemning for homosexuality nor gender fluidity; instead it varies from a positive to a neutral position. Many ancient temples, such as the Sun Temple and Khajuraho temple, display erotic artwork depicting homosexuality. Even after the Moghul Empire invaded and controlled India from mid 1500s to 1800s, Moghul rulers still tolerated Hindu eroticism and gender variance in Indian culture. Many Mughal artwork and poetry produced from this period contain male homoeroticism. This is a stark comparison to how modern India is arguably considered one of the most conservative countries today. So what happened?

In 1757, Britain took control over swathes of Indian life via economic controls, and in 1885 expanded this further to have complete governance of the country. British colonisation had numerous impacts on India, and one of them was the importation and contamination of homophobia and its proliferation in India. In 1861, homosexuality was criminalised by a law drafted by Thomas Macaulay, who conceptualised it based on anti-sodomy laws that already existed in Britain. Section 377 of Indian Penal Code (IPC) states that: “whoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse against the order of nature… shall be punished with imprisonment for life.” The term “order of nature” was left ambiguous and hence the law could apply to any sexual act that was considered against this order by the British judiciary. While at first not many cases were reported, it had a larger impact on Indian social values, and inspired a ‘purity campaign’, an ideology that aimed to repressed sexual conduct in society.

The queer community still faces today extreme harassment and blackmail

Through the 1990s, despite the spread of colonial homosexual hatred, many Indian writers and directors published films, books, poems, and art about homosexual love and longing. Petitioners, such as Naz Foundation (India) Trust, filed lawsuits and challenged the Delhi High Court over the legalisation of homosexual intercourse. After much hard-fought activism, in 2018 the endeavours of these individuals and organisations were successful as same-sex intercourse was legalised. This was a huge step in the right direction, but for a country who has homosexual status sculpted and carved into holy temples, homosexuality should never have been criminalised, and yet, the queer community still faces today extreme harassment and blackmail which leads to the premature deaths of queer individuals.

This is just one example of Britain’s unjust and murky history of interference in other countries politics and lives through brutal and oppressive colonialism. The complete absence of knowledge of Britain’s active hand in homophobia in India is stark but unfortunately unsurprising. For a country known in popular culture to apologise profusely for minor day-to-day inconveniences, we sure don’t like to apologise or even recognise our unjust historical behaviour when it really counts.

Image credit: Ghoshavijit21 via Wikimedia Commons