Why the DU Go app feels awkward, for now
By Josh Roberts
If you hadn’t noticed by now, Durham University has released a new app for food and drink which offers discounts and rewards across all the cafes and restaurants in University buildings. It’s well-designed, looks nice and has a good user interface. However, for me it has served as an interesting example of when a well-designed digital solution encounters embodied practice and the actual benefits do not materialise as fast as hoped. Think of society as a network; we are all connected through various relationships, however, we are also connected to things and places. Our phones are a perfect example: they mediate many relationships and often provide more interaction than the people around us. Rules govern these relationships. We internalise them and they become part of our embodied practice. Think about the last time you walked down Church Street. Who moves out of the way or who steps into the road is not consciously worked out but becomes a sort of choreographed dance. It is chaotic but patterned and ordered. This is what our daily lives are like, we act based on rules that we are not fully aware of but which affect our lives.
We humans are stubborn. We find it hard to change and adapt to new things; overwriting our habitual behaviour takes effort
So what does that mean for the DU Go app? When you enter a cafe, queue up, order, pay and then wait for your order, you are acting based on internalised rules, as are the people around you and the person serving you at the counter. The person at the counter does the same thing every day. They have learnt to use the register efficiently, navigating the various buttons without having to consider every option at once. It’s a sort of rhythm that they have learnt. But the DU Go app disrupts this: the embodied rhythms and rules that govern this cafe encounter don’t flow in the same way. The app is not part of this system, its rules and practices have not yet been internalised. It disrupts the flow of ordering and paying for your food and drink; you have to remember that you have the app downloaded, you have to open it and ask to scan the QR code, the person at the counter has to remember to ask if you have the app. At every step, the people interacting have to actively fight their internalised rules and habits. Take, for example, the first time I tried to use the app. I had it open and ready to scan but the person at the counter had already pressed the button to pay and left me there to make my drink. I then had to apologise when she returned and awkwardly held up my phone with the QR code and asked to scan it.
The interaction that would normally flow from ordering to paying to waiting to thanking someone for my drink was disrupted by the app. Not because it is badly designed, clunky or disliked, but because it is not how that interaction normally flows. It is different and therefore, a little bit awkward and inefficient.
People who research the adoption of new digital technologies recognise this problem: they acknowledge that technologies have to become embedded within everyday life and the systems around them have to adapt over time. This is true of all innovation: the idea and the practice do not always line up perfectly. We humans are really stubborn. We find it hard to change and adapt to new things, overwriting our habitual behaviour takes effort.
The DU Go app might become embedded into University life, and the normal flow of the cafe interaction may return. However, not every app that is designed to increase efficiency ultimately works out. Consider the MyDurham App which was scrapped before the start of this academic year. But next time you are in a University café, try to keep an eye out for how embedded and adapted the DU Go app has become.
Image: takeaway/ Wikimedia Commons

