Why is the authenticator app detrimental for our degrees?

By Ben Bigwood

Our attention, human attention, is precious. Globally, human attention is a scarce commodity that forms a massive £6 trillion market where focus is bought and sold. Individually, our attention controls how we direct our lives and the outcomes we attain. That personal value is why so many of us are in a desperate struggle, battling for our attention, against this giant, multi-trillion-pound industry, to take control of our own focus and lead our lives with agency. Speaking to many people around me, I know we’re becoming more and more frustrated with this fight for our own attention, yet we’re losing. Our attention is so important, and Durham’s use of the authenticator app effectively aids the attention economy’s assault on our focus, becoming detrimental for our degrees – a policy that needs a change in approach.

My frustration with the authenticator app is that it forces us to take our phones with us; to the library, to our rooms, or to lectures, so we can access certain studying essentials, like Blackboard. Despite many of us knowing the pitfalls of bringing our phones, the authenticator app forces us to carry them around. I’ve spoken to many friends who wish they could leave behind their phones before going to the library so they can get more work done and feel more productive. They’re aware that bringing it means they’re a lot more likely to get distracted, losing productivity, or maybe even the motivation to do the hard work altogether. And there’s exceptionally convincing science on the value of human attention to back up our resentment at having to keep our distraction devices with us.

To understand the value of human attention, you have to accept a fundamental fact of the human brain: We can only consciously focus on one task at a time. Problematically, most teenagers think they can pay attention to multiple forms of media at the same time. When people are tested in a lab to “multi-task”, it turns out what they’re actually doing is rapidly task switching. This is actually very degrading for both the performance of each task and overall cognitive function. 

This so-called “switch cost effect” can deplete as much as 40% of someone’s productive time (e.g. taking an 8-hour summative to 11 hours instead!). Additionally, in 2005, Dr Glenn Wilson was commissioned to perform an informal study on the constant use of technology’s negative impact on IQ. The small study looked at the IQ score of two situations. In the first situation, the workers were being distracted or interrupted by email sounds, vibrations, and phone ringings. And in the second situation, they were not allowed to receive email notifications, phone calls, etc. The study found that the distractions and interruptions caused a 10-point drop in the workers’ IQ (often quoted as, in the short term, double the drop caused by smoking weed!). 

We need Durham to join our side and help us, as students, against the tech giants stealing and hacking our focus

As beings who can only properly focus on one task at a time, having technology repeatedly degrade, switch, and steal our attention is ruining the freedom in our lives. We find it harder to focus on the project in front of us, harder to enjoy a hobby, harder to reflect on how our past choices and actions influenced our current position in life, and harder to remain focused on our long-term goals. That means our success in exams, among many things, is directly linked to the quality of our attention. Therefore, because the authenticator app forces our phones to stay with us, hijacking and degrading our focus, it is undermining the performance of students across our university.

This isn’t our fault either. Multiple companies are competing to steal the most of individuals’ attention and data, they find the best ways to hack our psychology and steal our focus and time. We may want to be focused on what matters to us, but there are trillions of pounds acting against us; and the authenticator requires our phones to follow us around. Of course, I understand that multi-factor authentication (MFA) is essential for security and must remain in some form. However, the detriment it’s causing to our exams cannot remain. 

Finally, what can we ask Durham to do that retains security whilst preserving our minds? In my opinion, Durham needs to implement a system that doesn’t force us to depend on our distraction machines by changing the MFA system, like using a physical hardware token that will generate a code instead of our phones. There may be other possible systems, but we need Durham to join our side and help us, as students, against the tech giants stealing and hacking our focus.

As a postscript, though, given how important it is to preserve our attention, there are a couple solutions you can still use so I don’t leave you feeling hopeless. The best is to switch off or leave your phone behind after you have authenticated (be careful as this expires after a couple hours of inactivity). However, if you do need to bring your phone with you, give it to a friend and tell them to not give it back for the next 2 hours. These will help reduce your access to distractions, maximising your focus, productivity, IQ, and success. We can fight back against the devices leeching off our focus, but it takes a community and Durham’s support.

Image: Yan Krukau via Pexels