Cabinet Secretary forced out from office

By George Hammond

After a gruelling week for No 10 in the aftermath of the latest batch of released Epstein files, Sir Chris Wormald has stepped down as Cabinet Secretary, the most senior position in the civil service, after days of speculation over his potential resignation. Having only replaced The Lord (Simon) Case on the 16th December 2024, his resignation marks the third high profile departure from Downing Street in recent weeks and gives him the unwanted record of the shortest serving Cabinet Secretary in British history.

Despite concerns raised in The Guardian about his record as Permanent Secretary for the Department of Health and Social Care during the Covid-19 pandemic, Sir Keir Starmer chose Sir Chris to be his new Cabinet Secretary despite an independent panel recommending the Permanent Secretary of the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Dame Tamara Finkelstein, for the position. However, whilst Sir Chris was described to Sky News as a “safe choice” by sources in Whitehall, Sir Keir appears to have regretted his choice for the most senior position in the civil service, as ‘anonymous’ briefings soon started circulating about senior figures inability to work with Sir Chris in attempts to paint him as an establishment figure attempting to stop the push through of changes demanded by the Labour government.

However, senior civil servants and trade union figures, such as general secretary of the FDA union Dave Penman, have hit out at such briefings and Sir Chris’ sacking on X and in The Telegraph, accusing Sir Keir of using the civil service as a scapegoat for his own mistakes and failings. Given the months of briefings against Sir Chris, there are questions as to why Sir Keir has waited until now, when he is fighting for the continuation of his premiership, to finally pull the rug out from under the Cabinet Secretary and force him to resign. Questions have further been raised after reporting that Sir Chris is to receive a payout of £260,000 of taxpayer’s money, according to Shadow Minister Claire Coutinho, which civil service officials refused to sign off on until forced to be directed by ministers to administer the payout due to there being “no compelling reasons” for his dismissal.

”Sir Keir appears to have regretted his choice for the most senior position in the civil service, as ‘anonymous’ briefings soon started circulating about senior figures inability to work with Sir Chris in attempts to paint him as an establishment figure attempting to stop the push through of changes demanded by the Labour government”

Additionally, the Prime Minister is now facing backlash from former senior civil servants over his attempts to rush through the appointment of Sir Chris’ successor, who has now been confirmed to be Dame Antonia Romeo. The Lord (Simon) McDonald of Salford, the former Permanent Secretary of the Foreign Office, hit out against Sir Keir in what is an extraordinary move from a former civil servant. Lord McDonald called for a “full process” to be followed to find a new Cabinet Secretary, having overseen allegations against Dame Antonia of bullying and expense fiddling during her time as Consul-General in New York between 2016-2017. What is even more extraordinary is officials hitting back at Lord McDonald, dismissing his intervention as a “desperate attempt from a senior male official whose time has passed.” Another senior Civil Service source told The Telegraph that the intervention had a “whiff of misogyny about it.” This is after briefings in favour of Dame Antonia, due to the fact she is the first female Cabinet Secretary in history amid claims that there is a ‘boys club’ in Downing Street.

However, given that some sources are attempting to claim Sir Chris’ resignation was deserved due to his role over the failed vetting of Lord Mandelson, the media, and Whitehall sources, have been quick to point out Sir Chris was appointed only days before Lord Mandelson. Kemi Badenoch hit out at the Prime Minister tweeting: “The Cabinet Secretary is the latest person Keir Starmer has thrown under the bus to save his own skin.” Additionally, if Sir Keir fails to follow the correct due diligence in appointing Dame Antonia, he will just be opening himself up for further attacks against his failure in appointments which has already put his premiership on very rocky ground. Whilst Sir Keir may hope Sir Chris’ resignation will allow him to put a line under the Mandelson scandal, only time will tell if the Prime Minister will be able to survive.

Image: UK Government via Wikimedia Commons