Why does pension reform face so much resistance in France?

By Eve Mustin

In France, the government’s radical overhaul of the pension system, which plans to raise the age of retirement from 62 to 64, has been met with widespread opposition in the form of protests and public sector strikes. The reform will gradually increase the minimum retirement age to be entitled to a full pension by 3 months every year until 2030, yielding an additional €17.7bn in annual pension contributions. The bill also includes an increase of the minimum pension for low-income workers who have a full career, to 85% of the net minimum wage, or nearly €1,200 per month.

Because of an aging population and declining birth rates, Macron and his government forecast a deficit of €2.6bn in 2023 for the current pension system, making it financially unsustainable in the long run. And Macron is determined to “push ahead with this reform”, refusing to negotiate with trade unions on its key features, such as the increase in retirement age, despite protests. He argues that the reform was a key campaign pledge in his presidential election in 2017, and 2022 re-election, so voters should not be surprised. And since he cannot run for president again, he has nothing to lose by committing to its legislation, despite its unpopularity. It was back in 2019 that Macron first proposed the reform, but he was thus confronted with France’s longest strike action in 50 years. The plans were set aside during the Covid-19 pandemic, and re-introduced on January 10th.

The reform was a key campaign pledge in [Macron’s] presidential election in 2017, and 2022 re-election, so voters should not be surprised

Pension reform certainly has a controversial history in France: in 1981 president François Mitterrand actually cut the retirement age from 65 to 60. In 1993, prime minister Edouard Balladur, under Mitterrand, raised the contribution period required to obtain a full private pension from 37.5 to 40 years. It faced little resistance as it did not affect public sector pensions. However, in 1995, prime minister Alain Juppé’s attempts to change the pension eligibility age for public sector workers resulted in weeks of general strikes, and consequently a government climbdown. In 2003, mass protests erupted after prime minister Jean-Pierre Raffarin introduced a bill to increase the contribution period to 40 years for public workers. President Nicolas Sarkozy raised the age of retirement from 60 to 62 in 2010, but also faced nationwide strikes and demonstrations. In 2014, president Francois Hollande passed the “Touraine” law which planned to extend the contribution period from 42 to 43 years by 2035; Macron plans to bring this forward to 2027.  

So why are the French so opposed to raising the age of retirement? France currently has the lowest retirement age in Europe, and one of the lowest in the world, and perhaps for a reason: the French seem to value their retirement much more so than other countries, which speaks to a wider debate on the importance of work-life balance. According to a survey by Ifop and Fondation Jean-Jaurès, in 1990 60% of French people said work was “very important” in their life, compared to 31% for leisure. Today, only 24% see work as a high priority, and 41% view leisure as very important, so it is not surprising that workers want to retire early.

The French seem to value their retirement much more so than other countries

Furthermore, the working culture in France respects employees’ lives outside of work; in 2017 France introduced the “right to disconnect” law which prohibits employees sending or replying to emails after certain hours. The French enjoy long lunch breaks, a 35-hour working week and 30 days a year of annual leave, compared with 28 in the UK. Overtime is much less common in France, and it’s rare to find any shops open on Sunday. It’s clear that France takes a more relaxed approach to work, so it is understandable that 71% of people, as surveyed by the newspaper Le Figaro, support the current strike action.

France’s opposition parties have also criticised the reform bill for its discrimination against women, as they would have to postpone their retirement later than men in order to reduce the pension imbalance between the sexes. Left-wing groups have also voiced their concerns about an increase in poverty among retirees, including La France Insoumise, whose co-president Manon Aubry said on French radio that “when the legal retirement age is pushed back, at-risk-of-poverty rates increase too, it’s systematic.” She referenced other European countries, such as Germany and the Netherlands, whose at-risk-of-poverty rates grew as a consequence of raising their minimum retirement age. Other critics have argued that the expected deficit in the pension system will either not be as bad as predicted, or can be covered by alternate financing, such as higher taxes for the ultra-wealthy.

The proposed changes to the pension system concern a larger conversation regarding the culture of work in France, and continuous attacks on working class people by the government, in the context of soaring energy prices and a cost of living crisis. France has the third highest debt in the world, which Macron has used as an argument to support pension reform, whereas the opposition believe that welfare cuts would affect the average wage-earner. Although some kind of reform is definitely required to ensure that state pensions remain accessible, Macron’s bill is so unpopular that it might not pass through parliament; last year his party ‘Renaissance’ lost its majority in the National Assembly. Over 20,000 amendments have been proposed by opposition parties, slowing down the legislative process. And so, the pension debate trundles on, in a divisive time for France.

Image: Palamède via Wikimedia Commons