Why does no-one want to drive for Alpine?
By Angus Collingridge
Formula one’s silly season has recently reached chaotic proportions not seen since the 2004 Jenson Button BAR versus Williams dispute. On the 28th of July, Sebastian Vettel took the not entirely unexpected decision to retire from F1 at the end of the season, opening a seat with Aston Martin, and allowing contract carnage to ensue.
In a shock move, Aston Martin announced on the 1st August that they had, at great expense, poached Fernando Alonso from Alpine. In response, Alpine announced the next day that their reserve driver Oscar Piastri would promoted to a race seat for 2023. However, Alpine had not included a quote from Piastri, forgoing traditional protocol, fuelling speculation.
Later that day, Piastri confirmed the speculation that he had not authorised the Alpine announcement, and that he would not be driving for the team next season. Quite a bit of drama, even for F1’s lofty standards.
It is now all but confirmed that McLaren is Alpine’s rival in signing Piastri, but that leaves the Woking-based outfit with a problem. To sign one Aussie, another, Ricciardo, must be removed.
Removing Lando Norris with his consistent performance and long-term contract is of the question, so Ricciardo’s days at the team are numbered. Whilst the eight-time race winner does have a contract for the 2023 season, and has emphasised this, Zak Brown has made it clear that Ricciardo’s performances have been sub-standard.
Quite a bit of drama, even for F1’s lofty standards
It is now expected that McLaren will buy Ricciardo out of his contract and replace him with Piastri. In the space of a week, Alpine successfully managed to lose both the icon of their past success, and their hopeful future superstar. Team principal Otmar Szafnauer has stated that he believes Alpine have a binding contract with Piastri, so a visit to the Contract Recognition Board is likely in the pipeline.
But how did Alpine lose both of their superstars? Firstly, we have to discuss contracts. In negotiations with Alonso, Alpine refused to give him the two years he wanted, overconfident that Alonso could eventually be persuaded.
Instead, Aston Martin snatched him away with a cash-loaded, two-year deal that was more appealing to the Spanish veteran. To add salt to the wound, Alpine only discovered this when Aston Martin announced it, having not been told by Alonso prior.
In the meantime, rumour was Alpine were attempting to secure Piastri a one-year deal at Williams, in preparation for a promotion in 2024. However, due to prolonged negotiations with Alonso, it has been alleged by Piastri’s management team that Alpine missed the deadline to exercise their option on him for 2023, freeing him to enter discussions with McLaren. Two contracts successfully bungled in the space of a few weeks.
Secondly, why were two drivers, at opposite ends of their career, so keen to escape the clutches of the French manufacturer? Since re-joining the sport as Renault in 2016, the Enstone outfit have been the major underperformer of the full-works manufacturer teams, struggling to overcome the financial collapse of Lotus in 2015.
It would be another step back for Daniel, who has never looked further from a championship challenge
A struggle towards the midfield did eventually convince some of their potential, such as Ricciardo in 2018, however, one year at the team was enough to make him jump ship. In recent years the team’s management has been in turmoil with high-profile staff such as Alain Prost and former team principal Cyril Abiteboul being pushed out.
The leadership of CEO Laurent Rossi, and Szafnauer, have made their intentions clear with a 100-race plan, but success is far from guaranteed. Clearly, this was not enough to convince either Alonso or Piastri, as the massive investments by Aston Martin, or stability of McLaren were more enticing.
So where does the French manufacturer go from here? When he is on form, Ricciardo is the best option of a limited bunch, although Mick Schumacher is also an option, amongst others. However, the re-signing of Ricciardo comes with trepidation for both parties.
It would be another step back for Daniel, who has never looked further from a championship challenge. Alpine, on the other hand, run the risk of signing the McLaren spec Ricciardo, low on confidence and pace alike. It is no secret that this new generation of cars, with its low downforce in slow corners, has hurt Ricciardo’s dive-bombing, late-braking driving style more than others, compounding the difficulties he was already having with the McLaren car.
Alpine will have to see what outcomes they get from their contractual dispute, but it is hard to see the team forcing a driver to work with them who clearly does not want to be there. In the meantime, whether Ricciardo re-signs with them or not, there is no doubt that these events have seriously damaged the reputations of both Alpine as an aspiring top team, and Daniel as a future world champion. This could be the beginning of the end of the honey badger in F1, much to the fans’ dismay.
Image: 35mmMan via Flickr

