Freedom of speech – Parlez-vous anglais?

By Sean Hannigan

The hottest topic within Durham University this year has to be freedom of speech or, perhaps, a reduction thereof. Durham’s newest college, my home, South College, was at the centre of the Luckhurst-gate scandal two weeks into my role as Common Room president. This year certainly hasn’t been boring.

The Sun, The Telegraph, The Spectator, The Times, and all the other members of the right-wing press haven’t been dismayed with the latest journalist-turned-story at South College. They have rightly kept an eye on potential curtailments of freedom of speech within academic contexts. Fortunately, however, the situation isn’t quite the culture war nightmare our friends across the Atlantic endure. There are many who wish to contend that freedom of speech is ‘under attack’ in our country, and there exists a widespread concern about ‘being cancelled’ within our society, which is often not without foundation. But these concerns should be nuanced, and freedom of speech clarified, so that the discussion doesn’t quite become the chaos across the water.

In our country, freedom of speech is protected under the broader right of ‘freedom of expression’, including freedom of the press, right to petition government, and freedom of political association. It is reasonably incontestable that it is an essential, foundational bedrock of liberal democratic societies such as our own. Article 11 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights notes that “everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers”. Ideas must be permitted to be discussed, and this right is protected by law. No one has a right not to be offended. Ideas can – perhaps, even, should – shock and challenge those who wish to hear them, even more widely through national and other forms of media which increase the number of people who can access them.

What it does not mean, however, is that anyone has a right to be heard by those who do not wish to hear them. If you are surprised by a speaker, what they say, and perhaps get more (often, less) than you bargained for, you’re well within your rights to recuse yourself and take yourself out of that space. This does not mean they do not have a right to say it. If you were, for example, attending an event and a someone surprised you by making a speech which was not highlighted or publicised in advance (hint, hint), then an outcry, particularly if it is on a controversial topic, is to be expected. Attending a graduation dinner, or public ceremony, or otherwise, you would not expect to be jumped by someone wishing to discuss political and social issues irrelevant to the event you are attending – particularly if they have no link to the event in question.

What it does not mean, however, is that anyone has a right to be heard by those who do not wish to hear them

There is a time and a place, and those times and those places must be reinforced and supported in encouraging the active demonstration of freedom of expression, but don’t be surprised if those cajoled into listening do not hold you in high regard afterwards. A group of veterans, for example, do not need to be lectured on the morality of war at a reunion or memorial event. Women’s rights campaigners, similarly, are not obliged to sit through hijacked lectures on why men’s issues are equally important and that they should be doing more to address these. There is a right time and a right place – neither of these would be that.

Creating the conditions for a productive environment for freedom of expression is equally important to harvest the fruits of free expression. This is not always easy, but it is good enough to try. Ensuring that attendees are sufficiently informed of the topic(s) to be discussed, and that they are free to leave at any time without being accosted by other attendees for their decision to exercise this right, always goes a long way to ensure a productive exercise of our liberty. What would be even better is if attendees could join in and were notified in advance of the option to reply. If we were all able to notice, to read the room, maybe we wouldn’t need to take refuge under the banner of freedom of speech when we make a mistake. A genuine apology always goes a long way when we have made a mistake. 

Image: Iori Sean Thorpe