Why do we love Sherlock Holmes?
By Ellen Orange
In 2012, Guinness World Records announced that Conan Doyle’s famous detective was the most portrayed character in film and TV. With 60 books written by the original author and 254 subsequent adaptations with over 75 actors representing him, it is clear that Sherlock Holmes is one of the most popular literary characters in existence, but why? Recent adaptations such as the blockbuster film directed by Guy Ritchie, the American series Elementary and, perhaps most significantly, the BBC’s Sherlock have renewed interest in the franchise that has now been in existence for over one hundred years.
The popularity of the detective story is understandable; it is an adventure, and a puzzle or a mystery to solve. The detective figure has become a hero and has survived social change to still be hugely popular today. Writing at the end of the Victorian period, Sir Conan Doyle has created what many see as the epitome of a good detective novel, in his stories of Sherlock Holmes.
We can understand why the original books were so popular, the protagonist was a highly intelligent private detective, whose ability to deduce information from what he could observe was almost fantastic. An eccentric character proves to be more interesting and charismatic for audiences than the typical heroic, goody-two-shoes stereotype, so when Watson describes to us the chaos of Sherlock’s apartment or his erratic eating habits, they prove to be distinctive, not to mention endearing characteristics alongside his uncannily impressive intellect.
We can also point towards the character’s drug abuse, originally opiates in the books and in adaptations represented as anything from cocaine and morphine, to prescription pills or nicotine. This aspect of the character shows the genius detective to be human, proving that despite his intelligence, even the great Sherlock Holmes is not infallible and so this makes it easier to relate to him.
Though the character has survived, he has been portrayed in many different ways. In period adaptations, Holmes is always the quintessence of the English gentleman, and is portrayed closely to the detached, logical character of the books. However, recent adaptations, particularly those that have brought the story into a modern context have sought to draw on particular aspects of the character. Sherlock Holmes (2009), and its sequel, starring Robert Downey Jr, retain the Victorian setting, but draw far more on the character’s eccentricity and social ineptitude. This is drawn out in Sherlock to a whole new degree, where it has even been considered that the character may suffer from Asperger’s Syndrome due to his difficulty in comprehending human emotions and social situations and in finding the appropriate way to respond to them.
The American version Elementary, on the other hand, focuses more on the detective’s addictive personality, whether to substances or even cases. The medical drama House, with the diagnostic specialist Dr Gregory Holmes representing the famous detective, portrays both these aspects to us as the doctor is criticised for his cold and detached manner towards his patients and his team, as well as his addiction to Vicodin and solving cases. These two factors merge when he begins to put patients’ lives at risk. A similar idea is seen in Benedict Cumberbatch’s portrayal when Watson questions his motives and priorities between solving a case and saving a life.
Sherlock type characters may also be seen in recent crime dramas such as Lie to Me or The Mentalist, in which the lead characters are detectives outside of the law and are usually detached from their colleagues, have eccentric tendencies and, most importantly, the premise which the shows are based on, they have an uncanny ability to deduce information from what they perceive.
Laying down these characteristics of Sherlock Holmes still doesn’t explain just why the public loves him so much. Is it because his eccentricity makes him so charismatic? Is it because we want to be as clever as him? Or is it simply because he is different? It may be all of these. The popularity of the BBC’s representation may offer a clue. Sherlock is cold and detached, a hedonistic drug addict, who particularly in this representation, is often rude and has been seen to be cruel, manipulating people for his own ends regardless of their feelings. In all honesty he should be likeable. But we hold Sherlock Holmes up on a pedestal, hailing him as a great British hero. Moriarty blames Sherlock for being ‘on the side of the angels’, but Sherlock warns him not to mistake him for one. At the end of the last episode he eloquently points out, ‘I am not a hero, I’m a high functioning sociopath’. This is why we love the maverick Sherlock, his brutal honesty, favouring reason over sentiment, his ability to break the rules where we can’t. He may not see himself as a hero, but even as a high functioning sociopath, his self-sacrifice in the name of solving cases is heroic. His dark side only gives more depth to the clever, charismatic, adventurous detective, making him both more human and for the audiences, even more heroic. And this is why we love, and will continue to love Sherlock Holmes.
Illustration: Madeleine Brown

