Whose liberté, égalité, fraternité? Police brutality in the Parisian banlieues

By Madeleine Steggall

The murder of George Floyd has sent reverberations across the globe, sparking waves of protest against the systemic racism pervading the US justice system and inspiring people worldwide to criticise racial inequalities within their own countries. In France, the global outrage has reignited a long-standing dispute about police brutality in the ethnically diverse Parisian suburbs. On Tuesday 2nd June, a sea of 20,000 protestors flooded the area surrounding the ‘Tribunal de Paris’ courthouse, chanting “Pas de justice, pas de paix!” – without justice, there can be no peace. The crowds demanded justice for a young, black man murdered by a police officer. But the name they chanted wasn’t George Floyd; it was Adama Traoré.

Four years ago, the 24-year old of Malian descent died in police custody after three officers knelt on his neck to restrain him, allegedly suffocating him to death. After the chilling Floyd video circulated, striking comparisons were made with Traoré’s case, even down to the last words uttered by both men: “I can’t breathe.”Two autopsies and four separate medical examinations have given conflicting reasons for Traoré’s death, the state-commissioned report citing underlying health conditions (which his family deny he had), the independent report favouring ‘asphyxiation from sustained pressure’. The contradictory medical reports echo Floyd’s case, where the preliminary autopsy claimed he had died from a pre-existing heart condition, and the independent autopsy found he had died from asphyxiation. Yet in France, the judge accepted the state’s original report and subsequently dropped all charges against the officers involved with Traoré’s death.

Whilst the protest was mostly peaceful, tensions were volatile between police and protestors and there were several violent clashes later in the night, duly capturing media attention. The government voiced its indignation, warning that “violence has no place in democracy”. Yet these are empty words for youths from the immigrant-rich suburbs whose ordinary lives are saturated by violence and whose voices occupy little space in French democracy.

The outer Parisian ‘banlieue’, built to accommodate the post-war influx of immigrants from former French colonies such as Algeria and the Maghreb, have the highest poverty, unemployment and crime rates in the country. The ethnic minorities who reside there often feel alienated and barred from the wealthy, predominantly white inner-city; this feeling is elevated by the racism, fear and hostility expressed by the media and right-wing political parties towards them. For decades, an explosive relationship between police and inhabitants has persisted, with depressing cycles of delinquency, violence and resentment leading to frequent altercations and eventually riots. Stories of racially motivated police brutality in the suburbs are commonplace, but during the coronavirus lockdown, the frequency of these events ostensibly escalated.

The first day that lockdown measures were introduced, the north-eastern Seine-Saint-Denis department of Paris – home to France’s poorest and most immigrant-rich districts – accounted for 10 percent of all fines handed out for breaching the rules, despite comprising just over two percent of the country’s population. Over the last few weeks, multiple videos have circulated on social media of heavy-handed and racially charged arrests, eliciting outrage and civil unrest. Seine-Saint-Denis has also been hit disproportionately hard health wise; large families in cramped quarters and a lack of hospital beds, coupled with the fact that the poorer suburbs supply most of the frontline workers, means the local population has been especially vulnerable.

The Black Lives Matter protestors in Paris seek an end to racial injustice, whether in the form of racially motivated police brutality in the suburbs, health inequalities, or cultural stereotypes held about ethnic minorities. But for France’s proudly egalitarian — and supposedly colour-blind — institutions, the racialised nature of such inequalities is simply non-existent, neither as a statistic nor as a social experience. In an effort to treat all citizens the same, French law forbids statistics to be collected by race, which means inequalities are hard to identify. The French president of Amnesty International, Cécile Coudriou, says “the anger and violence” of victims and protestors is magnified by “the systematic rejection of any allegation” by the French authorities. The more the government refuse to see racialised police violence as an issue, she says, the more people lose confidence in the institutions allegedly designed to protect them.

Just like the stubborn cry of “All Lives Matter”, the colour-blindness of the French government overlooks the systemic injustice plaguing BAME communities and dismisses the experiences of marginalised groups. Whilst racial inequalities in the US and France have very different origins, with racism in the US emerging from slavery and segregation, and prejudices in France stemming from its colonial past, it is clear that both countries suffer from institutionally racist authorities and require race-conscious approaches to fixing their judicial systems. Careful analyses of the socio-economic factors influencing racial inequality as well as radical changes to police culture and training programs need to be made before either country can claim their national virtues of ‘freedom’ and ‘equality’.

Image: Ev via Unsplash.