Deconstructing protest
By Saskia Wooton-Cane
As far-right protesters gather in the centre of cities across Britain, it is hard to escape the sense of an impending clash. What is playing out is far from a simple reaction to the killing of George Floyd. This battleground is reflective of a much deeper culture war, exposed in the UK during the Brexit referendum, the murder of the Labour MP Jo Cox in June 2016, and increasingly fraught interactions between politicians, institutions, and the public regarding issues such as immigration and austerity. Against this backdrop, the violence and tensions erupting onto the streets have been a long time coming.
[blockquote author=”” ]non-violent protesters can and often do utilise their non-violence to claim the moral high ground and gain sweeping public support[/blockquote]
Yet not all protest has to be this violent, ugly, and vitriolic. Non-violent protest must play out in clearly defined arenas where participants leave behind individual capability for violence and unite in a singular “master frame” whereby moralising philosophy and rhetoric set the boundaries of protest and clearly pit one group against another. In these cases, the non-violent protesters can and often do utilise their non-violence to claim the moral high ground and gain sweeping public support, paralysing the opposing group who must either capitulate or negotiate peacefully, or risk everything in a violent reaction. Prime examples of such protests were the majority of Eastern European movements in 1989 against their Communist governments.
Nonetheless, as I argued in a recent dissertation, non-violent philosophy was not enough to stimulate mass protest in these cases, nor enough to ensure its non-violence. Emotional expression, shared largely through underground networks of literature and art as well as intimate social networks beyond the reach of government surveillance, was key to creating the bonds that facilitated the trust and unity necessary for successful non-violent protest. However, in Romania, where society was far more atomised and individuals were unable to construct these emotional networks, the revolution in 1989 was an anomaly in that it was characterised by fear, anger, and violence. Violence was not simply a means to an end but the result of a lack of a conscious, collective decision to opt out of it, created by an oppressive regime that had reduced not only the levels of intellectual dissidence but also the capacity for emotional sharing, creating an atomised population with common but deeply individualised and unshared experience. It is therefore perhaps unsurprising that the emotions most present in individual experiences of the regime became the defining features of the revolution.
[blockquote author=”” ]non-violent philosophy was not enough to stimulate mass protest in these cases, nor enough to ensure its non-violence[/blockquote]
There are important differences between this and the situation in England. Primarily, whereas in Eastern Europe protest movements were largely fighting against regimes, the divide in England is largely between different civilian groups fighting for, and against, different constructions of national identity and perceptions of past and present. These tensions have been stoked by government rhetoric and policy, but are not reflected in a simple “people vs power” dichotomy. Whereas in Eastern Europe movements paralysed opposing regimes through the legitimising power of non-violence, in England the opposite is developing precisely because the battleground is over contested constructions and perceptions of a shared history. The capacity to set the arena of protest and conflict in non-violent boundaries is premised on shared emotional experience. Therefore, neither group will manage to paralyse the other because neither can erode the other’s claim to legitimacy, which on both sides is rooted not simply on vastly differing intellectual understandings of the past, but enormously different emotional connections with the past.
What we are witnessing today is the result of not simply an intellectual or educational fracture, but an emotional one. Individuals and groups relate their perception of this country to constructions of the past that are, in many cases, simply untrue. The performance of Nazi salutes at cenotaphs at the weekend is a simple demonstration of the irrelevance of historical fact to those involved, as well as the constant erasure of black and brown individuals from our curriculum and public memory. Scandals like Windrush matter not only for the devastating impact on those involved but also the attempt to rewrite Britain’s diverse history. Our country has failed to provide a national narrative that not only respects historical fact but also connects individuals emotionally, with not only the horrors of our colonial past, but also the incredible contributions of black and brown groups and individuals to our society. The consequence has been the emotional investment of thousands of largely white Britons in a construction of history that reflects not true experience but base xenophobia, racism and nationalism, promoted by a false perception of a “glory days” past.
[blockquote author=”” ]the need for emotional connection is a constant of our humanity[/blockquote]
Shared emotion can be the key that binds individuals to non-violence. Yet, as in Romania, more atomised emotion, whether on an individual level or, as we are seeing now, between groups emotionally invested in different constructions of the past, can define social movements as violent by ensuring that fear and anger, whether of a regime or an “other”, become the manifest emotions of such movements. Every age of protest reflects unique dynamics, but the need for emotional connection is a constant of our humanity. It is when that emotional connection is compromised, and we fail to construct a relationship with the past that leans into its complexities and acknowledges change as not just positive but necessary for progress, that we allow for the creation of and emotional investment in false constructions of history. These then serve as concepts against which groups seen as “other” are measured and, when inevitably found wanting, cast out of our narrative of the mainstream. Fractured history builds fractured nations, and in England it is communities of colour that bear this burden overwhelmingly. The violence we are seeing should shock all but surprise no one.
Image: Jason Hargrove. Available via Flickr.
