What happens to the money you donate to charity?

15938772705_7e37ee75b9_o
Women sorting through shoeboxes for the ‘Operation Christmas Child’ campaign.                                                 Image: Naval Surface Warriors via Flickr

By Helen Chamberlain

In this changing world and age of easily accessible information and technological advances should we be assessing our own charitable giving more critically, and does the way charities themselves work need to change? How do we know who to give to?

In the week beginning 9th November Durham Atheist, Secularist and Humanist Society will be running our annual charity week, ‘Non-Prophet‘ week, alongside other humanist societies across the world. This year we will be supporting Give Directly, a charity that sends funds directly to the extreme poor in Kenya and Uganda through mobile banking and has a commitment to transparency and efficacy. It is easy to just shove money in a bucket, but when we’re looking at making more of a commitment to charitable giving what do we need to consider?

Charitable giving is very personal so we need to decide what is important to us and what we think will have the maximum impact on those in need. Think about how effective the charity is in fulfilling these aims. This is not to say that the largest charities are the best; sometimes ‘microcharities’ can achieve more good on a local level, but equally sometimes a larger charity might have more power to achieve their goals – especially in fields like medical research. Try and find out how the charity goes about fulfilling its aims and then whether or not a) it meets them and b) checks how effective it is being. Give Directly constantly monitors how much of a difference it makes in the lives of the people it supports by performing regular (and open) spot checks and constantly re-evaluates how it works to achieve the maximum possible good. Some charities can work using the same model for decades which can be detrimental to the cause they’re trying to work for.

Often we are warned about charities that have large ‘overheads’ but sometimes this is a necessity, especially if part of their work is campaign-based; we need to consider this on a case-by-case basis. However, it is important that charities are honest and don’t use vague statements to confuse donors. The same can be said of corruption and bribery – are you sure your donation will get to the intended recipient? One charity that has gained attention is Samaritan’s Purse, the charity that organises the ‘Operation Christmas Child’ shoebox appeal that many of us have fond memories of. But did you know that the box will often be distributed alongside evangelical Christian literature? The charity’s money may also be used to support homophobic campaigns in the US. None of this is communicated openly, which is wrong.

Often it’s said that we ought to consider carefully how we work to support those in need. Are charities being responsible and supporting people in the right way? Africa as a continent is vast and has a diverse landscape. However, much charitable literature shows Africa as a desperate continent where there is no hope, no water and nothing to recommend it (think Band Aid). This is unhelpful in a number of ways: firstly it can confuse the real issues, and secondly such stereotypes can have a negative impact on the cultures they portray and are often patronising. This is a double-edged sword though, as it is well known more people will give to an emotive campaign – we have to be careful to strike a balance. It’s also important to consider how responsible a charity’s aims are – charities that have a commitment to evangelisation like Samarian’s Purse (amongst many others) may divert resources that could go to the people in need to promoting the gospel – which in itself can cause division in communities, disadvantage those that are not of the same faith and promote unhelpful attitudes (such as poor sex education and lack of women’s rights). This is not to say all faith-based charities are bad – there are many that do great work. But surely the best good is to help the most people as possible without discrimination or to pursue another agenda?

This is a complicated issue and it’s something to think about for yourself when you analyse your own giving. As we approach the festive season you may be looking for some charities to support. From our research we have found several that fulfil the criteria above and cover a wide range of interests:

 

Local Charities (especially those who need particular help over winter):

– Durham Foodbank

– Durham FoodCycle

– Children North East Christmas Tree collection

– Make Winter Warmer North East (donating useful items to the homeless)

– Crisis (supporting the homeless in Newcastle through a shelter)

 

National and International Charities:

– UNICEF

– Anthony Nolan Bone Marrow Donation

– ActionAid

– Goodgifts (buy a gift suitable for someone who really needs it)

– Aquabox (create a box of gifts to enable a community to enjoy clean water)

 

If you’re interested in discussing charitable giving we’re running a discussion session on Tuesday 10th November, meeting at the Durham Students’ Union Riverside Bar at 8pm – we’d love to see you as it’s great to have a wide range of opinions there!