The silence is deafening: the end of free speech?

By Helen Chamberlain

Listening is a skill that we are all aware is an important part of learning. Yet in recent times there has been a disturbing trend: the silencing of individuals in an effort to shelter people from their ideas – something that has been increasingly occurring on university campuses.Students are being denied the right to listen to and to learn from people and ideas that might conflict with their own. This only limits our ability to critically evaluate new ideas, to promote discussion of important issues and to challenge ourselves to engage with people with different points of view.

The tactic of censoring is used in two main ways: to ostensibly prevent extremism and to avoid offence. However the issue lies in how we define these and how we respond to them. The government currently states extremism is ‘the vocal or active opposition to fundamental British values, including democracy, the rule of law, individual liberty and the mutual respect and tolerance of different faiths and beliefs.’ For a legal definition this seems worrisomely vague – for one thing what exactly are “British values”? UK universities have come under scrutiny and in 2015 a list of higher education institutions that had hosted ‘extremist speakers’ was published by the government in an attempt to get them to commit to helping curb this perceived problem. But with such a vague definition, who are we allowed to invite and who do we ban?

The answer isn’t clear. Individuals often mentioned as ‘extreme’ include Haitham al-Haddad, Hamza Tzortzis and Uthman Lateef, all of whom, for example, have made openly homophobic statements and hold views many people would disagree with. However there is a very real risk that non-extremist Muslim speakers will be tarred with the same brush and excluded from speaking on the basis they *may* be extremists, purely by association with these or other people – as seen in the treatment of organisations accused of having links with the Muslim Brotherhood. The Church of England has recently sided with openly homophobic organisations, yet universities across the country host events with speakers from this organisation with no questions asked. It seems there is a disparity in how we treat religious organisations and speakers with homophobic views – we label some extreme, yet others are praised for being the source of British morality. This only serves to vilify, further alienate and increase animosity towards the Muslim population, the vast majority of whom are just normal, peaceful people.

On the other hand we have speakers being banned for causing offence or insult. Maryam Namazie, prominent human rights activist and spokesperson for the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain, was initially barred from speaking at 3 UK universities in 2015 and her talk was significantly disrupted at Goldsmith’s university by people seeking to silence her. Whilst Maryam may criticise Islamism (the far right political ideology) and even Islam (the religion), she does not incite hatred towards the people themselves and in fact hotly defends the right of the individual to hold their own beliefs. Criticising ideas is not the same is not the same as displaying prejudice towards those that hold them. This is not to suggest that seeking to knowingly cause offence is a good idea as it is often counter-productive, but at the same time we do not have a right not to be offended. Unless someone is directly inciting harm, hatred or prejudice towards a person or group of people they shouldn’t be silenced – they may have something important to say. We have a fundamental human right to be able to believe what we want to and unless we harm others, we ought to be free to speak about our own beliefs and ideas.

In an effort to protect students, universities are treading a dangerous line – in making tighter and tighter no platform policies to avoid extremism on the one hand and offence on the other we’re actually shutting down conversations which desperately need to occur. The majority of this discourse unfortunately surrounds Islam; however there have also been calls for other allegedly homophobic, sexist, transphobic and racist speakers to be banned from university campuses. By having the discussion, listening to people and challenging them we can learn from them why they hold their views and encourage them to change their opinion. Stifling the conversation only compounds the issue by making sure the two ‘sides’ never meet in constructive debate or discussion. People can be offended, people can protest, people can hold events promoting alternate points of view. We shouldn’t underestimate students in their ability to analyse people’s opinions critically and weigh up the arguments presented to them; only in this way will we truly tackle some of the most important issues facing us as a society.

Durham Atheist, Secularist and Humanist Society are pleased to announce that Maryam Namazie has accepted an invitation to speak at Durham university. This was due to take place on January 26th, however the event has had to be postponed – please keep your eyes open for details.

Photograph: Venus Loi