What does the social media trad wife trend reveal about modern feminism?

By Amelia Romanowska

If you recently scrolled through any social media you might have been met with ‘trad wife’ content, a trend led by women showcasing the traditional lifestyle of a stay-at-home mother who cooks and cares for her many children. There are common trends in the pioneers within this field, from accounts like Ballerina Farm on Instagram, they are fiscally comfortable living within a one-income family, religiously motivated to maintain a nuclear family image and tactically position the camera to broadcast only the aspects of life that would lure one into the content. This return to tradition has been scrutinised as it portrays the ideal that many have said stunts the progression that the feminist movement has given so much to women and portrays them in line with the male gaze of the stay-at-home good wife for whom the content is arguable.

The conception of this traditional wife is rooted within the ethos of the white picket fence suburban family, that prevails within the baby and consumer boom of the 1950s. That decade specifically as the ‘60s welcomed the second wave of feminism that historically fought for women’s rights, the pursuit of a life outside the family unit and their autonomy which 60 years later is ongoing to this day. The trad wife’s emphasis on the domestic sphere seems like a rollback on all the progression, but that is not necessarily true. Feminism emphasises the choice in the matter, and the option to stay home is on par with the pursuit of a financial career. It allows for a genuine choice that fulfils a person, and being a stay-at-home mother can do just that. I believe this choice is mainly dictated by a couple’s financial matters and religious beliefs which allows for a cleaner analysis.

The image they showcase is a fantasy… trad wives create content that is curated to be consumed

A one-income household is idyllic, something that is not shown in the allure of the videos that come up on our content feeds. This fiscal leverage allows women to make the choice to become stay-at-home mothers as not everyone can, even if it is within their agency to become one they can’t necessarily pursue that pathway. Two-income households are necessary, they are the custom as the price of food, of living and at this point, of breathing, becomes extortionate. Including children in the calculation, it’s needed more than ever. The idea of the husband as the breadwinner is mainly that of the past as women now are an important part of the fiscal task force. A nuance around the trad wife influencers is that income is possible for them through monetisation and sponsored posts. Beyond the trend, for stay-at-home mothers who are not content creators that harm lies that when the decision is made, the personal stream of income is forfeited. Being a trad wife is a net 0 pay job, being 24 hours on the clock and no Unions to protect your rights. Now relying on the back of your husband, the whole situation mirrors the problems that women faced in the 1950s, hoping the husband does not leave you, or worse become abusive and income and religious pressures become a factor in staying in the relationship longer than necessary.

Beyond that, the image they showcase is a fantasy. Through the lens of the camera, we see them make mozzarella from scratch, use their own sourdough starter, and aid their children in portraying a perfect life. We don’t exactly see them do the tasks we all dread like cleaning the bathroom as it is all a staged view of this lifestyle. But this portrayal shouldn’t come as a shock, as trad wives create content that is curated to be consumed and most importantly, urge us to come back for more. This clean-cut portrayal has a heavy involvement of religion within the movement. Many trad wives uphold religious beliefs which complement traditional roles, values and the general way of living. Some religions, more than others such as Mormonism, have a clearer way of displaying the roles that are meant for women and men. Women choosing to stay home now becomes part of the play to abide by their belief systems, where their agency is swayed to accompany their scriptures. While agency allows women to make such choices, autonomy questions whether those choices are fully independent of societal or religious pressures. The scrutiny against these content creators derives from their push towards their lifestyle being the right one, which as argued is a dangerous trap. From this comment being explicitly said in their videos or done so passively by just posting such content, they shape a narrative that this path is better than any other a young girl might consider. 

Ultimately, the ‘trad wife’ trend highlights key debates within modern feminism. As women come to embrace this lifestyle, we are reminded of the long-standing fight for this choice, we just need to be alert to the factors around us that might aid or shroud our autonomy. 

Image: Jessica Rockowitz via Unsplash