Anti-intellectualism and the rise of authoritarianism in America

By Amelia Romanowska

With a quick Google search, we can see that the term ‘anti-intellectualism’ was coined by Richard Hofstadter in 1963, referring to the period in American political history known as McCarythyism. It was a general mob distrust of those who leaned ideologically left – even called it a second Red Scare – but 60 years later, it’s something we still hear about, even though the USSR is long gone, a fact you can confirm with my grandmother.

As a whole, anti-intellectualism is the mistrust of intellect, intellectuals, and especially experts within their field and this can transform in all sorts of ways. We would recognise it more radically through the flat Earth community, individuals who are adamantly against all vaccines, and on a less conspiracy level, those who drink unpasteurised milk (which can give you tuberculosis – yes, everything is tuberculosis). What’s common between these three groups is that they are compiled with people who believe they know better, putting themselves on pedestals to speak on issues they most likely have no qualifications in.

The rise of anti-intellectualism should be seen as going hand in hand with totalitarian and authoritarian regimes

This is precisely when we see knowledge being overtaken by misinformation, often fuelled by conspiracy theories that begin to form the foundations of this mistrust. Sometimes there is this need to find an alternative truth because the one presented before us does not satisfy us, perhaps it is too simple, or we need it to align within a compact understanding on our terms. I think it is only natural to mistrust people; it’s innate to believe that we know what is best for ourselves, something that arguably dates back to hunter-gatherer days, but not to the extent in which we see this anti-intellectualist resurgence.

More recently, we could see the phrase being thrown around the actions and decisions of the Trump administration. The president of arguably the most powerful country in the world, at this given time in history, has recently signed an executive order to dismantle the Department of Education. The department, established in 1979, oversees crucial aspects such as funding for public schools, administering student loans, and running programs that help low-income students gain access and resources to continue their education to a higher level. Trump and the rallying right-wing politicians around him accuse the department of indoctrinating young people with racial, gender and sexual political agendas that allegedly ‘corrupt’ them. This is a disguise and falls nothing short of portraying itself as protecting the youth and future generations from what they deem to be incorrect line of thought. This directly bleeds into the attack on so-called ‘Mickey Mouse’ degrees – a symptom not only found in America. Degrees usually within the humanities, arts and social sciences sector that are deemed unemployable and not creating an ideal workforce.

The world needs historians, sociologists, anthropologists – scholars and experts who provide nuance and depth to different theoretics, offer new perspectives, and add richness to conversations we desperately need, rather than forcing homogenous ideas that are not allowed to be questioned

The rise of anti-intellectualism should be seen as going hand in hand with totalitarian and authoritarian regimes. These regimes aim to control narratives, suppress critical thinking, deny historical realities, and reject scientific evidence that would contradict the society they are aiming to construct. My mind goes to the likes of Adolf Hitler in Nazi Germany who at the very start of his political power in 1933 ordered the burning of the books, and it is a condition seen throughout other regimes: South Africa during the apartheid restricting books and universities, USSR and Imperial Japan doing the same- all rejected realities that did not support the narratives and propaganda they sought to embed in the public consciousness. 

Modern America is following in these footsteps. With Trump’s recent attacks on Harvard University, it is hard not to notice and say in collective voice that history is repeating itself under the ideals of anti-intellectualism. Education is at risk. By even talking about limiting courses which can be taught, it paves the way towards limiting who can take those courses, crucially impacting the freedom upon which America was created. The Trump administration is creating a narrowing narrative that, from history, we can see as oppressive and wrong.

I thought we had moved on from those times. The world needs historians, sociologists, anthropologists – scholars and experts who provide nuance and depth to different theoretics, offer new perspectives, and add richness to conversations we desperately need, rather than forcing homogenous ideas that are not allowed to be questioned. That is oppression – and that is the danger that anti-intellectualism brings.

Image: Gage skidmore via Wikimedia Commons