What City’s FFP ban and fine means for the club and Guardiola
By Luke Power
Call it manipulative. Call it mischievous. Call it malevolent. There are many ways you could describe Manchester City’s behaviour in provoking their latest controversy, none of which are particularly flattering.
To use a parenting metaphor, Manchester City have been grounded by UEFA, and won’t be allowed to go out to play for two years. As a result of overstating their sponsorship revenue in their accounts between 2012 and 2016, last year’s Premier League champions will not be allowed to compete in European competitions until the 2022/23 season and have been slapped with a £25,000,000 fine. They do, however, remain in this season’s Champions League, and are locking horns with Real Madrid for a place in the quarterfinals tonight.
The Premier League also look set to punish City for breaching Financial Fair Play regulations, which would likely see a points deduction. Not that it would affect the title race – at the time of writing Guardiola’s men are 22 points behind Liverpool – but it would be another sobering blow. There have also been rumours that the City could be stripped of their 2014 Premier League title, but that is unlikely.
So, what does all this mean moving forward?
Well, in financial terms, the impact of this ban has the potential to be seismic, and so it’s understandable why the club are arming a fleet of lawyers to aid an appeal and try to avert the impending disaster. City reportedly made £84,000,000 from their journey to the last eight of the Champions League last season, yet only made a £10,000,000 profit in total. Losing such a big source a revenue on top of the substantial fine will be impactful.
And yet, despite the predictions being all doom and gloom in the aftermath of this news breaking, the word from the City camp is calm and reassuring. After their game against West Ham, Pep Guardiola asserted that if he is not sacked, he “will stay 100%.” This is vital. Though he has received criticism for his side’s lack of glory in Europe, Guardiola has become the best manager in the club’s history since joining in 2016 by winning seven trophies, breaking numerous records and having by far the best win percentage out of any City manager.
Not only is he one of the only managers in Europe innovative and meticulous enough to possibly topple Liverpool in future seasons, but he is a magnet for the world’s most talented players. Since arriving at Manchester City, he has signed the likes of Ederson, Aymeric Laporte, Riyad Mahrez, Leroy Sané and İlkay Gündoğan to name just a few. Though being on Europe’s naughty step for two years will make it more difficult to attract elite players, it probably won’t have as negative an impact as you might initially think. A look at recent history shows why.
After David Moyes fluffed his lines in 2013/14 and secured Manchester United a ticket out of Europe for the following season, the club still managed to sign Ángel di María, Ander Herrera, Luke Shaw, Marcos Rojo, Daley Blind and Víctor Valdés in the summer. And after Jurgen Klopp could only finish eighth in his first season with Liverpool, the club could still bring in in the likes of Sadio Mané, Georginio Wijnaldum and Joël Matip for a domestic tussle. Admittedly, Rojo is no Laporte and Valdés no Ederson, but the point stands: if you’re a mega-sized club, you can sign great players whether you’re in Europe or not.
It remains to be seen whether City will need to make that many signings. Already, some players have pledged their allegiance to the cause, including Raheem Sterling and, perhaps to the frustration of some fans, Nicolas Otamendi. Other players could have special reasons for staying – would Agüero fancy his chances of breaking Alan Shearer’s all-time scoring record? And perhaps Phil Foden would finally become a regular if a few midfielders left?
The worrying factor for City is the age of their stars. David Silva confirmed at the start of the season that he would be leaving and he is joined on the wrong side of 30 by Fernandinho, Agüero and Claudio Bravo. Other VIPs like Kevin de Bruyne, Kyle Walker, Mahrez and Gündoğan are not far behind. Are these players going to hang on for two years at this stage of their careers when most of them haven’t won the Champions League? Can these players be expected to sacrifice game time at the highest level with places to fight for in their countries’ 2022 World Cup squads? It wouldn’t be surprising if a few of them jumped ship.
Bernardo Silva also looks likely to leave the club sooner rather than later after admitting he has felt an ‘emptiness’ since leaving Benfica, the club he supports, in 2015.
And so the pressure on this season mounts. The next few months may write the script for Manchester City’s immediate future. The next few months will feature episodes that sculpt Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City legacy.
If Guardiola can deliver City’s most coveted prize this season, it will go a long way to persuading some of his key players to stay. It will also place him on the podium of managerial greatness, if he is not already there. He delivered the first ever domestic treble in men’s football on English turf, but only a Champions League trophy parade in the blue half of Manchester will get most naysayers off his back. Though he says he will stay at Manchester City through the ban, who is to say he would make it that far and lead them into Europe again? Two years is a long time in football, and more pressure than ever will be on to deliver domestically given respite from continental affairs. This may well be Guardiola’s last foray into Europe with City.
Nevertheless, Manchester City will be undeterred by this blip. The financial impact will cause a bruise but will be easily plastered over. With an estimated net worth of £17,000,000,000, Sheikh Mansour could afford to buy every club in the Premier League if the idea floated into his head. They will compete for honours annually and attract glamorous players to the club. The man who will feel this blip the most is a man who had no part in causing it: Pep Guardiola.
Image: hm-photo via Flickr and Creative Commons
