What can Pride Parades teach us about accessible education?
By Daniel Pettingale
The most recent stir in the House of Commons has been that the government has published plans to reintroduce grammar schools. It could have made for an interesting session of Prime Minister’s Questions, with the leaders of two opposing parties locked in a debate over the fundamental purpose of one of the most important institutions in the modern world. But, like many things that could make for an interesting debate, this argument devolved into an exchange of sound bites, of which my personal least favourite was Corbyn constantly calling the grammar school policy “segregation at the age of 11.”
There are some nuances to the policy that can answer some of his main arguments but which May never mentioned, for reasons best known to herself. In fact, it hardly matters. Good school places are all very well, but the crucial thing for the sort of children who would go to grammar schools is that their strengths are academic, and so their goal will be university. However, some of the main children who are to be considered in any education policy are those from lower income families, and for them there is a rather more pressing problem than social stigma or school selection when it comes to getting a university place: they’re far too expensive.
A new student arriving at Durham University this year could be charged over ÂŁ16,000 if they are living in college (fees plus standard catered accommodation.) That does not include any other maintenance (for which the grant has now been scrapped, meaning another loan.) They also know that another two years of study will cost a further ÂŁ18000 just in fees, plus potentially another ÂŁ14,000 more from the college, or whatever they can get from a nearby estate agent. In other words, any student taking a standard, 3-year course at Durham university knows right from the start that they are in at the very least ÂŁ27,000 of debt (more for students arriving in 2017), assuming that their parents can help pay for rent and maintenance. Bearing in mind that we are considering low income families, that seems unlikely, so we have to assume that either they have to find a paid job and save up, (thus either forcing them to wait or piling on more work during term) or we assume that they will have to take out larger maintenance loans, meaning even more debt. And yet with all this, we are told that the university is still having financial problems, and with the even tighter squeeze we are told to expect from Brexit, there seems no real prospect of the fees going down anytime soon.
Just with those numbers readily available to me (alas), it is fairly obvious that neither reintroducing, nor rejecting grammar schools is an entire solution for making education less the preserve of the rich. Neither indeed is changing social attitudes. It may be desirable, but no matter how much university professors may want to be more inclusive of potential students from lower income families, that will not help anyone if those same students cannot afford a university degree and the university cannot afford to make the degree cheaper. That argument, however, is hardly news, and there lies the rub. Grammar schools can cause a stir among the press because they have become an event: something specific and identifiable happened in a short enough space of time for us to see it all at once and for it to cause a shock. In a word, it was news. The numbers that I have just quoted were also news, in their time, but once the increase was made, they ceased to be news: the events were over, the immediate shock was past. The problem for accessible education, then, is to keep the fact that education favours the rich in the news.
The gay pride parade might offer a good model for this. Legislation on homosexuality has ceased to be front page news for some time: gay marriage is legal and so believing in it is no longer rebellious enough to cause a stir. If anyone doubts this, I invite them to ask themselves: what do they imagine being bigger news? A politician declaring themselves in favour of gay marriage, or a politician saying something homophobic? However, the gay pride parade is an event. It cannot go unnoticed in any community; it commands attention; it is news. Hence, something as uninteresting as the education secretary having a girlfriend manages to reach the news simply because it is attached to an event. That happened two years after the introduction of gay marriage. If we care about accessible education, that is the sort of effect we want: an issue that has been around for some time and an opinion that has long been socially acceptable, still being news. To do that, the core issue must remain at the forefront: the grammar school debate will cease to be news; a particular increase in fees will cease to be news. The principle will never cease to be true, and so the best thing to do to make it a working reality in the modern world is to make sure it stays in the public eye.
Photograph by Venus Loi
