Project Fear, Project Bribe and European Diatribes

By Daniel Pettingale

I agree with the Devil. It is a fairly natural response to watching Newsnight, especially when Lord Mandelson appears, but it is a cathartic thing to say in public. Now the Devil is not always a reliable guide, and agreeing with him can cause something of a fuss, but occasionally it happens. This particular occasion was at the annual dinner of the Tempters’ Training College for Young Devils, in an address given by the venerable Screwtape, a tempter with a good reputation, who has left us a good account of his methods through a collection of his letters, made public by the efforts of C.S Lewis. Lewis never explained how he came across them.

I will reproduce some of Screwtape’s remarks here, and in particular, his complaints about the appetiser, a municipal authority with graft source: “Was he not unmistakably a Little Man – a creature of the petty rake-off pocketed with a petty joke in private and denied with the stalest platitudes in his public utterances – a grubby little nonentity who had drifted into corruption, only just realising that he was corrupt, and chiefly because everyone else did it?” Judging by most of the arguments that we have heard about our EU referendum, I doubt that Screwtape’s fare will be improving anytime soon. The stale platitudes in this case have to do with money and very little else. Aside from a few token acknowledgements of patriotism, cause that’s a thing people do, almost all the arguments seem to be variations on a theme of, “if the referendum goes the way we don’t want it to, we’ll lose all our cash.”

I don’t want to get into the EU debate itself here: I don’t know very much about the politics involved and less about the economics. My point is that those things are all that the people involved in the argument do seem to know about. For example, the government sent around a leaflet to try to convince everybody to vote to remain in the EU, with some token pretence that they were trying to inform us. That in itself is hardly new; complaining that the government said that it was going to do one thing and then did something entirely different is like going to the beach and complaining that the tides keep going in and out. Even so, one would think that if the government did plan to bring us all round to think the way that they did, they would give us something that sounded grand and inspiring and patriotic, even more so given that we keep being told that it is a once in a generation decision that will affect our history for years to come. One would expect the  buzzwords of the government to be something like “standing with our allies,” “uniting the nations of Europe,” or “taking hold of our future;” something, in short, that sounded historic, something that sounded like a rallying cry to a nation standing on a precipice. Instead the slogans on the leaflet are these: “Protecting jobs,” “A stronger economy,” and “ Providing security.” Even worse, those come on the back cover: those are the slogans that somebody in the government chose to be the ending that would embody the spirit of the leaflet and put all arguments against it to rest. And the best things they could think of to do that were the economy, jobs and security.

That is the heart of this debate and, it seems, every argument that anybody in charge of anything seems to engage in: what saves us money? What is most expedient? What is easiest? The idea is never even entertained that maybe the difficult road might just be the right one. There is, for example, a perfectly human response that one could make to all of the remain arguments simultaneously: yes leaving the EU will be hard, yes the economy will suffer, yes we will lose a number of large business headquarters; but, those are all sacrifices worth making for our sovereignty, and if that is what true sovereignty costs then it will be up to the British people to make that sacrifice, taking whatever hardship comes our way to reclaim our independence. Meanwhile, the remain campaign has one of the greatest propaganda opportunities in history: here we are after centuries of conflict and division in Europe with the chance to bring it all together. The EU, if properly managed, could be the beginning of a new era of history for Europe: nations that once ruled empires and nations once barely more than slaves all brought together as one Union; the old enmities of Germany with Poland and Britain with Ireland forgotten forever as the nations come together and form something new, merging all the nobility and honour of their pasts together and leaving every old grudge behind. Either of those cases has a real appeal that could be made to a human being with a soul. Instead, what we get is bribes of a “stronger economy” and threats of a loss of jobs, as though nothing else mattered: nothing could be worth unemployment, nothing could be worth losing money, surely? Surely nothing could be worth struggling for?

If there is a point to this article then it is this: it is all very well for us to be concerned about money and our own positions, but it is not the supreme thing. There are things important enough that it is worth sacrificing prosperity or safety for them, and national sovereignty or unity may well be among them. They may not be, that will be your decision to make on referendum day. The point is that it does not seem to have occurred to most people involved in the public debate that they might be. I therefore ask that somebody might think about them from time to time and actually allow a touch of humanity to infiltrate the debate, almost as though the decision being made were being made by human beings rather than economic calculators. A naive hope, perhaps, but one that needs expressing somewhere, and it might as well be here.

Illustration: Mariam Hayat