West Indies withdrawal from India tour a major worry

By Kishan Vaghela

 

West Indies withdrew from their tour of India on 18th October after a pay dispute.  Captain Dwayne Bravo confirmed to the West Indies Cricket Board (WICB) of the players’ decision “to withdraw their services for the remainder of the tour of India”.

The five-match series was all level at 1-1 on the day of the fourth, and what turned out to be, the final One Day International (ODI) between India and the West Indies in the series, as the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) claimed that the WICB had informed them of the players’ decision to withdraw from the tour. The WICB initially denied the claim made by their opposite number, but in a later statement confirmed the players’ decision to end the tour. Sri Lanka have replaced West Indies on the tour of India but it is the relationship between the two countries with regards to cricket which will be the most severely affected, despite the WICB apologising  “to West Indies fans, cricket fans and the BCCI” for this “most regrettable situation”.

Chris_Gayle, commons.wikimedia

However, it is yet to be seen to what extent the most powerful cricketing board in the whole world, the BCCI, will demand of their fellow counterparts. Having already withdrawn from all future tours to the Caribbean, the BCCI have demanded $42m (around £26.2m) in compensation for pulling out of the tour. Although at the time of writing the West Indies have asked the BBCI for a “mutually agreeable solution”, it remains to be seen what the ramifications are for the West Indies, and this is perhaps the most worrying aspect for the future of cricket in the Caribbean.

Two West Indies greats have had their say on which way the future of West Indian cricket will go, and both contrast each other enormously. West Indies’ record run scorer Brian Lara, who still holds the record for the most runs in a single innings in a Test match, expects them to survive the compensation they will have to pay, believing that the BCCI will not be that “severe” on them. However, Lara also stated that the cost of $42m in compensation is “way beyond” the WICB, but still believes that the game in the Caribbean will “be alive”. What was most telling in Lara’s interview with the BBC was when he said that “there have been many little quarrels between players and board but it’s the first time they are perhaps facing something as severe as this”, clearly demonstrating that a dispute between players and the board is common, but failed to condemn what the players had done.

A similar incident occurred in 2005 where the players were unhappy with a certain clause in the tour contract which led to the likes of Lara being left out of the team for the visit of South Africa and the tour of Sri Lanka. History repeated itself in 2009 where the players refused to take part in a series against Bangladesh and the Champions Trophy due to pay and contract issues. What kind of message is this sending out to the rest of the cricketing world? According to the other great, former fast bowler Ian Bishop, the withdrawal should send such a message to the players that it serves as a “wake-up call”. “I don’t think the players understood the ramifications of such a move” he said, but, like Lara, warned the BCCI that the amount of compensation would not only “bankrupt” West Indies but also “reduce the spectacle of world cricket”. However, in contrast to Lara, he did believe that the future of West Indian cricket was under threat, but was confident a solution would be found.

Unfortunately, the only positive that can be taken by such a withdrawal is that relations between the BCCI and Sri Lanka Cricket (SLC) have been strengthened. It remains to be seen whether England will go ahead with the scheduled three-match Test series in the Caribbean in April and May despite Lara’s confidence that “England are safe, they can book the hotels and feel very comfortable”. The other question that has to be asked is what does this mean for West Indies’ chances of lifting the World Cup in February and March? Like India, they have not been a threat in Test cricket for a few years now, but there can be no doubting their quality in the limited overs version of the game. Whilst they may not be considered as one of the favourites to lift the trophy like Australia, India and South Africa, you can never rule out a team that boasts the talent of Chris Gayle, Kieron Pollard, Dwayne Bravo and Darren Sammy, to name a few. But with this latest dispute, it is difficult to judge whether the team will be able to put the dispute behind them and challenge the favourites in Australia and New Zealand.

Photograph: commons.wikimedia