We should be careful not to keep revisiting the Iraq debate

From the left and the right of the political spectrum, Tony Blair is being widely derided. At best he is simply a liar; at worst, he is a warmonger and a criminal, who was involved in a secret pact with the great Satan (dear old George W. Bush) to take this country to war with or without the backing of the United Nations, and, by extension, the international community.

For those who were always adamant that this war was immoral, nothing short of a full-blown war trial would suffice to absolve this country of his dereliction in duty; which is why, outside of the stuffy Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre in Westminster, the crowds brandished placards, yelled slogans and bayed for Blair’s blood. From the perspective of these protestors, this inquiry, like the Hutton and Butler inquiries before it, is inherently flawed. It is an inquiry set up by this government, to indict this government: a thoroughly paradoxical affair.

I find myself in a rare quandary, because, the fact is: in 2003 I supported the invasion loudly, passionately, and, I thought, with right on my side.

I supported the invasion for a whole host of reasons. Principally, because I had watched for years as the Iraqi people were tortured and bullied by a violent despot, whose lives were made a misery by the sanctions regime we imposed; because the only alternative was to stick with a containment strategy which was not working, a strategy which had caused the deaths of around a million Iraqis, including 500,000 children.

I reckoned that Saddam Hussein was a thug, and that we had lost control of him. He had ignored seventeen UN resolutions over twelve years. He was not complying with the weapons inspectors and the only alternative to war left him in power and did nothing for the plight of the Iraqi people.

Furthermore, I felt, as I am sure Blair did, that with 250,000 troops on the border, a climb down would have sent an incredibly damaging message across the world that the west was not willing to stand firm on its convictions: we would be seen to have a loud bark, and a weak bite.

I do not often find myself agreeing with the multitude simply because they are more numerous. I believe that the majority can be wrong and often are. Indeed, when I saw Blair sitting in front of the Chilcot panel I could not help but think of another famous trial, distant in time but which will resonate for time immemorial.

In this trial the protagonist was equally sure of his convictions; he was equally truculent and refused to back down. Like Blair, he felt that he had right on his side, and like Blair, he was sure that he would be indicted. In 399 BC, this man (Socrates) was put to death for “corrupting the youth of Athens”. It is a proof, if any were needed, that the masses can get things terribly wrong.

The analogy may seem a little stretched. But it does point to an important factor that we must consider when forming our own judgements about this, our third inquiry into the Iraq war. Blair, like Socrates, may well be long dead by the time the judgement of history can truly and fully reflect on his guilt or innocence.

It seems, however, that we can begin to form a judgement, however partial and qualified it might be. We know, for instance, that we did not find weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. We also have evidence that some of the intelligence information was distorted and we are beginning to see how Blair’s sofa style of government allowed him to go on a messianic crusade, without proper cabinet scrutiny.

What is also clear is that the immediate impact of the war was grisly. In 2006, a team at John Hopkins University estimated that 655,000 people had died since the invasion of Iraq in 2003 (and that these deaths were in excess of those which would have occurred in any case, if the invasion had not occurred). But what we do not know is what the situation in Iraq would be like today if we had pulled back from the brink, leaving an emboldened Saddam, secure in his power.

What we often forget is that the alternative to war with Iraq in 2003 was not a ‘just peace’, but an equally unsatisfying continuation of the status quo. This would have, in all likelihood, meant a continuation of the corrupt sanctions regime and hence a continuation of the steady trickle of blood that had characterised the years since the first Gulf War in 1990.

This absence of real distance and time makes a proper judgement impossible, and the moral ambiguity of the Iraq affair will lead (of necessity) to a nuanced conclusion that will not satisfy the baying mobs outside of the Conference Centre. The worrying fact is that whilst the spotlight is focussed on Iraq, an intractable war in Afghanistan is escalating.  It is time for all of us to stop reliving the debates of the past and focus on the now.