We need to talk about paedophilia

By Patrick Brennan

An article from The Independent recently popped up on my Facebook timeline. It was reporting on a piece entitled ‘I’m a paedophile, but not a monster’. You might ask, ‘how can this be? Surely the two are one and the same?’

The original piece written for Salon by Todd Nickerson, a graphic designer from Tennessee – which at first appears to be defending sexual attraction towards children – seems to have lost the fight before it’s even begun. And a quick glance at the comments section of the article in The Independent corroborates this.

One woman commented: “I’m not even going to give this the benefit of reading. If you’re a paedophile, you’re a monster. End of.” Numerous comments of a similar sentiment lie below the post, gathering a similarly large number of ‘likes’.

The inherent problem that Nickerson attempts to address surrounds the word ‘paedophile’ itself, and what it actually means

Ironically enough, through this swift dismissal, she has highlighted the main misunderstanding that the article is trying to clear up. The inherent problem that Nickerson attempts to address surrounds the word ‘paedophile’ itself, and what it actually means.

In the piece, Nickerson explains how his sexual attraction towards children is involuntary and may have come about through a number of different routes, both environmental and genetic. His childhood introversion and shyness (due in part to being born without a right hand and suffering from a chronic bladder problem) played a large part, along with his own experience of having been abused by a family friend, aged seven.

The details of Nickerson’s attraction to children aren’t important. What’s important here is that he has never actually molested a child, nor has he ever consumed child pornography. Mr Nickerson has never committed a crime in relation to his attraction to children.

The dictionary definition of ‘paedophile’ is ‘a person who is sexually attracted to children’ – more specifically, someone who is attracted to children aged 11 or below (attraction to children aged 11-15 and 15-19 is known as hebephilia or ephebophilia respectively). What a paedophile isn’t, is someone who has abused, molested or raped a child. Just like how all medicines are drugs, but not all drugs are medicines, it is important to note that whilst child molesters/sexual abusers might well all be paedophiles, not all paedophiles are child molesters/abusers. But over time the term ‘paedophile’ has become synonymous for someone who has committed criminal acts.

To solve this problem, we must make a decision: should we endorse the true definition of the word ‘paedophile’ and get rid of the incriminating assumptions that surround it, or should we adopt ‘paedophile’ as a term specifically used for molesters/abusers, and start using a new word for those who feel attraction towards minors but have not committed crimes against them?

The latter option, despite its etymological incorrectness, might be the better option. Only in the advent of a new word – perhaps stemming from the Latin word ‘infans’ rather than the Greek word ‘paidí’ – can we ensure the safety of those who are innocent in the eyes of the law. Don’t forget that in 2000, a vigilante mob vandalised the home of a Welsh doctor after confusing the words ‘paedophile’ and ‘paediatrician’…

It goes without saying that anyone who finds themselves in a position of fancying children must never ever act on these wishes. Like incest and bestiality, paedophilia, even as an involuntary sensation in those who harbour it, will never be accepted by any civilised society. And rightly so. But the mere thought process of being attracted to children can never be illegal, lest we find ourselves in some kind of Orwellian thought-police state. Instead, paedophilia should be seen as a psychiatric disorder; one which can be helped with therapy and with better understanding and acceptance. The way to face the issue is rehabilitation, not persecution.

Can law-abiding paedophiles ever be given the understanding and acceptance they deserve? Yes they can. Regardless of what route we choose, we need a clear, foolproof naming system; one that easily differentiates between innocent people suffering from an involuntary mental state, and people who have committed what is considered by many to be the most evil crime of them all.

Photograph: Nicolas Alejandro via Flickr