Wave goodbye to your 2:1 as changes planned for degree classification

by Ettie Bailey-King

Every university in the UK will be asked to replace its existing system of degree classification (first, second and third class) with a new, more detailed measure of performance.

The Higher Education Achievement Report (HEAR) recommends that the “blunt instrument” of current degree classes be replaced by a record which “drills down to modular level” and reveals how students perform across a range of activities, indicating whether these are “timed examinations, projects [or] dissertations”.

Robert Burgess, the Chairman of the Universities and College Admission Service (UCAS) and head of the steering group calling for classification reform, called the current system a “crude” measure of performance. The HEAR will include details of students’ “achievements in extra-curricular activities” such as “[representing] the university in terms of sport or [being] conductor of the university orchestra.”

Burgess has been a prominent advocate of reform since 2003. In 2004 his “scoping group” produced a report claiming that the grading system had “outlived its usefulness” – and called for a more informative “progress file” to reflect the increasing importance of a graduate’s University performance in the employment market.

Since 2004, pilot schemes have operated in twenty Universities. Of these, Leicester will be the first to award the HEAR to graduates this year. Meanwhile the “template is in place” for every University follow suit the following year.

Burgess states that “the intention is to propose to the sector, as from October 2012, that all students entering higher education institutions will get the opportunity to achieve a HEAR having worked with it through a three-year period.”

This information will also be on offer to employers- with the student’s consent – before graduation so that it can be used as part of the application process.

The Association of Graduate Recruiters (AGR) warns that amid fierce competition for jobs and increasingly stringent requirements, the class of one’s degree has never been so important. A recent survey for the AGR found that 78% of employers insisted on a 2:1 minimum degree class, and that graduates with a 2:2 or below risked being filtered out by automated applications.

As university tuition fees have risen sharply to an average of ÂŁ8,750 per year, students are likely to “expect a much more detailed evaluation of their performance”. It is hoped that the HEAR will provide the kind of “detailed evaluation that can be given to employers and can be used in order to help them in their careers.”

Furthermore, it aims to measure a range of skills which are not usually apparent from one’s CV. Using the HEAR, employers will now be able to tell whether students are “really good in timed examinations”, to help them pick graduates with the skills they “really require”.

UCAS will also be diversifying the information which it presents as part of an application for Higher Education. Now, students’ own details will be accompanied by information such as the school’s academic performance and the percentage of pupils receiving free school meals.

The Office for Fair Access is currently vetting Universities’ plans to charge higher fees, to ensure that they are continue to work towards widening access for students from all backgrounds.