Wales vs England: player ratings

Rob Stevenson rates the players following England’s thrilling victory over Wales 

 

England

1. Joe Marler – 7/10
Provided solid platform at scrum time.
2. Dylan Hartley – 5/10
Poor line out throwing and quiet in open play.
3. Dan Cole 7/10
Strong scrummaging but gave away too many penalties. Solid first performance back from injury nevertheless.
4. Dave Attwood – 7/10
Colossal carries and work rate.
5. George Kruis – 6/10
Quiet first start but full of promise, did the dirty laundry effectively.
6. James Haskell – 9/10
Magnificent performance. Dynamic in attack and dogged in defence. Influence of his style of play should not be underestimated.
7. Chris Robshaw – 8/10
Good tackle count and managed the game well.
8. Billy Vunipola – 7/10
Clearly marked by the Welsh, solid but not spectacular.
9. Ben Youngs – 8/10
Box kicked very well and brought forwards into the game effectively, while still looking dangerous enough around the breakdown to keep the Welsh
10. George Ford – 8/10
Mature and clinical. Silenced any who criticised his kicking ability under pressure.
11. Jonny May – 6/10
Defensively exposed once or twice and quiet in attack.
12. Luther Burrell – 6/10
Kept Roberts quiet for most of the game but was limited in attack
13. Jonathan Joseph – 8/10
Tremendous solo try. Looked dangerous every time he got the ball.
14. Anthony Watson – 8/10
Good finish for the first try and elusive counter-attacking. Also contained North very effectively.
15. Mike Brown – 7/10
Set up first try with the grubber and solid under the high ball as usual. However,  still seems to be outclassed by Halfpenny.
James Haskell
But for the post, Rob Stevenson’s man of the match James Haskell, would have added another try
Wales
1. Gethin Jenkins – 4/10
Losses at scrum time proved costly. Did not influence the game much in the loose.
2. Richard Hibbard – 5/10
Unusually quiet but line out worked well enough.
3. Samson Lee – 5/10
Struggled at times at the scrum but put in a big shift in defence.
4. Jake Ball – 7/10
Good shift in defence and attack. Carried particularly effectively.
5. Alan Wyn Jones – 5/10
Did little to influence the game – unusually passive display for such a prolific leader.
6. Dan Lydiate – 6/10
Made his tackles as per usual but outplayed by Haskell around the park.
7. Sam Warburton – 8/10
Terrific in defence. Slowed down the ball effectively for the majority of the game.
8. Toby Faletau – 8/10
Wales’ best forward on the day. Mr Consistency provided dynamism that lacked throughout the rest of the side.
9. Rhys Webb – 7/10
Marked around the breakdown but finished off the first try well. Box kicking was inaccurate on more than one occasion.
10. Dan Biggar – 8/10
Monumental effort. Growing into the position with relish. However, he was unable to give Wales the creative spark needed in the second half.
11. George North – 6/10
Questions over whether he should have been on the pitch after collisions. Not given the space that makes him unplayable but still looked a threat.
12. Jamie Roberts – 6/10
Didn’t make his usual impact. Solid nonetheless.
13. Jonathan Davies – 6/10
Offered little threat in attack but managed the game well enough.
14. Alex Cuthbert – 4/10
Quiet in attack and vulnerable in defence. Sin bin cost the team, regardless of its unavoidability.
15. Leigh Halfpenny – 8/10
Classy display. Supreme in the air and threatening on the counter attack. Kicking was mostly up to his high standards.
Photograph: wikipedia