Cautious England can win World Cup if Lancaster takes the handbrake off
By Rob Stevenson
With less than a year until the eighth Rugby World Cup is decided on Twickenham’s hallowed turf, it is hard to imagine that Stuart Lancaster, Chris Robshaw and the rest of the England team are thinking about much else. Over the last year Lancaster’s men seemed to be gathering momentum with impressive Six Nations performances. However, having lost their last five test matches, many will question their form going into the year of the World Cup.
The changes that Lancaster, Andy Farrell, Mike Catt and Graham Rowntree have implemented since the disastrous events of the 2011 World Cup have been remarkable. The difference in the side’s ethos, both on and off the pitch, has been clear for all to see. There is no need for England to panic just yet. Four of the five consecutive losses have been to the All Blacks (World Champions and top of the IRB’s rankings) and the fifth was to South Africa – an exceptional side in their own right.
If England are to win the World Cup next year, they will need to beat sides of the calibre of New Zealand and South Africa. It is imperative, therefore, that Lancaster picks the right 15 men for the job. If the England Head Coach had a weakness, a strong case can be made for it being his selection policy, which has been increasingly conservative. England need to be brave and attempt to match the flair and creativity of the Southern Hemisphere.
The obvious place to start is with the removal of Owen Farrell from the position of fly half. Since taking over from Charlie Hodgson two years ago, Farrell has provided very little in the way of expansive playmaking. Taking into consideration the firepower that England could field in the outside channels, this lack of creativity cannot exist if England are to challenge the top sides in the world. Both George Ford and Danny Cipriani offer a brand of rugby that breaks oppositions down. Farrell is a fantastic goal kicker and a solid defender, both
invaluable assets to the team, but not at the expense of effective playmaking. He would be far less detrimental to the team’s playing in the centres. There are unanswered questions over Ford and Cipriani’s ability to kick points under pressure because they have simply not been given the chance to do so in test match rugby. If England are to play with a style that will challenge the Southern Hemisphere, Farrell must be pushed wider or removed altogether.
England’s back row also presents selection headaches. Chris Robshaw is, quite rightly, virtually guaranteed his place by virtue of his captaincy. Lancaster has recently put his faith in Tom Wood and Billy Vunipola to make up the two other spots. Both are players able to cope with test match rugby. However, balance is the key to a successful back row. In their World Cup winning team of 2003, England had a ball carrier in the form of Dallaglio, a breakdown expert in Neil Back and an enforcer in Richard Hill. As it stands, England lack a pure breakdown expert and need to find the right man for their carrying role. I believe that the two men for the job are James Haskell and Ben Morgan. Haskell offers far more expertise in the dark arts of the breakdown and is a more effective carrier of the ball as well as being a giant of a man, which makes Wood’s lineout proficiency dispensable. If Lancaster is to pick on form, Morgan must be in the side. His ball carrying capability and athleticism set him apart from Wood and Vunipola. These selections, one feels, could prove to be the making or breaking of England’s World Cup hopes.

In the outside backs, Lancaster is blessed by a wealth of excitement and youth. Mike Brown and Manu Tuilagi stand out as players who almost seem to pick themselves. Semesa Rokoduguni has also been in sensational form for Bath this season and should be in the frame after recovering from injury. These are players that teams, even the Southern Hemisphere giants, will fear. It is in these outside backs that Lancaster should be advised most strongly to pick the most unpredictable, exciting and elusive players available to him. The selection of Kyle Eastmond indicates a step in the right direction by Lancaster. Hopefully he will not be dropped to accommodate Billy Twelvetrees, Luther Burrell or Brad Barritt. Eastmond and Tuilagi would be a formidable attacking force and, as long as their defensive shape is sorted in the next year, a real strength of the England team.
One area where England need not worry is the front five. Graham Rowntree has proved he is worth his weight in gold by providing the England side with a dominant set piece and driving maul. There are at least three loosehead props and hookers who could more than an adequate job come next year. Strength in depth at tighthead prop remains a slight worry as long as Dan Cole remains injured but Dave Wilson has shown his quality since being given the jersey.
England have the players to challenge the best teams in both hemispheres. If Lancaster makes the right selections, they could well go all the way. There has been lots of talk of Twickenham becoming a fortress, this needs to be the case in the next year – the home advantage at a World Cup is invaluable. In the wake of defeats to New Zealand and South Africa, England should not panic but realise that if they are to lift the Webb Ellis Cup in a year’s time, these are the teams they will need to beat.
Photograph: commons.wikimedia

