Viva la Vida? – Coldplay’s cultural contribution and the “communal aesthetic”
Coldplay’s music is a very good example of what I call the ‘communal aesthetic’, which attempts to provoke lonely, insecure emotions through an art form. I believe the communal aesthetic is a product of modern alienation so we must define this first.
We do not live in communities; we live in ‘networks.’ In a community you make contact and develop bonds with a wide range of people of different ages, professions and so on, just through the normal interaction of general life. We can also think of a community as simply having a strong social life.
However, a network offers thin contact with a restricted ‘web’ of people. For instance, a school or workplace is a network, where you are put with a specific age group or those who do a specific occupation, and you are kept restricted to those people.
The central element of living in networks is that relationships are fleeting and shallow, and you are asked to suppress all the parts of yourself except the network interest part – the part of you that can laugh with people of exactly the same age, or to do the same repetitive task all day in a highly specialised work environment. Adam Smith was prophetic when he described how the division of labour would act as a ‘mental mutilation’, creating ignorant and insular human beings.
I believe that the pathological state which eventually develops out of these constant repetitions of thin contact is a feeling that your ‘friends’ and ‘colleagues’ don’t really care about you beyond what you can do for them. Do you feel that about the majority of people you know?
Another important element in our cultural tendency is to ‘amuse ourselves to death’. As a culture we spend an enormous amount of time absorbed in television and other mediums like the internet, and even now newspapers which try to mimic televisions effect; namely by vaudeville and instant gratification through visual and aural stimulation. The world given to us by this rapid media flow is largely devoid of logical order and meaning.
Television certainly has the ability to short-circuit thought, to take logical, critical thinking and channel it into a giddy nothingness. Take Question Time; its prominence as a political debate programme only shows how de-politicised our culture is. Watch the program; it has no arguments or counter-arguments, no scrutinising of assumption, no explanations, no elaboration and no definitions. It is a masquerade of political debate.
However, television does not have to be harmful in small doses. But if the focus of television is entertainment and television is the paradigm for public discussion, can we say that television has made entertainment itself the natural format for the representation of our experience?
Neil Postman, the media theorist and cultural critic, agrees: “as typography once dictated the style of conducting style, politics, religion, business, education, law and other important social matters, television now takes command. In courtrooms, classrooms, operating rooms, board rooms, churches and even airplanes, Americans no longer talk to each other, they entertain each other. They do not exchange ideas; they exchange images. They do not argue with propositions; they argue with good looks, celebrities and commercials.” I think we can see this in the tendency for group mentality in schools; they give instant gratification and shallow pleasures in the same way TV does. The humanist and essayist Aldous Huxley described group mentality as ‘herd poisoning’, which he believed acts like “an active, extraverted drug. The crowd intoxicated individual escapes from responsibility, intelligence and morality into a kind of frantic, animal mindlessness.” It is the weak, dull social organisation of empty minds.
I think the people that emerge from this are people with ‘outer’ and ‘inner’ personalities. Their ‘outer’ personality is made up of bits and pieces they’ve seen off TV, and bits and pieces they’ve used to manipulate teachers and the few friends they have; their ‘inner’ personality is rarely exposed, and recoils from intimacy because it has not been developed through activities such as a strong, diverse social life, and critical thinking skills brought on by reading.
Now, for Coldplay. Let’s say a performer is looking for success and attention; it follows that one route would be to see what the audience wants and what their needs are. If their needs are perceived to be emotional insecurity and alienation, then appealing to those is one way to gain the love of the audience; a magnified, artificial love which is much wanted by a population in which self-esteem is increasingly seeked through performance.
What feeds Coldplay’s success is simple; when people do not belong to a community they will look for artificial integration into one. In this sense the communal aesthetic is very conservative, because it doesn’t try and solve these problems by moving away from a major cause of them – namely media saturation and the western norm of saturating yourself with shallow pleasures – it chooses to solve them by re-branding the media consumed.
The question that remains: are people willing to purge themselves of their anti-social behaviourisms and open up socially?
