Former Chief Executive of the Royal Bank of Scotland, Sir Fred Goodwin, ran a major bank into the ground. Should he be allowed to keep his pension?
All are equal under the law
Mark Harmstone
Desperate times, so they say, call for desperate measures – and the Labour Party is in very desperate times indeed. Almost certainly facing a drubbing at the rapidly approaching general election, Gordon et al. seem to have reverted to a core voters strategy in an aim to prevent their die-hard supporters from lapsing into apathy, or worse, Conservatism. Thatcher may have had the Falklands, but Brown has found his Galtieri in Sir Fred Goodwin, one of the few men in Britain more hated than the Prime Minister. His actions, it is argued, were responsible for the collapse of the Royal Bank of Scotland; yet, rather than being punished, he has instead been rewarded with a pension of over £700,000 a year.
Sir Fred’s situation may or may not be immoral, but it is certainly just. His pension was agreed in the days before RBS’s nationalization, and none but the most ardent socialist would deny the right of a private enterprise to remunerate its chief executive however it wishes. The fact that the bank is now owned by the state is irrelevant: Goodwin’s contract is still binding.
Harriet Harman, herself a solicitor and QC, implicitly acknowledged this when she noted that the pension “might be enforceable in a court of law… but it’s not enforceable in the court of public opinion”. The boundary between democracy and populism has always been blurred, but Harman’s words definitely cross the line. To retroactively alter contract law, for the sake of a few votes, seems folly in the extreme; doubly so, when one considers that the ‘credit crunch’ at its heart is nothing but a lack of confidence. If Harman rewrites the rules, what will there be left to trust?
Vince Cable, in Prime Minister’s Questions of 6th March, called upon the government to deprive Goodwin of his pension using existing rules regarding corporate negligence. I agree: let them, but the decision should be made by a fair trial in a court of law. The “court of public opinion” is nothing but mob rule. What Harman is suggesting is effectively a bill of attainder, whereby Parliament declares a person to be guilty of a crime, without going through any of the troublesome business of evidence and judges.
The last time such a thing was considered was in the dying days of the Second World War, when Churchill was talked out of getting Parliament to let him have all the high-profile Nazi leaders summarily executed. Spin as they might, I doubt the government will be able to convince anyone that Goodwin is in quite the same league of evil as Dr. Mengele.
The whole proposal would not even be an issue in the States, whose Constitution specifically forbids post-facto legislation. Article 7 of the European Convention on Human Rights, though a good deal more woolly, would also seem to guard against it; regardless, Parliament is still sovereign, and a government committing such gross constitutional vandalism would not be likely to obey such European niceties.
Assume, for a moment, that Harriet gets her way, and Sir Fred is officially designated a Naughty Boy and has his pocket money stopped. Who will be next, now that the precedent has been set? Goodwin’s role is merely symbolic; £700,000 may sound a lot, but it is a drop in the ocean compared to the vast sums already squandered in dealing with the crisis.
More “greedy bankers” will inevitably follow, as will anyone else regarded as being in any way complicit in the whole affair. It is a slippery slope, leading to arbitrary rule: once Parliament has awarded itself the moral right to punish individuals in such a matter, it will not relinquish it easily. At the risk of invoking Godwin’s Law, it is tempting to misquote Martin Niemöller here: “First they came for the bankers, and I did not speak out—because I was not a banker.”
Sir Fred may be infuriatingly smug, but that is all the more reason to defend him. We are all equal under the law, and there is no such thing as an objective moral judgement: once it is ruled that there is a category of ‘undesirables’ for which the law does not provide full protection, this category will grow and grow until it engulfs anybody deemed vaguely irritating to the state.
It is for this very reason that the BNP is still allowed to operate: there is only the slightest of differences between banning the Nationalists and banning the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats.
Retroactive, pseudo-judicial impositions have been useful tools of political manouvering for Labour in the past: in 1997, Blair passed a windfall tax on the profits of the privatized utility companies. It had been promised in his manifesto, on which he won a landslide majority. Then, as now, money and the incumbent government’s economic record were hot topics – and the promise of strong, seemingly principled action was one the electorate bought.
If Harman wishes Goodwin to be deprived in such an illiberal manner, I suggest she urge her boss to dissolve Parliament and call a general election. Somehow, though, I don’t think that’s going to happen.
A conflict of law and justice
Chris Wright
I remember once seeing a poster in Edinburgh airport in which Sir Jackie Stewart, three times Formula One champion and childhood sporting hero of Sir Fred Goodwin, explained: “Sport and RBS. Both global and driven by competition and success.”
You have to worry about those who enjoy fast and expensive cars. Goodwin’s style as head of the Royal Bank of Scotland was typical of the shallow competitiveness of people who equate winning with being worthwhile humans. Sir Fred’s ambitions for RBS were aggressively international.
What had traditionally been a cautious bank entered into ambitious expansion, including the development of a substantial American banking network, which exposed RBS to the toxic assets of the sub-prime mortgage market. Sir Fred built lavish new headquarters both in Edinburgh and in Conneticut, whilst RBS’s hostile takeover of Natwest earned Sir Fred his reputation for ruthlessness. There was a rather unpleasant mood of Scottish pride as the grammar school boy from Paisley saw 18,000 English heads roll.
The Natwest deal subsequently became the model for RBS’s part in the largest banking takeover in history. In 2007, Sir Fred moved to buy up a large part of the failing Dutch bank, ABN Amro, for much more than any serious analyst thought it was worth. The ABN Amro move makes it clear that Sir Fred simply wasn’t interested in a rational analysis of risk. And why should he have been? The opportunity for personal success and glory was immense, but when a banker like Sir Fred fails miserably he is still left with considerable personal wealth.
Sir Fred’s excessive risk-taking has delivered losses of £24.1 billion to RBS and incalculable damage to the economy. To add insult to injury, when RBS had to be rescued by the taxpayer, Sir Fred is on record as having described his dealings with the government as “less of a negotiation, more of a drive-by shooting”. To feel hard done by when you have run an important bank into ruin is a pretty extraordinary failure of moral imagination.
Goodwin is 50 years old. As it stands, till the day he dies he will annually receive £693,000 as a pension from a company now the government’s responsibility. He would be rich without this money, but he has nonetheless decided that he will not compromise his contractual right: he has chosen to disgrace himself rather than give up his pension, which tells us that he must really want it. Why should we let him have it?
The answer, of course, is that his contract is legally binding, and the rule of law is something more valuable than the millions of pounds we will be giving to Sir Fred. To retrospectively alter his pension arrangements would set a terrible precedent of government overriding the law to satisfy popular opinion.
I take the point, but it is mistaken for two reasons. The first is that extraordinary situations don’t generate precedents. It is unprecedented for the government to have to rescue a major bank. There is no serious danger of anyone invoking the Goodwin pension precendent to cancel contractual arrangements in ordinary circumstances.
The second is that the financial crash raises the profound issue of how capitalism incorporates justice, and only an excess of wealth and security can induce us to forget that this problem should be taken as earnestly as the principles of liberal democracy. Those who have characterised the pension proposal as mob rule seem to me to be extraordinarily insensitive to the moral seriousness of the popular sentiment against greedy and incompotent bankers. Nobody is demanding a lynching. All that is being considered is taking action to deny Sir Fred his right to get even more obscenely wealthy from the institution he has crippled. This is not a violent or a self-pitying populism: it is an expression of anger that is entirely contained within reasonable norms of fairness.
Some have claimed that capitalism is now in crisis. This is merely wishful thinking on the part of deluded utopians. Capitalism will continue indefinitely, and so it should. But capitalism’s moral authority really is in crisis. The experience of Fascism is that anti-democratic populism is more dangerous than anyone imagined it could be. This is what we face if the current resentment for bankers mutates into something altogether less reasonable. Sir Fred has eschewed the opportunity to make a ‘gesture of goodwill’ by volunteering his pension: to forcefully rescind it would be capitalism’s gesture of goodwill, its olive branch to the people.
Yes, we would be singling out one man without untangling the complex causes of the financial crash. But it’s difficult to think of a more deserving scapegoat. Goodwin was a bad banker in a system that did not motivate him to be a good one, but he could not find the motivation within himself to be responsible. To deny Sir Fred his pension would be a bold symbolic act that could help introduce a new morally conscientious banking culture.
