Viruses aren’t conscious: why our fear is driving Monkeypox

By Harvey Joyce

With the world stumbling out of one pandemic to another, many countries and organisations are now declaring Monkeypox a major concern as cases rise in the UK and around the world. Governments have already been criticised for their handling of the virus. With 98% of reported cases being men who have sex with other men, many LGBTQ+ critics feel that the specific targeting of gay and bisexual men is creating false perceptions in these communities, reminiscent of the days of HIV and Aids. However, this is not the same.

The collective trauma faced by the LGBTQ+ community during the Aids crisis cannot be understated. People faced an onslaught of hostility from the pubic, governments and the media. Headlines flooded newspapers such as The Mail on Sunday’s “Britain threatened by gay virus plague” and The Sun’s “I’d shoot my son if he has Aids, says vicar!” The chief constable of Greater Manchester, and the self-proclaimed ‘God’s copper’, Sir James Anderton said Aids victims were “swirling around in a human cesspit of their own making”, these common beliefs were bolstered by waves of discriminatory legislation by Thatcher’s government.

The ramifications of this mass victim-blaming can still be felt to this day, with misconceptions still tainting public opinion. The connotations of being ‘dirty’ or ‘sinful’ is still a major reason as to why people don’t get tested for HIV, delaying treatment. Due to the falsification that HIV/Aids are still only a ‘gay issue’, there are now more straight people being diagnosed with HIV than gay and bisexual people in recent years. Regardless of infection rates, the development of new treatments and drugs have allowed HIV positive individuals to live completely normal lives. HIV has changed and that should be celebrated.

The ramifications of this mass victim-blaming can still be felt to this day, with misconceptions still tainting public opinion

The crucial difference with the response to Monkeypox is that governments and experts are using a completely different rhetoric. We have a much better understanding of Monkeypox and its symptoms (which are typically mild), and already have effective vaccines for the related smallpox virus in the UK. This is wholly different to the beginning of the HIV/Aids crisis, which was shrouded in mystery and misery as young men were tragically dying of an unknown illness.

Viruses aren’t conscious: they don’t latch onto a specific race, gender, or sexual orientation. They only want to spread and replicate themselves by whatever means necessary. Thus, there has been a clear emphasis by experts that anybody can get Monkeypox, so nobody should be complacent.

But why are gay and bisexual men more likely to get it? While some have pointed out the selection bias in reporting, as gay and bisexual men a more likely to routinely test themselves at clinics, there is still an overwhelming proportion of gay and bisexual men at risk. Like HIV/Aids, Monkeypox is not a sexually transmitted virus, rather it is more effective at spreading in close spaces and bodily fluids. A significant number of new infections in straight people has been through drug use. Although, this means that it is more likely to spread in networks where men have a lot of sex, especially with anonymous partners.

Of course, there is nothing wrong with sex: it is a part of the human experience. As society has evolved, we have become more accepting of this, and government legislation has slowly started to reflect that.

Viruses aren’t conscious: they don’t latch onto a specific race, gender, or sexual orientation

The issue with the response to HIV/Aids was not that gay and bisexual men were targeted, it was because these groups were being stigmatised and left to die without help. We can’t be scared of targeting specific groups, the real homophobia is ignoring people in need.

Now this doesn’t mean the response so far has been flawless. The World Health Organisation suggesting that people should abstain from sex or limit sexual partners has always been proven ineffective historically. This type of messaging deepens the stigma of gay and bisexual men being promiscuous. 

The main issue in tackling this pandemic has been the weak public funding to health services that have already been weakened by Coronavirus. This has resulted in resources being removed for sexual health services, which reduces their ability to test for Monkeypox or HIV. The government’s slow vaccine rollout has also hindered the ability to control the spread, especially at large scale events like Pride. Governments and experts need to renew their efforts on testing and targeted awareness. We cannot let fear stop us from helping people.

Illustration by: Anna Kuptsova