VC leaves students guessing over proposed future tuition fee rises
THE LONG BATTLE being fought by UK students against rising tuition fees saw a dramatic shift in tone earlier this month following the annual NUS conference in Blackpool.
In a historic move, delegates at the conference on 1 – 3 April voted for the first time to stop campaigning for free tuition, a stance which they had held since well before the government introduced the first means-tested fees in 1998.
DSU president Flo Herbert was among the eleven delegates from Durham and strongly agreed with the proposals, citing the speed at which the landscape has changed in the past year – similar recommendations made by 2006-07 president Alex Duncan at last year’s conference were laughed and booed out of court, she said. She told Palatinate:
“I am glad that enough people in the student movement have woken up and realised that if we just shout about free education we are not going to be listened to. Variable fees have the potential to ruin the higher education system in this country and we should be very clear that that is the fight for 2009.”
Speaking exclusively to Palatinate, Durham Vice-Chancellor Chris Higgins showed his support for what he called “a very mature and sensible decision”. Those on the left have branded the change in policy as an inevitable death of idealism, but Higgins slams this view, saying:
“If you’re not realistic, you never achieve anything. Yes, it would be truly wonderful if we had free tertiary education for everybody, but I’m afraid life is just not like that.”
The hope is that this shift of focus will allow NUS to concentrate on campaigning to keep the status quo. Removing or raising the tuition cap could produce a system of variable fees, with institutions charging whatever they chose dependent on the quality of education offered.
Under this system, Durham would most likely place itself at the top end – Higgins comments that “it costs a lot more money to run Durham than it does to run some other universities because of all the facilities and excellent things we have, which are why students want to come here.”
DSU vehemently opposes the variable fee concept, claiming that academic standards would slip if students felt put off by Durham’s high fees and went instead for cheaper, “economy” options. Last week saw the roll-out of a campaign across Durham under the banner ‘education supermarket?’, designed to calculate Durham’s debt and find a “better, fairer solution to funding higher education”.
Either way, Higgins makes it clear that Durham needs more money – and insists that the responsibility of deciding how to get it lies with the government. “Universities are not actually free to make many decisions. We can’t at the moment charge what we think is appropriate, even if we wanted to, because of government controls.”
Whether the fee cap will be lifted after next year’s crucial government review, he says, is “unpredictable. I think if you’d asked me a year ago, I would’ve said that the fee cap was going to be raised. I’m not so sure now. I think genuinely there isn’t a decision made, so I think there is a chance for the students to influence that decision.”
Higgins emphasises how the university will ensure that those who cannot afford higher education will always be provided with bursaries and scholarships. However, this does not include the many students well-off enough not to qualify for grants but still taking out full loans. Such is the make-up of much of Durham’s middle-class intake: if variable fees come into effect, won’t they simply choose a cheaper university to avoid debt?
“Durham is one of those universities which provides an education, not a training,” Higgins claims, “and I think that most of our students are broad-minded enough to understand that that is what they need.”
That’s an old motto – learning for the sake of learning. But will students really choose something this romanticised in the face of escalating costs?
“Yes, we need to make sure people do. It’s all very well having a society full of people who can screw widgets together, but you need leaders who are going to bring through new ideas, new ways of doing things.”
Though Higgins is defiant, the reality is that students are increasingly opting for the kinds of vocational degrees with clear paths to steady salaries that Durham does not offer. As the rest of the country moves in this way, traditional institutions like Durham could be left behind – as could the postgraduate community, which Flo Herbert claims would see a fall in its numbers as students move out of the pricey world of academia.
Higgins challenges this, citing a 50% increase in postgraduate numbers in the last year – but this figure is for students who have not yet been hit by the £3000 ‘top-up’ fees introduced two years ago, let alone possible higher fees to come.
NUS is prepared for a fight. President-elect Wes Streeting, who was voted in at this month’s conference, recently told the Times Higher Education Supplement that “all hell” would break loose if the government attempted to lift the cap.
However, NUS will need to unite before any constructive campaign can be possible. A series of major constitutional reforms, designed to allow “more room for students to get involved”, were defeated at the conference by just 25 votes, much to the dismay of those clamouring for a clearer structure to the union, which represents around 5 million students in the UK.
