Palatinate considers Olympic Games crisis

Palatinate turned to former editor Alice Xin Liu for an inside perspective on the recent Tibetan monk protests, and the furore surrounding the Olympic torch relay which has dominated its journey around the world. Alice grew up in China and left for England at the age of seven, but has returned to Beijing every summer for 15 years. After 15 years abroad she has returned to China and is currently working for The Guardian in Beijing.

FIRST OF ALL, it is not going to be easy to describe the clashing of Western and Chinese media concerning the issue of Tibet. To begin with, when the March 14th incident happened whereupon Tibetans, including Buddhist monks, attacked ethnic Han and Hui Chinese dwellers and shop-keepers in Lhasa, the capital of Tibet, the Chinese media did not react straight away. As the communist party’s mouth organ, they, like the state, did not want to give the western media any impetus to start writing about “Chinese communist regime oppression” in the same vein as reporting the events of June 4th, 1989 – the “Tiananmen Massacre”. Chinese media outlets simply released a uniformed report, mainly calling the Tibetan rioters “a small number of separatists” who are “beating, smashing and stealing” on the streets of Lhasa.

That was the day when all foreign media with stations and bureaus in Beijing made the pointless effort of trying to enter Lhasa – pointless because as soon as the ethnic clashes began, Lhasa was immediately closed off to all foreigners, not to mention journalists. Most of the foreign journalists then went around the borders of Tibet, such as Gansu, Sichuan, Qinghai and Yunnan provinces. The proximity of these places to Tibet meant that they contained Tibetan Autonomous Regions, so it was deemed the next best thing.

From these disparate locations reporters such as Mark Magnier from the LA Times and Jonathan Watts from the Guardian made their observations of the crisis – for an example see Watts’ “Seven days not in Tibet” video on the Guardian Unlimited website. The only journalist who happened to be in Lhasa at the time was James Miles of the Economist. Miles has written about the ethnic clashes in a balanced fashion, and his interview with CNN is often quoted.

However, disaster for western reporting struck when CNN’s report of March 14th used a picture of a Chinese military truck moving into Lhasa which had been edited. The original showed Tibetans throwing rocks at the truck, but this detail was cropped out of the picture. Since then, an attack on western media in China has begun – happening at first with netizens (cybercitizens actively involved in online communities), but which is also supported by the government. Internet forums have been taken over by angry netizens citing that western media is biased, and aimed at demonizing China. Websites such as anti-cnn.com (which is worth a look) have since become popular. Another strange but prolific campaign on cyberspace is the recent msn “heart China” campaign, which has been all the rage since last week. More and more Chinese msn users are now adding the “(L) CHINA” in front of their msn names, which appears as a red heart in front of the word CHINA in capitals. The effect of this is a growing list of msn users who are expressing their support for China, in opposition to western ‘media bashing’ of China. The sentiment of these campaigns has also been reflected in the Chinese state media, which has run stories about the so-called ‘bias’ of western media.

There is no way that the Chinese government’s position on Tibet will change. In a country where the main concern for the state is to prevent its citizens from looking at an issue from all the different angles, it would be absolutely detrimental to inform its people of anything BUT the idea that Tibet is, and always will be, a part of China. National stability is of the utmost importance because China has had a long history of bloodshed – there was almost no stability prior to when Emperor Qin united all of China (the different provinces were mini-countries themselves, and the country was also subject to constant invasion and occupation). Thus, the government let Tibet become a separate country.

This summer’s Olympics will see a bigger media presence from around the world, but, this will not mean the Chinese media will open up because of it. The period leading up to the Olympics is meant to be a time of open-door policy to journalists, when a pyramid of opinion should be the rule of the day. The Chinese government will not stop limiting freedoms, because they are afraid of the country falling to pieces and into political chaos. China becoming divided would be disastrous, making economic growth rates hard to maintain, ensuring China will not develop at the rate it has been for the past thirty years since the opening up and reform advocated by Deng Xiaoping. Therefore China will not halt its efforts to make national “unity” a top concern. Just because foreign journalists are entering the country does not mean their priority of keeping national disintegration at bay is abandoned. Their tone regarding media freedom and where western journalists can go and the kind of stories they can write may change during the few months bracketing the Olympics – but it won’t continue in years to come.


Professor Gerald Chan is a lecturer in the School of Government and International Affairs. His area of expertise includes Chinese politics and foreign policy.

The street protests that disrupted the Olympic torch relays in London, Paris and San Francisco in early April have put China’s human rights record under the spotlight. Chinese leaders had hoped for a smooth run-up to the Games. They wanted to use the sports extravaganza to mark China’s remarkable rise, but they have been disappointed by the outbreak of recent events.

The crackdown on protesting Buddhist monks in Lhasa, capital of Tibet, in March played into the hands of the Tibetan independence movement and anti-China activists. The publicity generated by the riots in Tibet, the disruptions to the torch relays, and competition from cheap Chinese exports have hardened Western public opinion against China.

Political leaders have thrown in their lots. German Chancellor Angela Merkel, British Prime Minister Gordon Brown, and the UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon have all said that they would not attend the opening ceremony of the Beijing Olympics. French President Nicolas Sarkozy is mulling over whether he will attend or not, depending on whether China will take measures to ease the Tibetan situation and commence talks with the Dalai Lama, the Tibetan’s spiritual leaders and head of the government-in-exile based in Daresalam, India. US President George Bush is urged by all three presidential candidates, Hillary Clinton, Barak Obama and John McCain, to abstain from the opening ceremony. At present the US government takes a cautious, diplomatic stance on dealing with China, contrasting some European countries which have adopted a more confrontational approach. Given the diversity within the group, the EU’s approach to China is somewhat mixed and confused, trying to balance the need to uphold human rights principles with the need to trade with a rising power.

Such controversies have troubled the Beijing leadership. Worried about the damage done to China’s international image and reputation as a responsible member of the international community, the Chinese government has taken steps to try to ease the situation. Chinese President Hu Juntao, in a public statement made on 11 April, said that his officials were ready to talk to the Dalai Lama if he stopped sabotaging the Games. Hu said that the issue of Tibet was a domestic one and the unrest there had nothing to do with human rights, religion, or ethnic differences.

The Dalai Lama appears moderate. He said that Beijing deserved to host the Games, but he urged China to give more freedom to Tibetans in the country. He reiterated that Tibet was a part of China, and he even threatened to resign as the spiritual head if the majority of Tibetans took to violence and destruction.

The spokesperson for the Beijing Organising Committee of the Olympic Games said that the torch relay would go ahead as planned. The Chinese government will do all it can to mitigate any possible disturbances to the remaining legs of the relay. It has started to hire foreign PR firms to advise ways to tackle the waves of anti-Chinese protests. The Chinese Ambassador to the UK, Fu Ying, has called for a better understanding of the situation in Tibet and blamed the media in the West for biased reporting.

The protests which have marred the Olympic event are unprecedented in history. Jacques Rogge, President of the International Olympic Committee, while visiting Beijing in April to inspect the preparation of the Games, said that the Olympics Games faced a crisis. He urged the Chinese government to talk to the Dalai Lama. Beijing mildly rebuked Rogge, saying that politics should not intervene in sport. Yet Rogge was obviously trying to strike a delicate balance between Beijing’s defiance and global pressure. His position reflects that of walking a tightrope; he needs to be seen to be putting pressure on Beijing to change but, on the other hand, he has to support Beijing in organising the Games. Rogge pointed out that when the right to host the Games was awarded to Beijing some seven years ago, China promised to run a Green Olympics, improve its human rights record and allow greater press freedom.

Several implications have become apparent. Grass-roots protests, organised by NGOs and other actors, protesting against globalization, are likely to continue to haunt the Olympic Games in Beijing, London or elsewhere in the years to come. The 2012 London Olympics could become a venue for popular protests if, for example, British troops still remain in Iraq. Other major events, such as future summit meetings of world leaders, could become targets for popular dissent.

Domestically, because of the worsening situation in Tibet, Beijing has softened its attitude towards Taiwan. Vincent Siew, Taiwan’s vice-president elect, who attended the Boao Forum in China in April, received an unusually warm welcome extended by Chinese leaders, including Hu.

The Chinese government is under immense international pressure to moderate its dealings with Tibet and human rights issues. Beijing seems willing to change, but it is difficult to know the exact point beyond which excessive pressure on Beijing might backfire and roll back what has been achieved so far in persuading Beijing to become more accommodating in the field of human rights.