Valentine’s Day Playlists: healing heartbreak or causing earache?

By Myrtle Watts

Spotify seems to have a playlist for every occasion. They range from the broad – ‘Feel Good Beats’ – to the niche – ‘Music for Plants’ – to the downright obscure – ‘Beast Mode Christian’. Seemingly, whatever your mood, someone at the Spotify offices has made a playlist to cater for it. This extends to national holidays (their ‘Christmas Hits’ playlist is the only thing I listen to for the whole of December), including, of course, Valentine’s Day. Their ‘Valentine’s Day Love’ playlist has nearly 600,000 saves, with the description ‘the most romantic tracks of all time, featuring today’s hits and all the classics.’ Given the nature of a holiday like Valentine’s Day though, I have to ask, who is actually listening to this playlist?

There are two types of people on Valentine’s Day: the hopelessly single and those in a relationship. And even then, not everyone who is coupled up particularly celebrates the occasion. For those who are spending the day with a loved one, surely this generic Spotify playlist is the last thing you’re listening to. While it has a cohesive theme, the playlist erratically jumps from genre to genre and decade to decade. 

It reads as though someone did a Ctrl+F for songs that have the word ‘love’ in the title and then just added them all to a playlist 

I mean, in what scenario is it appropriate to listen to ‘Fade Into You’ by Mazzy Star, immediately followed by ‘Love On Top’ by Beyoncé? I think the sheer number of key changes in the latter would give anyone whiplash, especially when it’s followed by ‘The Night We Met’ by Lord Huron. 

Not only is the playlist a nightmare to listen to (on shuffle or otherwise), but the very concept of a Spotify-made Valentine’s Day playlist doesn’t gel. The Spotify-curated playlist for Christmas makes total sense. There’s a handful of good Christmas songs, they all kind of sound the same anyway, so Spotify just cuts out the middleman of having to piece them together yourself. 

But Valentine’s Day is such an intimate and personal holiday. If, for example, you’re planning on spending the evening at home with your partner and you decide to put on some music, what would possess you to use the generic Spotify-made one? If anything, that would kill the mood. Surely a hand-made playlist of music that is personal to you and your relationship is more indicative of a romantic evening. 

For most couples, if you’ve been together long enough, there’ll be certain songs, albums and artists that have some sort of significance to your relationship: maybe the song that was playing in Jimmy’s when you had your first kiss, or the band you first saw live together. If I’m trying to concoct a romantic atmosphere, that’s where my mind goes: not – and I cannot stress this enough – ‘Love On Top’ by Beyonce.

The impersonal, generic nature of the playlist represents the broader commodification of Valentine’s Day

For a day that is meant to be spent (for those who can) with loved ones, it should be highly personal. As we fall further down the spiral of late-stage capitalism, Valentine’s Day becomes more and more commercialised, with impersonal, identical heart-shaped gifts for sale in every supermarket. The Spotify playlist is just an extension of this. Why put in the effort to curate a playlist that includes songs representative of, and related to, your relationship, when an underpaid Spotify intern can do it for you? 

If you do plan on playing any music this Valentine’s Day, maybe think about something more personal

The playlist ultimately functions to strategically funnel more streams into Spotify’s most lucrative songs – it is nothing more than a cash grab. So, if you do plan on playing any music this Valentine’s Day, maybe think about something more personal. And for those who are single, perhaps Spotify’s ‘Classics for Crying’ or ‘Broken Heart’ might be a better fit – no judgement, we’ve all been there.

Image Credit: Mazzy Star – So Tonight I Might See Album Cover