A definitive ranking of the best Christmas songs of all time

By Myrtle Watts

We had our first dusting of snow in Durham recently, which can only mean one thing: Christmas is coming. As the holiday season begins, we will inevitably hear the same Christmas songs everywhere—in the pub, on the radio, or in any clothing shop or supermarket. Chances are you’ve formed strong opinions on these songs; I know I have. In case you haven’t and are looking to curate the perfect playlist, here is my personal ranking of the top 10 Christmas songs of all time.

10. Santa Baby – Kylie Minogue

 Kylie’s playful take Eartha Kitt’s original rendition sold over 600,000 copies and cracked the UK Top 40. And let’s not forget Michael Bublé’s infamous album cover, in which he changed “Santa Baby”, to “Santa Buddy”, and the request for a “light blue” car to a “steel blue” one (because steel blue is a much more manly colour, obviously). Anyway, the song is iconic and I torture myself every year by putting Kylie Minogue’s version on my playlist and cringing whenever it plays while my parents are in the room.

9. All I Want For Christmas Is You – Mariah Carey 

I believe this is perhaps the most overplayed song in the history of music. It’s certainly intensely Christmassy, with Mariah Carey demonstrating her huge range and technical vocal dexterity over the backdrop of bell chimes and approximately one million backing vocals. Sure, it’s cheesy—but isn’t that what Christmas is about? With over 30 chart-topping appearances worldwide, the public clearly agrees.

Here is my personal ranking of the top 10 Christmas songs of all time

8. Happy Xmas (War Is Over) – John Lennon, Yoko Ono

Lennon and Ono’s peace anthem remains just as poignant today as it was during the Vietnam War. Now a Christmas staple, its message of hope and activism earns it a place on any festive playlist.

7. Wonderful Christmastime – Paul McCartney

With playfully festive synths, this is a relatively stripped-back Christmas song compared to others on the list. Charting in the Top 10 in multiple countries, Paul proved that he wasn’t the only Beatles boy who could get in touch with his festive side.  

6. Mary’s Boy Child / Oh My Lord – Boney M.

Why settle for one Boney M. Christmas song when you can have two? This disco-gospel-pop hybrid recounts the nativity story with all the flair you’d expect from the band behind Rasputin. The UK’s Christmas number one in 1978, it remains a festive radio favourite.

5. I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus – The Jackson 5 

With baby Michael Jackson’s adorable vocals and humorous lyrics, this is easily the biggest bop on the list. The Jackson 5’s version is a cover of Jimmy Boyd’s 1952 original and became a four-week UK chart success, solidifying its place as a Christmas classic.

4. It’s Beginning to Look a Lot like Christmas – Michael Bublé 

Bublé is perhaps the twenty first century’s embodiment of Christmas itself. His whole festive album (aptly named Christmas) belongs on this list really, but if I had to pick just one song, it would be this. The introduction especially feels almost magical, and the moment I hear his crooning voice, it really does begin to look a lot like Christmas.

3. Fairytale of New York (feat. Kirsty MacColl) – The Pogues 

Officially the most-played Christmas song of the 21st century, there’s something about Shane MacGowan’s rough-around-the-edges vocals and Kirsty MacColl’s enthusiastic hurling of insults that makes this song so fun to listen to. 

2. Driving Home for Christmas – Chris Rea

Perhaps an unconventional choice for second place, but this understated, cosy song perfectly captures the feeling of heading home for the holidays. Since 2007, it has re-entered the UK charts annually, with Rea’s hopeful sentiment of reuniting with family echoed in the piano and guitar backing to make a cosy, Christmassy soundtrack to any December drive home.

It’s the third biggest song of all time in the UK, and for good reason

1. Last Christmas – Wham!

While some partake in ‘Whamageddon’, the game of trying to see how long you can go without hearing this particular song play, I instead revel in trying to listen to it as much as possible. Combining sales and streams, it’s the third biggest song of all time in the UK, and for good reason. What sets it apart is that it isn’t overwhelmingly jolly or upbeat like other Christmas songs. It’s about lost love and the painful memories that the holiday season can evoke, with George Michael’s soaring, melancholy vocals overlayed on some very 80s synths and perhaps the catchiest use of bells in a song ever, cementing it’s place on the top of my list.

Image: Ralf Liebhold