Using funding from foreign powers is morally bankrupt

They say every man has his price. It seems that so too does every institution.
Durham University claims that its involvement in recent controversy regarding Iranian and United States funding is still “remaining true to the principles of independent academic discovery”.
I would imagine that Dr Reza Molavi would disagree.
As was reported by Palatinate recently, former honorary research fellow and College tutor Dr Molavi resigned from the University’s Centre for Iranian Studies in 2010 for family reasons, and returned to Iran. There, he was arrested, is believed to be in solitary confinement, and reports suggest that he is suffering from an array of illnesses in prison. Additionally, there are those who believe that this arrest was pre-orchestrated, and that he was set up.
I would also imagine that Durham University’s own student, Ehsan Abdoh-Tabrizi would disagree.
Ehsan was arrested and sentenced to seven years in prison for participating in anti-government protests in Tehran in 2009. Until very recently, there had been no public response from the University to the arrest and captivity of its own student. When Durham’s response did arrive, they nobly stated that they were “extremely disappointed” to hear of his conviction.
I wonder, with utmost sincerity, just what “principles” the University claim they are holding to. It could be argued that these detentions occurred – or at least only became public knowledge– after the University accepted funding from Iran to hold a seminar here. But we should remember that the day the seminar was held, Tehran announced the execution of two young men it described as terrorists. Iran was hardly a beacon of political freedom and civil liberty, and the University cannot argue otherwise.
On one hand, the University may have accepted over $400,000 from the US State Department to run the Iranian seminars, and on the other, in 2010, were happy to accept a tidy sum of £5,000 from Iran to hold another. Last year, Dr Reza Molavi defended the University and denied that the seminar was pro-regime despite plenty of suggestions to the contrary. The same Dr Reza Molavi is now incarcerated somewhere in Iran.
A Durham University student told The Guardian last year that “If universities want to hold events they don’t have the resources in-house. This highlights how British universities are forced to turn to authoritarian regimes for funding”. Yet, it is not merely the fact that the University accepted this money that makes their actions unacceptable. It is the University’s apparently complete lack of regret for the damage it has caused. It has damaged its own reputation; that of its students and staff, and has done absolutely nothing to rectify it. A moral institution should realise that accepting funds from the Iranian government is simply unacceptable. Iran, according to the State of World Liberty index, is ranked 147 out of 159 in terms of economic and personal freedom. It executed 179 people in 2010 alone. Last month, two Iranian men were sentenced to death by stoning for homosexuality. Soheila Vahdati, who works with Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and a Iranian gay rights organisation, stated that the Iranian Government “don’t differentiate between rape and homosexual acts”.
Ask yourself, is it morally right to accept money – no matter how much – from that government?
Durham University may claim to hide under the guise of an intellectual institution aiming to promote buzzwords like “discovery”, “learning” and “personal development”. The truth is quite different. Durham University is a business, and the evidence for this is clear for all to see. The University’s recent attempts to centralise the collegiate system and restrict the independence and freedoms of the JCRs stands diametrically opposed to the very point of the college system. The motivation behind all of the centralisation plans? Money saving.
The Iranian seminars are simply another example of how the University’s main driving force is the acquisition of wealth; money to help facilitate, for example, the construction of the new Gateway building at the science site.
The University could repair the damage. It could apologise for its acceptance of money; it could campaign for the release of Dr. Molavi and Ehsan Abdoh-Tabrizi; it could donate a sum of money to a human rights charity. Instead, it seems to have chosen to bury its head in the sand and hope that the problem goes away. We can only hope that our University finds somehow a conscience. Quickly.
Alex Parsons says No:
As a politics student you get used to periodically seeing your department show up somewhere in Palatinate. I have no idea if we really do have more scandals or if the School of Government and International Affairs (SGIA) is just terrible at public relations, but you do get a vague feeling of impending doom whenever you see someone outside the ski-lodge (or ‘spy-lodge’ – free one there headline writers!) with a camera.
These latest allegations are possibly the worst yet: The department has been caught red-handed trying to promote human rights and democracy, training journalists and encouraging discussion of these issues in Iranian society. It goes without saying I am ashamed to be associated with such a morally-depraved department.
Bizarrely these are details that have to date been played down. You’d think when suspicious grants were being made one of the more important details would be what these grants were funding, but while most of the early coverage seemed to be inferring a fairly straightforward ‘Cash 4 Spying’ arrangement what we’re actually talking about is a series of seminars and events with the aim of promoting discourse about democracy, human rights within Iran (with a special focus on women’s advocacy) and effectively building human infrastructure for the continued progression of these goals, projects that in themselves would appear to be pretty ‘not terrible’ things to be doing.
That funding has come from the US government has raised some suspicions. However, the cables are clear it isn’t being funded out of some mysterious spy money pot but the Democracy Small Grants programme which seems to have laudable but restrained aims, having specific stipulations against using the money to agitate for regime change in Iran for example (something you wouldn’t expect to find in internal correspondence if it was actually an Orwellian fund devoted to undermining by any means possible).
While there’s the implication in the cables that contacts made and information obtained would be useful to US organisations, it’s fairly easy to make the case that this element has been overemphasised – in part because it’s the sexy part of the story, but also because the nature of the leak draws attention to it.
When we look at cables released through Wikileaks what needs to be remembered is that these are private communications intended for a specific function to a specific audience.
They’re not an objective assessment of the proposal, but one that at several levels is designed to convince US officials it’s a good idea to fund the projects. The comment that the event would offer ‘U.S. and USG observers a useful look inside Iranian politics at a grassroots level’ feels a lot like one of those points made to remind people that what you wanted to do anyway is also good for them, and the London Embassy in passing this request back home would also have had an interest in drawing attention to this to persuade the Department to follow their advised course of action.
In this case, the phrase is added as a note in brackets after a proposal stating that rather than the spies sitting behind a one-way mirror, the seminar planned to have US representatives taking part, and so the fact that they might hear and report back on proceedings would presumably have been fairly obvious to all involved.
The interest US officials showed in the ‘political cover’ has been read as something dodgy, but all it’s really saying is they believed that these projects were likely to be more worthwhile (as they can attract more influential figures) than ones run by individuals without these networks and so were a good candidate of grant money.
You could naturally take the opposite tact and say that any talk of Human Rights in the cables is a devious cover for a huge conspiracy of spying, but while we can’t say for sure if academics at the SGIA devised a series of ridiculously detailed proposals with the sole intention of using them as a cover to gather information for the Americans (who then talk in code about it even among themselves), I think the idea that they thought that their plans were actually good ideas, that would help make Iran a better place, and they were happy to work with the US to see them happen is a pretty reasonable interpretation.
Ethical implications seem to have been well considered in the proposals – the possibility that building a database to help Iranian Non-Governmental Organizations and media outlets coordinate and link up with each other could end up being used by Iranian authorities has been considered, and safeguards suggested.
From the cable it is really easy to see a positive side to this story and it seems to have been driven by generally noble aims. It’s hard to argue that spending money to build networks and positive discussion in unattractive regimes in ways that are neither violent nor particularly coercive is a bad thing and when one proposed project is named ‘Iran-U.S. Civil Society Engagement’ it’s hard to say there’s much emphasis on the US’s role here being secretive.
All that really separates this from the many other ‘academic applies for and receives grant’ stories is that this ended up appearing in US diplomatic cables – which automatically makes the story seem much more scandalous than it otherwise would be (it wouldn’t surprise me at all if more dodgy grants have been snuck out of various departments as press releases).
Naturally we don’t know for sure if these projects were ever funded or what form they eventually took, but from the cables I find it difficult to take anything but a positive impression of the motives involved and it’d be a shame if similar projects are harder to run in future as a result of this one’s exposure.
