US-Russia Tension Endangers Peace in Syria
By Anna Myers
Maybe Donald Trump struggles with teleprompters, joked Hillary Clinton at a charity dinner this week, ‘because it’s harder when you’re translating from the original Russian.’ But behind the joke is a serious issue. Not only is Russia accused of trying to influence the outcome of America’s presidential election, but the two countries stopped communicating after the collapse of a ceasefire agreement in Syria. If this reminds you of the Cold War, you are not the only one. Vitaly Churkin, the Russian ambassador to the UN, said that relations between the two countries had not been as bad since 1973. ‘This needs to stop’, said Mikhail Gorbachev, the 85-year-old former chief secretary of the Soviet Communist party, who was largely responsible for ending the Cold War. ‘The world has reached a dangerous point.’
The principal victim of the deteriorating relations is Syria. In early September, Russia and the US had agreed to a ceasefire there. The deal required both sides to halt all aerial bombardments, end attempts to gain further territory and allow ‘unimpeded and sustained humanitarian access’ to besieged areas in Syria. If the ceasefire held, the US and Russia would start planning joint attacks on IS. John Kerry, the US Secretary of State, was understandably cautious: ‘This is an opportunity, and no more than that until it becomes a reality.’ But it was an opportunity wasted. Talks fell apart when the US alleged that Russia attacked a UN aid convoy; Moscow claimed it was simply ‘monitoring’ the trucks and suggested that perhaps they had ‘caught fire’. After the ceasefire collapsed, the US state department said it was suspending communications with Russia.
American voters may also feel the consequence of the worsening relationship, for Russia seems to be interfering in the presidential election campaign. The US government has formally accused Russian hackers of stealing nearly 20,000 emails, which were then released via Wikileaks. They revealed the details of speeches by Mrs Clinton to Goldman Sachs. Even during the Cold War, Russia never tried to influence an American election. Putin denied the claims, but didn’t put much effort into his defence: ‘Listen, does it even matter who hacked the data?[…]the important thing is that the content was given to the public.’
So why have relations deteriorated so badly? First, Putin’s aggression is probably a form of distraction. The Russian economy is shrinking, and real disposable income has fallen by 12% since 2014; its population is ageing, and is expected to fall by 10% by 2050. Throughout history, leaders have engaged in adventurism abroad to help their people forget problems at home. It’s worked for Putin before. His approval ratings rose dramatically after he invaded Crimea, and he has presumably concluded that more foreign aggression will make him more popular.
Second, Putin probably does want to influence the outcome of the American election. It is generally assumed that he would prefer a President Trump, whose ‘America First’ isolationism is far more appealing to Russia than the interventionist policies of Mrs Clinton, who has repeatedly called for no-fly zones over Syria. Both candidates have accused the other of being Mr Putin’s ‘puppet’. If Hillary Clinton is his puppet, she is a rather bad one: the two have a history of animosity. Putin blamed Mrs Clinton for stoking up protests against him in 2011; Mrs Clinton compared Russia’s actions in Ukraine to those of Hitler. Mr Trump, however, has been far more complimentary: ‘He’s been a leader, far more than our President he’s been a leader.’ Mr Putin has returned the praise, calling Mr Trump a ‘very talented man’. Hopefully the relationship will not have the chance to blossom.
Image by cryogenic666 via flickr.
