Is Halloween more than a vehicle for consumerism?

By Jonathan Murden

Halloween is that most curious of holidays, a commemoration of all that is spectral and supernatural in our supposedly secular age. It is often said that its origins lie in the pagan festival of Samhain, however, the historical accuracy of this is dubious. It is true that there was an Irish Celtic festival of that name from the 31st of October to the first of November, however, we have very little knowledge of what happened at this time, or even what the festival was supposed to commemorate. Most festivals commemorating the dead, both pagan and Christian, were in May until the Roman Catholic Church moved the Christian All Saints Day (or ‘All Hallows Day’) to the 1st of November in 1006. This is the origin of the modern association of the holiday with the ghostly and supernatural, a time when the veil between the worlds is thin.

We in the liberal West like to pretend we are very enlightened, but our persistent fascination with the supernatural seems to belie this. Why is it, if we have truly purged ourselves of the superstitions of the past and entered an age of science and universal reason, that we are still fascinated and thrilled all things spooky? From the roaring success of the Harry Potter franchise to The Conjuring 2, which came out in June and made over $100 million in the box office, our culture is still haunted (pun intended) by the ghosts of our pre-modern past. Could it be that we are still just as irrational as we have ever been? In the words of Hamlet, “there are more things in heaven and Earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy”, and as 2016 has demonstrated, the world is still bizarre, strange and surprising.

But there is another invisible force at hand in these things, namely, the invisible hand of the market. Just as the popularity of Christmas and Valentine’s Day says very little about societal attitudes to a certain Jewish infant in first century Palestine or a Roman martyr, or even the abstract values of peace and love, Halloween is just another opportunity for the obsessive consumption and consumerism that dominates our culture: consumption of sweets, of alcohol, of goods and services in general.

And much as we might expect on Halloween, this invisible hand works to sinister effect. Consumerism functions by packaging everything, reducing all to just another item to be bought and sold. This is the essential nihilism of our times; everything – including death – is ultimately an image to be marketed, and each image is interchangeable with any other. The differences between things lie only in the subjective taste of the consumer.

Exactly what this means becomes clearer when we turn to the numerous cases in recent years where people have found themselves unable to distinguish between Halloween decorations and real corpses (See here, here, and here). In a striking case from 2009, a man in California committed suicide by shooting himself in the head, and the body was left undisturbed on his balcony for five days. This can be seen more broadly too; new footage emerges of the police in the US killing black people every month, and one thinks also of the images of the three year-old Syrian refugee Alan Kurdi that made headlines last year after he drowned in the Mediterranean. In a culture saturated, almost constituted, by the vast proliferation of images, are we still able to tell objects of consumption from human beings? Or, more succinctly, is it possible to see at all with so much flashing past our eyes?

In another sense, however, this process whereby death becomes just another consumer object, a performance for public entertainment, is not part of the spectral Other-world conjured up on All Hallows Eve but a very material process. The nature of our economic system combines with a modern mass media to commodify all that it comes into contact with. Halloween, on the other hand, is a reminder that life and death are beyond the purely rational, beyond any neat packaging we might want to squeeze them into. The world we live in is full of needless horror, full of the illogic of death, but in a constant stream of images, it can be hard to imagine anything different. Halloween reminds us that other worlds are possible; such reminders are hard to come by, and for that at least, it is worth preserving.

Photograph by Maurits Verbiest