University criticised for its support of Union Society

By Anoushka Mundey

The University has been criticised by Durham Islamic Society and Durham Students’ Union for supporting the Durham Union Society for holding a debate titled “This House Believes Palestinian Leadership is the Greatest Barrier to Peace”.

In a statement published after the debate was held, Durham Islamic Society condemned the University’s support of the debate, saying it “erodes the values of tolerance, mutual respect and constructive dialogue that should define our academic community.” 

The Union Society, in a statement, reiterated that “any opinions expressed by the speakers we host are their own and are not reflective of the Union views”. The Society is student-run and a charity, independent of both the University and SU.

We do not tolerate antisemitism or anti-Muslim hatred or any form of harassment

Durham University

The University strongly denies these accusations, a spokesperson told Palatinate “as an inclusive community, we do not tolerate antisemitism or anti-Muslim hatred or any form of harassment. We reject outright any public claims made to the contrary by student organisations and student representatives.” They continue to specify that “Some social media posts are offering accounts of the evening that are inaccurate and  misleading.”

The controversial debate focused on the broader history of Israel- Palestine conflict and took place against the background of Israel’s current war on Gaza. The debate itself was rescheduled from last term as the University postponed the event after protestors blocked entrances to the debating chamber.

A spokesperson from Durham University told Palatinate it “was wholly committed to ensuring the Durham Union Society debate scheduled for Friday 8th November went ahead, which it did.” It said it had engaged with the society to ensure “arrangements were in place” for “the safety and security of those attending”.

The Union Society voted 92-59 in  favour of Palestinian leadership being the “greatest barrier to peace”.

Whilst the debate is divisive, on instagram, Jerry Li, Durham Union President stated, he believes that “dialogue and expression trumps intimidation and silence”.

The University similarly defends free speech, saying it is “committed to upholding freedom of speech within the law and the right to lawful protest.”

The Union Society voted 92-59 in  favour of Palestinian leadership being the “greatest barrier to peace”.

Durham Students’ Union President, Dan Lonsdale published a statement titled “Student Protest Against the Durham Union Society” on 13th November.

In Mr Lonsdale’s statement, he went on to accuse the University of “shield[ing]” the Union from any responsibility for its actions, and that it “continues to pretend that because it doesn’t have control over the [the Union Society], it can’t have any influence on [the Union Society]. We all know that this is nonsense”.

“There’s no point in the University preaching its ‘values’ if they aren’t used to challenge people to be better; this isn’t about control, it’s about leadership. The University abdicated this responsibility.”

Mr Lonsdale said he would “ask the University to explain why it didn’t ask [the Union Society] to take steps to avoid the use of police.”

The SU also raised concerns about the completion of anti-racism work, saying in a statement in October that “We are concerned, based on past incidents, that the risk of racism is too high if this work is not done.”

The University continues to pretend that because it doesn’t have any control over [the Union Society] […] We all know this is nonsense

dan Lonsdale, Su President

This came after the Daily Mail reported in 2023 that a member of the Union Society used a racial slur against another member, the Union Society agreed to subject itself to a timeline of reviews and reforms.

The SU renewed a boycott of the Union Society, barring them from purchasing a stall, saying that they had failed to meet the deadlines agreed in the report.

In the most recent statement, Mr Lonsdale criticised the University for not doing enough to ensure the Union Society’s anti-racism work was completed saying that “Durham SU will always protect the  rights of every student who wants to protest against racism – even when their University allows it to run rampant.”

The Union Society rejected this assertion in October, telling Palatinate it “considers it unfounded for the SU to accuse us of failing to tackle racism when they take no interest at all in the society other than to marginalise it.”

They continued: “If the SU had taken up our invitation to them to attend the open access debate, they would find the Society to be friendly, inclusive and civil”, referring to an invitation that Mr Li gave to Mr Lonsdale in early October to come to a debate. They also pointed to some of the reforms that they had made.

A spokesperson from Durham University urged students “affected by any such incidents to report them to us via our Report + Support tool, or, where appropriate, the police, so that they can be investigated.”

Image: Uli Harder