University and College Union go on strike

By Emily Doughty and Daniel Hodgson

Durham has faced a wave of strike action over this term, with the University and College Union (UCU) taking strike action and Action Short Of a Strike (ASOS). 

The strike action, which is over the UCU’s ongoing pensions dispute as well as pay and working conditions, saw the union members go on strike for three days this term at the end of November.  

It was called after the UCU voted overwhelmingly in favour of industrial action in a ballot in October. 

While pay negotiations did take place at the start of December to try and bring an end to the dispute, the UCU has now said on their social media that more action is planned for the new year. 

When asked for the reason why they were striking, Dr John Warren, Vice President of Durham UCU said there were two disputes, one of which being the ongoing dispute about pensions.  

“A lot of the benefits to that pension were cut earlier in the year, but that was based on a valuation that was done at the beginning of Covid. It was done, actually on the 31st March 2020 and was based on the stock market that day and of course they were all falling through the floor because of Covid and that predicted that our pension scheme would have a huge, huge deficit.”

Dr Warren went on to say that “we went through the strikes earlier in the year and guess what, it turns out they’ve now done another valuation and guess what, the pension fund is not in deficit at all, it’s in fact in surplus instead. So we’re saying effectively, give us back our pensions, restore the benefits for that.”

“None of the issues [which the UCU took industrial action over last year] got resolved the previous time”

Dr SAra uckelman

Dr Sarah Uckelman, one of the one equalities officers of the local UCU branch said “None of the issues [which the UCU took industrial action over last year] got resolved the previous time” 

“Unions are very good at collective action, we understand how to organise with each other and talk with each other and work with other institutions and to be honest, that’s what the Vice Chancellors need to do. So many Vice Chancellors say ‘Oh, it’s a national problem, it needs a national solution, I’m just one Vice Chancellor, I can’t do anything’.

“But if the Vice Chancellors actually got together and organised in a way that a Union does, then they could think creatively, think big picture and actually ask themselves: What can we do to address the structural issues in higher education, in Britain?”

When asked about reports about lecturers who had continued working despite voicing support for the strike, Dr Uckelman said “It’s hard to back a strike and then not participate in it”. 

Another discussion point among both staff and students was Durham Students’ Union decision to hold a referendum to decide their position on taking strike action. 

Dr Sol Gamsu, President of Durham UCU, said of the decision “Obviously we have had SU support in previous years which has been fantastic. Democracy is important and I am not too sure about the role of the Trustee board in that.”

“The student union seem to be saying “We don’t support our students, we don’t support our own members””

dr sara uckelman

Under the Articles of Association, which the Durham Student Union is governed by, trustees have the right to call a referendum.

Talking about the preferendum, Dr Uckelman said “I’m quite disappointed because the preferendum doesn’t seem to recognise that amongst Union members are students. We have a significant number of PGR and PGT students, who are also employees of the University and members of the Union but not even them, we have undergraduate members. 

“The student union seems to be saying “We don’t support our students, we don’t support our own members” and that’s very frustrating that there doesn’t seem to be recognition that this isn’t UCU against DSU, that we are on the same side and often have the same members.”

In a statement, a Durham SU spokesperson said a “democratic vote by students to support industrial action is a clear example of the SU’s democracy providing students, including research students who are postgraduate members of UCU, the opportunity to gain a strong democratic mandate on an issue they care about. 

“That they have been successful in doing so is a credit to their passion and commitment to this issue, but that passion and commitment does not make their opinion the only student opinion entitled for consideration. While at the time of comment Palatinate has not included the voices of students who supported other policy positions in the referendum, this was in fact over 40% of voters. Recognising these students’ rights to have a say does not ‘undermine’ the rights of those with a different opinion.

“Durham SU commissioned research in 2020 into how Durham students wanted to be involved in SU decision making, 89% agreed they wanted to vote directly on more SU policy. Industrial Action will impact the experience of most students this year, and Durham SU’s governing documents are clear that a referendum was desirable, and possible, and entirely consistent with the way things are meant to happen.

“working conditions of staff are working conditions of students”

mary kelly foy mp

“Durham SU’s elected leaders, collectively, decided to hold this referendum. They recognised that any organisation with elected leaders has a continuing responsibility to consult students, and students should make decisions by democratic vote.”

The referendum results, which were announced after the strike ended, saw nearly 60% of students vote in support of industrial action. 

Local MP Mary Foy also was on the picket line in support of the UCU. Speaking to Palatinate, Ms Foy said that she supported the strikers “as working conditions of staff are working conditions on students.” 

When asked why the issue hadn’t been resolved since last year, when Ms Foy had joined workers on the picket line she said that “How many prime ministers have we had? The Government has been in chaos and the Government have not done anything.”

She continued on to say “The Government has got to step up… It’s education, we talk about levelling up, how are we levelling up when most of the workers who are educating people here in the north east, where we need to level up, and they’re struggling to make ends meet.”

A spokesperson for Durham University said: “We are very aware of the cost of living pressures staff face. Working with other Universities and all recognised trade union representatives including UCU, the University always looks to find a way forward that avoids the need for industrial action being taken.

“We are also very concerned about the impact of the current cost of living crisis on our students. This is why we have already invested heavily in our student hardship funds and the Durham Grant Scheme.

“We are actively engaged at a national level…as well as discussing pensions issues locally”

durham university spokesperson

“Pay and pensions are subject to national negotiations in which Durham University actively participates. 

“The University has been informed that UCEA (which represents University employers) and the joint Trade Unions have agreed to bring forward negotiations on the 2023-24 national pay round. 

“Negotiations will begin this month with a view to concluding the discussions by the end of January 2023. As part of these negotiations there is a commitment from UCEA and the Trade Unions to de-escalate the dispute between the parties, to allow for this intense period of negotiation which will hopefully reach a conclusion.

“We welcome these developments and will keep you updated.

“We are actively engaged at a national level on issues around USS governance, investment principles and development of alternative, low-cost options, as well as discussing pensions issues locally with DUCU.”

Image Credit: Daniel Hodgson