Underequipped and underinformed: The Government’s failings on transgender rights
By Marcus Baldwin
The rising prominence of LGBTQ+ issues within modern society has created the newest hotbed of discussion and debate within the landscape of British politics, that of transgender rights. This is certainly a complex issue at its core, with inherently massive changes in not only society and its lexicon, but the very way in which people view themselves. With guidance for teachers pertaining to the treatment of transgender children in schools finally released, Kemi Badenoch, minister for women and equalities, seems to have stuck to her July proposal that teachers will be compelled to inform parents of children questioning their gender at school. The effective question is now this, is the government overstepping its role, and will its directives instead inhibit the youth who are simply not comfortable with the gender assigned to them at birth?
Firstly, the debate from the viewpoint of Badenoch and her conservative supporters. The crux of the argument appears to be this – parents ought to know what circumstances are affecting their children. Their issue is therefore firmly rooted in the perennial diatribe between age and independence, the age-old ‘how young is too young?’ debate. In their eyes, transgender rights should not be dismissed outright, but the prerogative of independence ought to remain firmly with the parent until 18, which is the major cut-off point for adulthood. The question that could be perhaps facetiously posed from this perspective is: should a ten-year old be able to make a decision regarding their own gender? You may very well argue that every person has a right to determine their own individual status, but converting that point of view into legislation is nigh-on-impossible. The universal nature of the law is attempting to tackle what is a very individualised issue. The very nature of gender in the modern era is multifaceted, referring to a vast array of individualisation all compounded into a single all-encompassing word, gender. The government therefore may try to address all issues of gender through the medium of age, by stating that parents are still the effective watchdogs in the household, and should be kept abreast of all information as pertains to their family.
The government would appear to have forgotten its role as legislator, wading into a debate it seems woefully underequipped and underinformed to deal with
The counterpoints however are obvious. The legislation is bound by the mentioned universal overview of the law, and therefore assumes a great many things. Firstly, the teacher is provided with an enormous degree of importance. They will be forced to make difficult decisions regarding a child questioning their gender, such as what could be regarded as questioning, and at what point would they intervene and involve the parents. Teachers would also have to assess the impact that such information could have in the child’s household, whether it could lead to a dramatic shift in the child’s life. While society has certainly begun to change for the better in terms of inclusivity, to suggest that all transgender people are free from disparagement and, in some cases, violence is appalling naivete. Cases of domestic abuse and sexual violence against transgender individuals has rocketed by 18% from 2020/21 to 2021/22. The teacher must therefore make the impossible choice to predict behaviour from parents, all for a salary which they already believe to be unfair, as evidenced by their recent strikes. The child themselves in this scenario would also have no input, their gender decision would be laid bare before their parents, without their consent, with the consequences mainly relating to them themselves.
This questioning is all before recent government behaviour regarding banning conversion therapy is analysed, with Kemi Badenoch herself refusing to take a legal stance on the matter, merely promising to ‘end’ the practice in a parliamentary debate. The debate has been strung out for so long, that the calls for Ms Badenoch’s resignation have arisen from a member of the government’s LGBTQ+ advisory panel. Further plans to change the equality act to ban transgender people from single gender spaces, such as female only hospital wards, provide a darker shade to the government’s approach to transgender issues.
The issue is as previously stated, complex. If viewing Badenoch’s policy with an optimist’s lens, you can argue that the guidance would simply try to make the best of an impossible scenario, and that parental rights should outweigh those of a child, who will be supported by both their parent and their teacher. However, from the viewpoint of a realist, the guidance assumes far too many points with sunny disposition, from the reaction of teacher, parent and indeed child, to the child’s gender being a point of open discussion, which they may not be ready for. The government would appear to have forgotten its role as legislator, wading into a debate it seems woefully underequipped and underinformed to deal with.
Image credit: Department for International Trade via Wikimedia Commons

