UCU General Secretary candidates make their pitch to Palatinate as voting begins

By Luke Alsford

Voting has begun for University and College Union (UCU) members to elect their next General Secretary. Dr Jo Grady, who was elected to the position in 2019, is standing for re-election alongside three other candidates: Professor Ewan McGaughey, Saira Weiner, and Vicky Blake. UCU members, who consist of academics, researchers and support staff in further and higher education, are also voting to elect a trustee, Vice President and national executive committee members. Palatinate has interviewed all four candidates who are standing for General Secretary about their motivations for running, views on the industrial action of the last four years, and plans for office. 

The General Secretary election follows off the back of a long period of industrial action by the UCU. Members of the Union had been striking against cuts to pension benefits and contribution rate increases in the University Superannuation Scheme (USS) pension scheme, which is predominantly for academics from universities established before 1992. Strike action, which took place in the first half of the 2022 to 2023 academic year, resulted in an agreement being reached between the UCU and Universities UK (UUK), who were representing employers. The USS subsequently lowered the contribution rates for members and has pledged to restore previously cut pension benefits by April of this year. 

The UCU has simultaneously engaged in industrial action to support their “Four Fights” over pay equality, workload, casualisation, and pay levels. As a result of progress on pension negotiations, the UCU paused their industrial action in relation to the USS dispute in April 2023, but at the same time declared a marking and assessment boycott (MAB) over the Four Fights dispute. The boycott was called off by the UCU on 6th September 2023 as it became clear that reballoting for a new mandate to continue industrial action would not be completed in time and after a consultation of members showed that 60% of respondents favoured ending the MAB. Strike action on behalf of the Four Fights did take place on 25th to 29th September, but a ballot in November to mandate further industrial action failed to reach the legal threshold requiring a 50% turnout.

Ewan McGaughey

Professor Ewan McGaughey, a law professor at King’s College, London, told Palatinate that he is standing for the position of General Secretary because “higher education is so broken in the UK and the Union has been failing so badly since 2019. I genuinely believe I’ve got an obligation to try and change it if I can.” He is a candidate after having spent three years as branch President of the KCL UCU from December 2020 to September 2023. Professor McGaughey, alongside the University of Bristol’s Dr Neil Davies, crowdfunded a high-profile legal case in early 2022 against the pension fund directors of the USS. The case against the USS was ultimately dismissed in August 2023, but Professor McGaughey claims that the court action was a factor in the UCU’s victory in its pension dispute.

We do not want strike action. What we want to do is have fair pay, equality, security, democracy

Ewan McGaughey

Professor McGaughey cites his successes as a branch President as proof that he can deliver at the top of the UCU: “At King’s [College, London], we got the highest London Weighting in the capital city – a 42% pay rise over 2 years for local pay. We got among the highest levels of paid parental leave in the country, as a University. We know that paid parental leave is a major structural cause of the gender pay gap. We got a written collective agreement for the first time in over a decade. We got more staff elected to the governing body, the Council. It really is important for a democratic workplace and I think that we need these changes at national level.”

A key pillar of Professor McGaughey’s candidacy is securing fair pay for UCU members. He said that “We have got to reverse the 13% real terms pay cuts since 2019, when the current incumbent General Secretary took over. Since 2009, it is over 21% real terms pay cuts […] Money needs to go into teaching, that’s what students expect their money is used for, but it’s not.” 

The real terms pay cuts since 2019 were described by Professor McGaughey as only one part of the “deep” and “systemic” “failings” of the UCU over the last four years. Professor McGaughey claimed that the Union has been “losing members” since 2019 and that there have been “no court cases to defend members rights.” He added, “What you want to do is actually not get to court. But sometimes you need to fight in court even if you don’t always win, you need to have a strategy for litigation to defend members rights.” 

In relation to strike action to achieve his aims on pay and the other Four Fights, Professor McGaughey said that, “We do not want strike action. What we want to do is have fair pay, equality, security, democracy at workplace, through good faith, collective bargaining. That’s central to what I’m promising.” He has a three- pronged approach: “The three main ones [strategies] are collective action, including strike action if needed. Secondly, there’s legal action that can put pressure on employers and vindicate members rights. And thirdly, there’s targeted publicity over wrongdoing.” 

Image via Ewan McGaughey

Professor McGaughey did acknowledge the “major win” that strike action had in reversing the pension cuts in the USS dispute, but said the failure to reach the 50% turnout threshold for strike action last November “shows a lack of organisation” and that “this leadership of [the] UCU has failed so badly that it couldn’t get its act together to just get the vote out.” If elected, he has pledged to overhaul the UCU’s voter data systems and that the UCU “will never ever lose a ballot…We’ll get the highest voter turnouts that UCU has ever seen”. Professor McGaughey’s manifesto also vows to “restore democracy in education” by ensuring that “every university and college must have a governing body that is majority- elected by staff”, as is already the case at Cambridge, Oxford and UCL. 

Lobbying of the Government is a central tenet of Professor McGaughey’s approach. His opinions is that “the country is so broken by this incompetent, pathetic, failed conservative government that the public finances are in such a terrible state that Labour can’t have unlimited spending.” Professor McGaughey instead wants to lobby the Government to achieve these things and instill “a culture of encouraging evidence-based debate and policy making” with the UCU.

Sara Weiner

Saira Weiner, a Senior Lecturer at Liverpool John Moores University, is the chosen candidate of the Union’s UCU Left faction. She told Palatinate that she is running for General Secretary position because “the experience of the last few years has been quite difficult for a lot of UCU members, who have been almost marched up the hill and down again in terms of industrial strategy, over the four fights.” Ms Weiner was a member of the UCU’s National Executive Committee (NEC) from 2019 to 2023 and was Chair of the UCU’s Recruitment, Organising and Campaigns Committee from 2022 to 2023. 

Ms Weiner is critical of the General Secretary’s attitude to the pension dispute: “The USS dispute [was] won, but for those of us in post-92 branches like myself, we haven’t won anything after a year’s worth of being in dispute. I believe that’s because the strategy that has been democratically decided has not been carried out.” Staff in post-1992 universities are mostly members of the Teacher’s Pension Scheme (TPS) and Weiner argues that “in pre-92s we’ve got nothing. We haven’t won on pay. We haven’t won on casualisation, we haven’t won on workload and the equality pay gaps haven’t been addressed in any way shape or form. So, we’ve got nothing […] It is a dereliction of duty for a UK-wide union to leave branches to fight institution by institution.” 

The failure of the November strike ballot to reach the turnout threshold demonstrated that “people felt really let down” by the UCU’s leadership, according to Ms Weiner. She continued, “[Members thought that] we’ll have action put off for three months and then we’ll decide on something and it won’t be carried out and we’ve not had financial support. The MAB was called off at a crucial time, letting down particularly our casualized members of staff.”

We’d win for students. And we’d bring confidence back to students that this is what they deserve

Sara Weiner

Ms Weiner called the November strike ballot “a defeat when we don’t have a strategy to move forward.” She has instead pledged “a strategy based on militancy” of “taking really serious industrial action”, including “shutting down the campuses until we decide to come back again.” Ms Weiner said that “although that [strategy] is unpleasant for students, I also think that is far less disruptive than having a week here a week there. We do the job because we care about education. We think it’s important that our students receive a proper education. We can’t just sit by and do nothing while there’s this stack them high, sell them cheap strategy… I think it would be a hard win for students. We’d win for students. And we’d bring confidence back to students that this is what they deserve.” A defining element of Ms Weiner’s campaign is her pledge to implement a “democratic transformation in the UCU”. She says that “If I carry out the democratic decisions carried out by our democratic bodies, I will represent everybody […] Healthy discussion and debate is a good thing. There are always going to be disagreements, I think unfortunately they’ve been aired very, very publicly […] I’m happy to work with people who disagree with me on many things on what we agree on and what the democratic decisions made.” Ms Weiner has also said that she will implement “more open, inclusive and participatory” structures in the UCU.

To encourage change in education policies at a national level, Ms Weiner commented that “to get the Government policy changed, I think lobbying the Government is really effective and noted that “in the UCU we have friends with many Labour backbenchers.” Her goals are for the Government “to see education as something valued in this country.” As General Secretary, Ms Weiner would tell those who think the answer is putting student fees up again” that their “model” is “wrong” and would “work with all the other unions” on education “to create a real force of argument and steam.” 

Sara Weiner, who is Jewish, has also called for teaching staff to join “Stand with Gaza” student walkouts and advocates an academic boycott of Israeli institutions. She commented to Palatinate, “Trade unions are about solidarity. You cannot separate solidarity in the workplace with your [Palestinian] colleagues who are facing genocide.”

Vicky Blake

Vicky Blake, who was President of the Leeds UCU branch from 2017 to 2019 before serving four years as a UCU UK officer, including one year as Vice President and two as President of the Union, told Palatinate that she stood to become the next General Secretary because “[in] my time as a UK officer… I just saw up close how broken I think things have become.” She said, “I feel I know our Union well. I believe in our members. I believe in the UCU and I believe in the potential and the capacity that we have to be a really strong voice for our members […] I’m offering a really practical program for change based on my experience as a branch officer.”

I believe in our members. I believe in the UCU and I believe in the potential and the capacity that we have to be a really strong voice for our members

Vicky Blake

Ms Blake pointed to her successes in negotiations with employers in 2019 and 2020, when she was Vice President and led both the USS dispute negotiation team and the Four Fights pay and conditions team. She claimed “We made really significant progress in those negotiations, backed by really solid strikes” that resulted in securing, “for the first time, pay related conditions – casualization, inequality, pay gaps, workload – [being included] into formal talks the first time.”

In relation to industrial action strategy since 2020, the Durham University graduate says that the “the current approach to decision making in the UCU” has “basically led to an erosion of trust and confidence.” She said that “There are times when we’ve [the Higher Education Committee] had a really coherent strategy […] that [was] then actually undermined.” The Higher Education Committee (HEC), which Ms Blake chaired during her time as a UCU officer, is made up of NEC members and decisions about industrial action in higher education are made by the body. As an example, Ms Blake pointed to the General Secretary’s announcement of a marking and assessment boycott and her criticism of a HEC decision to support indefinite strike action in a Twitter video in December 2022. Ms Blake claimed that this announcement was explained “in a really partial way, without that background information and without information that it had been decided” by the HEC as part of a longer-term strategy earlier in the year. This course of action by Dr Jo Grady, she commented, ”meant that it was a more difficult strategy”. This move by the incumbent General Secretary was also attacked by Saira Weiner in her interview with Palatinate. 

In her campaign to be General Secretary, Vicky Blake’s strategy on industrial action pledges “mutually reinforcing strategies of local and collective sectoral bargaining […] I believe that local bargaining should drive better and more comprehensive collective sectoral bargaining and the reason for that is it’s the it matters that we drive up the minimum standards in our sector.” She believes “that it is possible that our employers could agree with us a framework to raise standards across the sector.” A key reform of Ms Blake’s campaign manifesto is to “create a network of UCU Organising Hubs”. These hubs would “facilitate a more coordinated approach to organising” and would “foster mutual learning and support between branches and across sectors”, particularly to “benefit smaller branches.” 

Image via Tim Packer

Ms Blake is also pledging to “make it a priority to re- establish trust in” the UCU’s “decision making structures” and to “increase campaigning for equitable and safe workplaces.” This will involve improving the UCU’s “legal provision[s]” in order to “improve access to support for members in critical and stressful situations.” She also wants to “embed inclusive and accessible practice in [the] UCU” by “working alongside members to combat racism and ensure unlearning of ableism, homophobia, transphobia and sexism.” 

One of Ms Blake’s central policy platforms is to influence policy and the political landscape. She says that lobbying government is “really about relationship building.” She hopes Labour would be “bold about addressing problems with the funding model in higher education and also funding in further education.” Ms Blake wants to try influence policy at all levels of government, from local level to devolved and national level, and she “want[s] to make it easier for members to get involved in policy development work in UCU.” Ms Blake added, “We have to get really serious about getting UCU’s policy expertise out there and advocating for it.”

Jo Grady

Dr Jo Grady, who was elected General Secretary in 2019 after working as a Senior Lecturer at Sheffield University, explained to Palatinate that she is running for reelection to the post because “there’s still so much for us to achieve.” Dr Grady said that she wants to “keep going and keep pushing” on the “progress” that the UCU has made since 2019: “I think it’s sometimes worth reminding ourselves of the backdrop to that progress. Despite the pandemic, despite one of the most right- wing governments in in recent decades. Despite all manner of things, we’ve won two UK wide ballots, we’ve been victorious in a historic pensions dispute. We really pushed back during COVID and kept people safe. And we’ve doubled our membership in in like some areas of the Union, like prison education. We’ve really set a climate inequality agenda that I’m proud of.”

The whole union must unite around a national campaign
aimed at saving higher education and defeating marketisation

Jo Grady

Dr Grady defended her record on industrial action as General Secretary. She said that the pension dispute with the USS, to “deliver pension justice” ended with “as close to a total victory as you can get.” Dr Grady also praised the “progress” achieved on “non-pay elements” in negotiations, saying “a promise to end zero hours contract isn’t to be scoffed at.” She also criticised “simplistic claims that everything’s the General Secretary fault.” She commented, “At least two other candidates […] have been on the Union’s governing bodies. They are the bodies that call strike action […] they’re the bodies that can call the marking boycott off and the General Secretary doesn’t get a vote on those bodies […] I think it needs calling out when people who have been part of the decision-making process seek to present somebody who doesn’t get a vote on the committees [… as being] the person with ultimate responsibility for those things.” 

In response to the November strike ballot that failed to reach the 50% legal turnout threshold, Dr Grady is pledging that “a big part of my reelection campaign” on industrial action strategy “is saying let’s do it differently.” Dr Grady is also reacting to a UCU survey of higher education members, the results of which were provided to Palatinate, which show that 64% of the respondents believed that the UCU were far from winning the dispute and 82% wanted the development of a longer-term strategy on industrial action. Dr Grady told Palatinate that this has persuaded her of a need for “a completely new strategy” that “is ambitious” in covering “casualization, workload and pay.” 

Dr Grady indicated that her new approach would “be a two-pronged strategy” of national efforts and “making local wins where we can get them”. She said that the UCU should not “take our foot off the gas of local bargaining in order to just pursue a national dispute.” Dr Grady has pledged to “shift” the “old fashioned” democratic culture in the UCU, which she described as “inaccessible and sometimes off-putting”. She hopes to address the issue in “the culture” that “you have to be at an in-person meeting […] to have say” and that many members “don’t take part in the voting process of who gets to go to Congress” and receive no feedback from their delegates who attended. 

In her higher education strategy document, the incumbent General Secretary also vows to “respond to the threat” posed by the “huge rise in costs” that most post-92 university members will face in their TPS pension. She says that “the whole union must unite around a national campaign aimed at saving higher education and defeating marketisation”, including being prepared to engage in more “local disputes” to stop “the threat of course closures and redundancies.” 

Dr Jo Grady expressed her confidence in her ability to lobby and influence government on the Four Fights and other issues, in particular a prospective Labour government. “They will need to deliver for students, for staff. I think during the last four years I have demonstrated that I am perfectly capable to hold politicians to account […] If I’m reelected, we will use the useful working relationships that we’ve got with Labour… [and the] shadow cabinet team… [but] we are not going to support them blindly if they’re not actually putting into practice some of the things that we’ve talked about.”

Ballots for the UCU elections close at noon on 1st March 2024.

Image: Strikes led by the UCU in Durham in 2020 (Tim Packer)