Plans for care home opposite South refused by County Council
By Elliot Burrin
Councillors have refused to back plans to build a new care home opposite South College after the plans were submitted for approval by Durham County Council’s planning department.
The 74-bed facility proposed by Torsion Care planned to create 50 full-time and 25 part-time jobs, but committee members and councillors argued that the site’s closeness to South College and other Durham University buildings meant that it was inappropriate for providing this level of healthcare.
The development was also opposed by County Durham Care Partnership and Professor Timothy Luckhurst, Principal of South College.
Professor Luckhurst explained his opposition to the care home in a public letter: “South College is home to 492 students, the large majority of whom are undergraduates. Approximately 700 additional students of Durham University are members of South College. Every year we host events including matriculation, graduation, college days, remembrance day, formal dinners, college balls, fashion shows and drama performances. Each attracts large numbers of students, and some are accompanied by live and/or amplified music.
“The proposed care home will be directly opposite South College, closer than any of the existing private residences. I fear the possibility of conflict between student lifestyles and the expectations of families placing their aged relatives in residential care.
“Plainly, I am anxious to ensure that South College students can continue to enjoy student life without inconveniencing or disturbing any neighbours.”
Similarly, County Durham Care Partnership said: “We actually have an overprovision of Older Persons Care Home beds in County Durham […] there are already two large new Older Persons Care Homes being built in County Durham.”
The Durham City Neighbourhood Plan, which was referenced in the planning application, predicts that, as a result of an ageing population and an expected 500 more people over the age of 75 by 2035 in Durham City, there will need to be 50 more beds in Durham City care homes and a further 100 in the wider area to meet these increasing demands.
“I fear the possibility of conflict between student lifestyles and the expectations of families placing their aged relatives in residential care”
Professor Timothy Luckhurst, Principal of South College
Torsion Care explained in a statement that the proposal would benefit the local area, saying: “The development represents the opportunity to meet the growing care needs for an increasing elderly population.”
Palatinate has previously reported that, in August 2023, Hallgarth Care Home closed in Durham City, resulting in the loss of 60 beds. At the time, Durham County Council’s deputy director of integrated commissioning said: “In County Durham we currently have around 86 per cent occupancy in care homes, meaning there are over 200 beds available. More locally in the Durham district, the occupancy figure is still slightly lower at around 84 per cent, with an estimated 97 care home beds available.
“At the time of its closure, Hallgarth Care Home was significantly under-capacity and all the residents and staff were successfully relocated with little to no impact on the wider availability of beds.”
The County Council’s Adult and Health Services maintained their position in the planning application for the care home by South College that “there is insufficient evidence of need for a new care home and the proposal would place extra pressure on existing care homes”, paraphrased within the report.
The planning application also reported that NHS Local Healthcare Estates would require £15,540 to “mitigate the likely demands that the development of a 74 patient increase would place on the local healthcare system.” Claypath and University Medical Group also expressed concern for the negative impact that the development would bring: in the planning application, they say that their “current buildings are considered 50% smaller than their patient list demands.”
Sarah Douglas, strategic commissioning manager in adult and health services at Durham County Council, said: “It’s really important we help our existing providers to be sustainable. Care homes are not the type of provision that we need any more of in County Durham. Any further care home creates further pressure on the NHS.”
Image: Luke Alsford

