UAE honour killing punishment reconsidered

By Barney Bolton

Honour killings are attacks on women who are believed to have dishonored their families. The attacks take the form of physical abuse and, occasionally, murder. They are carried out for a variety of reasons including suspected pre- or extra-marital sex.

On Saturday 7th November, President His Highness Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan announced an alteration of federal laws regarding the penal code of the UAE. These laws changed the historic leniency that had been shown when punishing honour crimes. In previous years, honour crimes carried sentences between three and fifteen years in prison. Following the changes made to the law, those who have been judged to have committed an honour killing will receive punishments of life imprisonment or execution, the same sentence as any murder.

In addition to the alterations regarding abuse, the government has amended laws on the cohabitation of unmarried couples as well as the possession and sale of alcohol for those over the age of 21.

The Emirates news agency, WAM, stated that these changes aim to “consolidate the UAE’s principles of tolerance.”

The Emirates news agency, WAM, stated that these changes aim to “consolidate the UAE’s principles of tolerance.” These amendments have been made to give a more secular and, to an extent, a more Western impression of the UAE. Former US president, Donald Trump, contributed significantly to the UAE’s previous efforts to alter their image. During his time in office, Trump played a part in the normalisation of relations between the UAE and neighboring Israel. Previously, the two nations had a shaky relationship, with the UAE not recognising Israel until 15th September 2020, when a Trump-driven deal was signed between the two.

 The deal was most likely signed to encourage the increase in investment from Israel to the UAE. Additionally, by improving relations, the oil-rich UAE stood to benefit from an increase in tourism, a sector which according to The Daily Mail makes up 5% of the nation’s GDP. The changes to laws regarding honour killings follow in the same vein as the deal signed in September. The lenient punishments for honour criminals gave the UAE an image problem in the West. Potential investors have been put off by the Sharia law that dominates the country. The severity of Sharia law is alien to many Westerners and marked the UAE as fundamentally different from other developed nations.

 As well as encouraging investment into the UAE, these changes, which move towards a more secular government, have likely been made to accommodate the number of expatriates living in the UAE. Dubai Online reports that in 2019, over 8.5 million migrants were living in the UAE, making up 87.9% of the total population. What is striking, and telling, in the population statistics of the UAE is the proportion of male to female citizens. Dubai Online reports that in 2019 only 31% of the population of the UAE were female. A possible reason for this disparity is the historic mistreatment of women in the UAE, meaning that female migrants may be deterred by the consequences of Sharia law.

The laws aim to make westerners, and particularly women, feel more comfortable with the legal system of the UAE. The significant proportion of migrants, many of whom have come from Western countries, means that pressure has been applied to alter the laws of the country. Foreign business links have always been vital in an area that is driven by money and, by removing laws which disproportionately punish women, the UAE expects immigration and investment to rise.

There is no doubt that the UAE is becoming more secular, with the laws moving the courts away from the traditional Islamic laws, but the extent to which the changes in the law have been installed to reassure natives is questionable. The recent alterations have been made predominantly for foreigners who may be uncomfortable with the current penal code. Regardless of the motive behind the changes, the UAE has made a positive step towards the improvement of human rights in the country.

Image: Geoffrey Foo via Flickr