Two Tribes: Newcastle v Sunderland

By Henry Clare
Craig Garner lashes home Sunderland’s third goal. Newcastle manager Alan Pardew looks to the ground in disdain. His Sunderland counterpart, Paolo Di Canio, slides along the St James’ Park turf, experiencing the bliss that comes with victory. It might be the Italian’s first, and last, taste of a Tyne-Wear derby – but Di Canio knows the joy that a 3-0 victory will give the red and white segment of the North East.
In recent times, matches between the Manchester clubs have played a huge role in the Premier League title race. Meanwhile, the North London derby has often decided the fate of fourth place. But for many the enduring passion of the North East’s football fandom makes the Tyne Wear derby one the Premier League’s more significant contests.
As with every great rivalry, there is an ugly side. Throughout history the meetings between Sunderland and Newcastle have caused controversy. Even as early as 1901, crowd trouble caused the derby to have a premature ending. 112 years later, alcohol and violence still plague the derby, with shocking images of a Newcastle United fan striking a police horse being broadcast after the most recent meeting of the two clubs.
However, for those working class men from the North East, who clutch onto their season tickets with all the same elation as a child at Christmas, football comes as an escape for the economic and social pressures of everyday life. In the cauldrons of St James’ Park and the Stadium of Light, the amount of money in one’s pocket is of no concern, nor is the job that one will invariably return to on Monday. All that matters is the badge they wear on their chest – or, for Garry Sunderland AFC Lamb, one’s middle name.
Looking from the outside in, one could say that Newcastle and Sunderland are nothing more than ‘football clubs’. To those who are unversed in football gospel, the clubs are nothing more than corporate institutions, made up of smartly dressed men with clipboards who parasitically feed on every penny that they possibly can possibly find. To others though, a football club is far more than that. To Bobby Robson, former Newcastle manager, a football club is ‘the noise, the passion, the feeling of belonging, the pride in your city’. And this is something that both of the North East’s top sides have taken to heart.
When match day comes round, the streets of Newcastle and Sunderland are threadbare. During Alan Shearer’s testimonial, 52,000 Newcastle fans waved black and white scarves in unison, serenading their greatest player, and the man that had given them such joy. When Sunderland’s Ji Dong-Won slipped the ball past to Manchester City goalkeeper Joe Hart, in the final minute of what was looking to be a stale 0-0 draw, the Stadium of Light went silent. Every Sunderland fan around the world simultaneously prayed that the South Korean would put the ball into the empty net. When Ji obliged, the place erupted.
As Bill Shankly once said, football is so much more than a matter of life and death, and that victory is the perfect example of it. People from the North East wearing their hearts on their sleeves is nothing new though. The modern day antipathy that accompanies the Tyne Wear derby is merely a manifestation of events that occurred hundreds of years before the word ‘football’ was inserted into the dictionary. During a civil war that divided the entire nation, Newcastle and Sunderland took opposite sides – with Newcastle backing Charles I’s royalist cause, and Sunderland supporting Oliver Cromwell and the Roundheads. Tensions between the two were further raised when Charles I ordered that Newcastle merchants be given a portion of the revenue earned by Sunderland’s coal industry.
The two made a habit of going on opposite sides – during the Jacobite Rebellions Newcastle sided the Hanoverians, whilst Sunderland supported the Stuarts. From Newcastle’s undying support from King George II the term ‘Geordie’ is believed to have been derived, and Sunderland’s ‘Mackem’ nickname could have origins in Scotland’s ‘Blue Mac’ army, which the Wearsiders backed. For modern fans, by chanting the anthems of their respective clubs, they keep the memory of their forefathers alive, and show their family loyalties.
In recent times, much of the hatred has been fueled by Sunderland’s alleged inferiority complex. Off the pitch, there is a perception that Newcastle is very much the capital of the North East, which irks their Wearside counterparts. On the pitch, the memories of the mid 90’s, in which Kevin Keegan’s Newcastle side challenged regular for the Title, still cause envy from the Black Cats. So, for fans of all generations, this is more than just a football match, it’s war between two tribes, divided by cultural, political and historical differences.
Photograph: DKO Digital
