Two hit shows, but one legendary winner

The How I Met Your Mother gang, still going strong after 8 years. Photograph: CBS

by Elaine Lau

How I Met Your Mother versus Friends. When watching these shows for yourselves, and hearing what other people have to say about them, you instantly elect your winner. Barney or Joey? Ross or Ted? Monica or Lily? No doubt a debate that you’ll have had amongst your friends in the past few years. Feeling as though I would be cheating on Friends, I never gave HIMYM the chance to prove itself. But since the show was about to air its 8th season, I decided to switch to the ‘dark side’. And I found, despite the similarities — New York setting, beverage-serving hangout — and claims that it’s the ‘new Friends,’ it would be unfair to say that HIMYM does not have its own uniqueness that perhaps outshines some of the more classic moments in its predecessor.

I have to say that HIMYM has gone that one step further than Friends dared to; namely, Barney Stinson’s questionable ways of courtship. One of Joey’s best moments in getting out of a sticky ‘hook up and forget to call you back’ situation was him turning the blame around on her; “Do you know how many girls I had to sleep with to get over you?!” Yes, this was genius, but sadly does not quite match up to ‘Barney’s Playbook’ – every scam, con, “flim-flam strateg-gam and bamboozle” every guy wishes they could get away with. And Barney does. That is a true testament to his skills, and it is his misdeeds and tongue-in-cheek humour that make him one of the most enduring characters in the show.

Barney has made the phrase “new is always better” one of his golden life rules, but despite all that has been said, does HIMYM still trump Friends? Sure some may say that the suit-and-tie wearer is more appealing than Joey Tribianni’s jeans and T-shirt combo, and the voiceover narration by Bob Saget brings such comedic relief to the show you feel you are getting the inside scoop to their everyday lives. But Friends has this feel-good factor about it. Fundamental elements like the brilliant opening theme, Joey’s ‘How you doin’?’ chat-up line and the iconic nature of so many episodes make you feel a connection to the characters that is beyond most sitcoms.

And let’s not forget that each member on the cast of Friends got paid one million dollars per episode in their last two seasons. And while HIMYM has grown in popularity, it was never climbed above no. 42 in its yearly ratings, whereas Friends was a top 10 show for its entire 10 year run. Friends certainly set the stage for HIMYM, and will always be respected for its longevity and ability to entertain despite how fickle audiences can be.

How I Met Your Mother has proven itself as worthy of not just being mentioned in the same breath as Friends, but of being legitimate competition. With the final series due to air soon, finally showing us how Ted meets the love of his life, it’s fair to say it has become its own, unique show.

HIMYM will return to E4 later this autumn.